Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

Reading through the first few years of the Los Angeles Free Press has already been very fruitful exercise! In addition to making (what I consider to be) a major breakthrough, I’ve started to find answers to some earlier questions too.

761px-TudorCageShiraz1971

David Tudor (left) and John Cage performing at the 1971 Shiraz Art Festival. (source)

In my post from November 6, I tried to track down the source for a story that Zappa often told about John Cage. He recalled attending a concert in which he witnessed Cage drinking carrot juice with a contact microphone attached to his throat:

A short time after that, John Cage came to Claremont College and he was giving one of his … he does these performances with a throat microphone. He’d put this thing on his throat and drink a quart of carrot juice, or read something to you while he was drinking the carrot juice. [1]

I determined that the piece in question was 0’00”–in which the performer is instructed to, “in a situation provided with maximum amplification (no feedback), perform a disciplined action”–and went on to suggest that Cage’s November 26 and 27, 1965 concerts at the Harper Theater in Hyde Park were the source of Zappa’s recollection. Cage gave a performance matching Zappa’s description there and, given that the score indicates that “no two performances [may] be of the same action,” I figured that this must be the source. (Curiously, after posting a query to silence, the John Cage mailing list, I received several responses that suggested Cage did the carrot juice thing on more than one occasion.)

As it turns out, I was incorrect.

In the January 29, 1965 issue of the Los Angeles Free Press, Michael Agnello reports on a concert Cage gave with David Tudor at the Pasadena Art Museum, now the Norton Simon Museum (click on the image to the right to read the whole article):

LAFP 2-5 p5It was a common swivel chair which the man (John Cage) sat on. Whenever he moved, I heard a grating sound of metal against metal. I then discovered that he had a contact microphone attached to the swivel of the chair (just as the microphone discovered the sounds contained in the knot which joins the two parts of the chair together). The man then strapped a similar type of microphone around his neck, and proceeded to cut carrots, apples and green peppers into pieces, using an amplified knife. As the knife penetrated, I noticed that there was a commotion resulting from the instrument breaking through the fibers of which these plants are composed. My eye saw and my ears heard and at one point I was moved to say to myself, “This is ridiculous, what possible purpose could there be to all this madness?” At that point a fellow named Snyder began to expound a variety of attempted witticisms; no, he was not intended to be part of the show—–and my eyes saw and my ears heard. After the man was finished cutting, he put each piece into the electric juicer. After each piece of carrot, green pepper and apple, he lowered a microphone down into the machine so we could witness at least the aural part of their metamorphosis. Altogether, it was a happy experience and it fittingly concluded with the sound of the juice passing through the man’s throat. [2]

The description matches Zappa’s perfectly. And given that this performance took place so close to where Zappa was living at the time, it seems the obvious source for Zappa’s story.

The article does not mention the specific date of the performance, only that it was at the Pasadena Art Museum. A quick search on ProQuest revealed the following confirmation:

LA Times - 'Experiments' in New Music to Be Heard - Jan 1, 1965 pSG8John Cage, one of the country’s new musical experimenters, will present three of his compositions at the Pasadena Art Museum in two performances, 7:30 and 9:30 p.m., Thursday, Jan 7.

This will be the second in a series of musical events presented by the museum in cooperation with the Coleman Chamber Music Assn. and the Pasadena Music Teachers Assn.

The series, called “Encounters,” is designed to bring together outstanding composers and performers and their listeners who seek to gain an insight into original works.

To encourage rapport between the performer and listeners, the setting is informal. The compser or performer will speak before his works will be played.

Cage’s works will include “Variations II,” “Zero Zero Zero,” and “Duet for Cymbals.” Pianist will be David Tudor. [3]

I can’t say for certain if Zappa actually attended the concert or simply read the Free Press review–he did, after all, remember the concert as having took place in Claremont–but I would be inclined to take his word for it and assume the former.

FURTHER UPDATE (December 11, 2009):

In trying to track down some more information about Cage’s performance, I took it upon myself to contact the Pasadena Art Museum (now the Norton Simon Museum). I promptly received a very helpful email from curatorial assistant Tom Norris confirming the date and the compositions performed. According to a PDF of the museum’s member newsletter and calendar, which Mr. Norris was kind enough to send me, Cage gave:

Two performances January 7, Thursday evening: 7:30 p.m. and 9:30 p.m. An encounters concert featuring the composer and David Tudor, pianist. Tickets $2.50, students $1.50.

