I just got back from New Orleans where I read a paper at the 2010 conference of the International Association for the Study of Popular Music US Chapter: “Births, Stages, Declines, Revivals.” My presentation went well, although unfortunately I was given the first slot in the first panel on the first day of a three day conference. (8:30 AM on Friday morning!) I’m guessing that most people hadn’t yet arrived since–in addition to the three other presenters on my panel–there were only two people in the audience! Oh well.
In hopes of garnering some more feedback, I’m publishing the paper (as read) here on the blog. As usual, this remains a work in progress.
Click here to download a PDF version of the paper. (Slides and visual examples appear at the end of the PDF.) Or, follow the jump to read the html version.
Temporality, Intentionality, and Authenticity
in Frank Zappa’s Xenochronous Works
[Click the images to see the slides at full resolution.]
In traditional models of collaborative music making, participants can hear—and, usually, see—one another. Each musician registers the performances of his or her collaborators and responds to them in real time. Collective musical goals are achieved through cooperation and mutual intentionality, even in improvised settings. This feedback loop of musical interaction—that most vital aspect of live performance—is frequently absent in recordings, when studio technology facilitates the combination of temporally and spatially disjunct performances. Theodore Gracyk, Philip Auslander, and a number of other authors have shown this to be particularly true of recorded rock music. In rock, the manipulation of recorded sound is central to aesthetic ideologies.
Lee B. Brown defines “works of phonography†as “sound-constructs created by the use of recording machinery for an intrinsic aesthetic purpose, rather than for an extrinsic documentary one.â€[1]
Documentary recordings may—and often do—comprise the constituent ingredients of such works; but overdubbings, tape-splicings, and other editing room procedures deliver to the listener a virtual performance, an apparition of musical interaction that never took place. Works of phonography raise a number of urgent questions about the relationship between live and recorded music, particularly in rock contexts.
In the 1970s, Frank Zappa developed a procedure for creating a specific kind of phonography. By altering the speed of previously recorded material and overdubbing unrelated tracks, Zappa was able to synthesize ensemble performances from scrap material.
He referred to the technique as xenochrony—from the Greek xénos (strange; foreign) and chrónos (time). Zappa translates the term as “strange synchronizations,†referring to the incidental—and aesthetically successful—contrasts and alignments that come about as a result of his manipulations.
Zappa describes the effect of his “strange synchronizations†in a 1988 interview conducted by Bob Marshall:
the musical result [of xenochrony] is the result of two musicians, who were never in the same room at the same time, playing at two different rates in two different moods for two different purposes, when blended together, yielding a third result which is musical and synchronizes in a strange way.[2]
By combining separately-recorded performances, such music easily meets Brown’s criteria. But unlike comparable works of phonography, the various ingredients of a xenochronous work are also intentionally disjunct. Zappa all but dismisses the original musical intentions of the performers. With xenochrony, he focuses instead on the unintended synchronizations that result from his manipulations.
In many cases, rock artists and producers mask their methods. Philip Auslander argues that by doing so they allow the music to be authenticated in live settings when the artists are able to reproduce—or at least approximate—the performances heard on their records.[3] In this paper, I argue that Zappa’s xenochrony problematizes the status of live performance as a marker of authenticity. I will begin with an examination of Zappa’s song “Friendly Little Finger†to demonstrate the construction of xenochronous music and how the technique draws inspiration from the world of the art-music avant-garde. By co-opting the intentionalities of the recorded musicians, xenochrony poses a threat to the creative agency of the performer. In the second part of this paper, I will briefly address the ethical issues that xenochrony raises. Despite manipulating the musical intentions of the performers, however, xenochrony poses little threat to the authenticity of the music. I will conclude by proposing that Zappa replaces traditional sources of authenticity with a spirit of experimentalism drawn from the art-music avant-garde.
I. Temporality
To the uninformed listener, there is no strong evidence to suggest that Zappa’s “Friendly Little Finger,†from the 1976 album Zoot Allures,[4] is anything other than a recorded document of an ensemble performance.
The piece begins with a brief introduction featuring a repeated riff performed on guitar, marimba, and synthesizer. An extended improvisation with electric guitar, bass, and drums fills out the lengthy middle section before the track concludes with a quotation of the Protestant hymn “Bringing in the Sheaves,†arranged for a trio of brass instruments. Despite its apparent normalcy, however, “Friendly Little Finger†combines materials from four distinct sources spanning three years of Zappa’s career.
The primary recording—a guitar solo with a droning bass accompaniment—was recorded in the dressing room of the Hofstra University Playhouse as a warm-up before a performance on October 26, 1975. Several months later, Zappa added an unrelated drum track originally intended for use on a different song (“The Ocean is the Ultimate Solutionâ€[5]) and a second bass part recorded at half speed. These three recordings, all appearing in the middle solo section, comprise the xenochronous core of the piece. To this, Zappa superimposed two additional recordings. The introduction comes from the same session as the added bass part, and the coda was recorded several years earlier, during a session for the song “Wonderful Wino.”
As Example 1 makes clear, the result of Zappa’s editing is a moderately dense