Not a bad deal! The newsletter describes the program thusly:

Whenever contemporary experimental music is discussed, the name of John Cage is sure to be mentioned. The “prepared piano,” chance music, choice music, superimposition of different layers of sound, extension and modification of sound through mechanical media–these are all fields in which Mr. Cage has taken the lead. Even silence as an element of composition has been provocatively explored by this restlessly inventive composer.

Encounters will bring John Cage and David Tudor to the Pasadena Art Museum on Thursday, January 7th, for two performances at 7:30 and 9:30 p.m. The program will consist of Duet for Cymbal, Variations II and Zero’ Zero Zero”.

References:
[1] Den Simms, “An Evening With Pierre Boulez and Frank Zappa,” T’Mershi Duween 9 (October 1989). (Text here.)
[2] Michael Agnello, “John Cage at Pasadena,” Los Angeles Free Press 2.5 (January 29, 1965): 5. (Scan of article here.)
[3] “‘Experiments’ in New Music to Be Heard.” Los Angeles Times (1965, January 1): SG8. (Full text here.)
Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

4,522 thoughts on “Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

  1. vtracauto

    adidas predator accelerator cena billig air jordan 7 black pink shoes on sale adidas 18.1 speed mesh billig air jordan 3 negro and amarillo nike premier sg anti clog 3d steelers hoodie

  2. juddhoos

    yeezy boost 350 v2 neon green billig yeezy boost 350 v2 price edmonton nike womens classic cortez nylon chicago cubs 9 javier baez red long sleeve stitched baseball jersey adidas x 16.3 tf all black red billig nike air max 90 br mint green shoes on sal…

  3. salsamonde

    mercurial superfly 4 hyper punch 2016 billig texas rangers baylor hat zone nike magista onda ii ic white yellow uk nike kyrie irving 1 shoes ebay air jordan 7 grey and gold replica celtic shirt

  4. halemalu

    giroux stadium series jersey for cheap hvid herre nike tennis sko black new york yankees cap documentary air jordan 1 gold toe aj1 san francisco giants trapper hat furniture new air max 90

  5. youkits

    nike air flightposite racer blue billig nike hyperdunk 2015 low black green shoes jordan 9 red white blue for canada billig limited drew brees mens jersey new orleans saints 9 road white nfl kansas city royals game hat maps gray gold nike kobe venomeno…

  6. onlinebyran

    cooper kupp throwback jersey for cheap nike air max 90 hommes chaussures blanc noir orange cheap sunderland shirt for cheap air jordan future low joker women nike tennessee titans 56 akeem ayers elite light blue team color nfl jersey sale blue yankees…

  7. trailsnet

    hyper crimson 1 billig kobe 9 blue metallic billig adidas eqt support blue driver all gray nike kobe a.d uk shoes loom knit baby boy hats new drinks mennns nike shox oz svart

  8. spiderdm

    elite kevin vickerson womens jersey denver broncos 99 alternate navy blue nfl nike air perce bianca scarpe da ginnastica 2012 new nfl jerseys washington redskins 10 robert griffin iii yellow game jerseys with c patch nike air max guld salg nfl knit hat…

  9. marathonps

    blue and white 12s 2018 sidney crosby hoodie for cheap nike air more uptempo infrarosso 2017 all red nike hyperdunk 2012 billig adidas nmd uk all blue black and brown fake yeezys for sale shoes spain billig

  10. gonnect

    jordan retro 28 xx8 menn all svart nike air max thea black and green air max 90 flyknit nike magista onda jr movie ny yankees snapback cap for eu nike dunk high premium grau rot

  11. pionierzeit

    denver broncos 95 derek wolfe green mens stitched nfl limited salute to service jersey jordan 10 ovo white restock for cheap fc barcelona neon green jersey adidas barricade ii hvit kvinners sko adidas messi 10.1 indoor quotes all white yeezy trainer.ne…

  12. netlobo

    jordan 11 low baby blue billig jordan future low black gamma blue air jordan 3 11.5 adidas yeezy boost 750 pre order status nike free run 3 id womens nike magistax proximo tf pro direct mail billig

  13. madeonearth

    adidas yeezy boost 350 low voltage red nike air max 90 essential billig royal blue nike free 7.0 los angeles dodgers hats new era university nike shox navina si womens amazon 50 youth nike oakland raiders 61 stefen wisniewski elite white nfl jersey sal…

  14. gelbett

    air max 90 boots 2014 new york yankees cap retro zoning nike air jordan 1 prix jordan 88 retro billig nike lebron soldier 9 india tracking billig elite jordan cameron mens jersey miami dolphins 84 road white nfl

  15. fieldandfab

    michael jordan hats amazon for cheap black and green nike air huarache for sale shoes spain penguins 81 phil kessel black sawyer hooded sweatshirt 2016 stanley cup champions stitched nhl jersey adidas ace 17.3 in yellow red black billig all grey new ai…

  16. thevoliste

    nike air jordan 9 low billig air max 2017 mens all white gold uk billig nike air max 2018.5 all grey shoes billig mens nike air max 95 ultra billig nike lunarlon cole haan nike tiempo legend 6 soft ground

  17. bslatkin

    nike air huarache run premium outlet billig vinny curry 75 jersey nike mercurial superfly golden touch billig nike nfl philadelphia eagles 10 desean jackson limited women black alternate jersey sale san francisco giants hats for sale kansas city nike c…

  18. rowisoft

    adidas stan smith blanc copper mettoutic nike sale vapormax billig fc soccer uniforms for cheap new shirt juventus 2020 jd sports air force 1 utility billig nike air force 1 low 07 lv8 croc gum black

  19. wortvoll

    air jordan 12 blanc gris phillies pinstripe hat for sale nike vapor iii billig jordan 11 glitter black billig air jordan 11 sort legend blue oakland as hat ebay japan

  20. learnstar

    air max 90 grigio bianca nero ace 17.3 primemesh adidas tubular doom sock black trace olive pk 10 jordan bucket hat uk yahoo finance nike flyknit grau mango cheap all gray air jordan hydro 2017

  21. lapanse

    jordan retro 28 xx8 menn all svart nike air max thea black and green air max 90 flyknit nike magista onda jr movie ny yankees snapback cap for eu nike dunk high premium grau rot

  22. potagic

    nike hypervenom phelon weight you janoski black camo billig the hundreds hats for sale houston mercurial superfly cr7 box nike kobe 6 alle sort wholesale jordan 7 black and grey

  23. stewardism

    nike lady cortez noir trainers jordan spizike black and gray for cheap nike city loop gold pink shoes billig nike free 5.0 tr fit black and red air force 1 low black friday for cheap billig jordan 1 black and pink for cheap

  24. cironajle

    san francisco giants caps wholesale furniture yeezy 700 black 2019 billig oregon football uniforms 2018 for cheap nike hypervenom phelon 3 review vancouver billig air force 1 mid white ebay billig adidas nmd r1 damen white

  25. rehema

    nike kobe 8 black shoes for sale billig kobe bryant shoes cheap black white and gold shoes billig chargers gold jersey for cheap nike lebron soldier 9 le live nike mercurial superfly gelb gold billig dunk sb panda billig

  26. chumbabikes

    nike tanjun racer mens sapphire green shoes nike metcon dsx flyknit 2 men nike free 3.0 v3 green gelb nike roshe gull metallic adidas eqt support 2.0 usb jordan retro 4 rosa and schwarz

  27. freedomrvwi

    white blue black nike free 5.0 v6 mens shoes uniqlo gilet womens game evan mathis womens jersey denver broncos 69 home orange nfl adidas nmd runner blue black shoes billig port authority l500 womens shoes 5.5

  28. efthimiades

    cheap all white nike superflyx 6 kids billig nike kaishi run black white gold shoes on sale women air jordan 11 black grey shoes on sale billig new balance 3090 mens all white red billig nike magista onda size 1 note billig jordan 4 negro premium

  29. corsicactus

    nike dunks white low billig nike air max tn white black orange new balance 574 blanc and gris salute to service steelers cap for cheap nike air max 87 men black and grey billig san diego padres caps new era girlfriend

  30. coolrvpro

    aj4 hot lava adidas magnetic storm all red shoes on sale billig realtree san francisco giants hat liners 07 san francisco giants opening day hats womens nike cortez barn 21 game thomas decoud carolina panthers womens jersey nfl home black

  31. cakesvb

    cheap all white nike superflyx 6 kids billig nike kaishi run black white gold shoes on sale women air jordan 11 black grey shoes on sale billig new balance 3090 mens all white red billig nike magista onda size 1 note billig jordan 4 negro premium

  32. surfmorocco

    michael jordan new shoes nike dunk high j pack rot under armor thermal long sleeve golden state warriors 23 draymond green revolution 30 swingman 2014 new white short sleeved jersey black red white lebron e.e uk shoes green crop top long sleeve

  33. leochappaz

    psg air jordan mbappe bruins baseball jersey for cheap shoes nike mercurialx finale ii blue black shoes australia adidas x 15.1 tf gray yellow billig ralph big pony washington nationals green hat zions

  34. mcarta

    blue graphic crop top mens minnesota twins 25 byron buxton green salute to service jersey mercurial superfly yankees ltd billig huk tide point short sleeve shirt adidas ultra boost 11 black billig stores that sell womens jordans billig

  35. estiahalkis

    air max 2016 womens all white red billig texas rangers hats wholesale australia atl nmd billig nike cortez noir vintage nike kevin durant 9 cheap black and blue shoes billig rustler classic mens regular 5 pocket jean

  36. chapacms

    nike park derby ii long sleeve shirt adidas nmd nero primeknit adidas yeezy boost 350 hong kong price gold billig new balance 501 mens all red uk billig nike city loop gold pink shoes billig womens air jordan 11 retro blue black shoes canada

  37. malatyarent

    air max 2016 womens all white red billig texas rangers hats wholesale australia atl nmd billig nike cortez noir vintage nike kevin durant 9 cheap black and blue shoes billig rustler classic mens regular 5 pocket jean

  38. mvaesthetic

    adidas nmd holi billig nike soccer winter jacket for cheap green black nike flyknit air max women for uk nike air pource 1 high blanc vivid orange all white 2017 latest air max 90 uk shoes billig nike air max 90 air yeezy 2 solar red

  39. selectakaza

    nike presto extreme white and black billig adidas predator 18.4 fg black blue brown nike kobe 10 youtube online billig womens air huarache city move sneaker billig nike air huarache white high washington nationals hat with redskins colors zodiac

  40. marianbader

    2019 jordans 11 billig royal blue camo yeezy adidas yeezy boost 350 india ltd billig nike roshe run black friday for cheap billig all brown nike free 5.0 v3 mens shoes silver black nike magista obra 2 shoes billig

  41. swiftliftmd

    san francisco giants caps wholesale furniture yeezy 700 black 2019 billig oregon football uniforms 2018 for cheap nike hypervenom phelon 3 review vancouver billig air force 1 mid white ebay billig adidas nmd r1 damen white

  42. ensasailor

    cheap all white nike superflyx 6 kids billig nike kaishi run black white gold shoes on sale women air jordan 11 black grey shoes on sale billig new balance 3090 mens all white red billig nike magista onda size 1 note billig jordan 4 negro premium

  43. holzsiegel

    red black blue air jordan 6 for uk jordan trainer 2 flyknit nero black and green yeezy 350 cheap black and brown air jordan 11 women new balance 574 blanc and gris realtree san francisco giants hat list

  44. saveorpave

    air max 95 sale womens billig nike air force black high tops for cheap billig nike kobe 9 elite nba 2k14 editor billig bayern home shirt nike magista opus poison green card billig jordan 4 blanc and bleu

  45. markderry

    nike kobe ad womens all red grey uk nike sb black mint for cheap billig toddler football kits sale 2012 new nfl jerseys san diego chargers 24 ryan mathews white jerseys limited nike kd trey 6 all grey shoes canada billig lebron 11 graffiti nike id bill…

  46. midiparts

    grey red black adidas crazy byw boost uk shoes elite marc mariani womens jersey tennessee titans 83 home light blue nfl nike flyknit max black white yellow shoes air jordan son of mars low white rot nike sacai blazer snow beach billig nba jerseys new y…

  47. ganenkou

    air jordan choose your flight billig white fitted boston red sox hat cecil air jordan 5 fire rojo 2012 adidas yeezy boost 750 mercadolibre le air jordan 10 hvid blue adidas crazy train boost shoes review paper

  48. bocksberg

    air max mens grey billig nike cortez burgundy tampa bay rays jeremy hellickson 58 white replica jersey sale jordan cp3.7 white black blue air jordan 1 black white gs nike magista opus 12.5 inch

  49. longhornsup

    atletico madrid 2020 away kit new balance ml574 classic billig black mens canada goose gilet adidas eqt cushion adv north america korea billig nike air pource 1 high bleu and blanc beckham accelerator billig

Comments are closed.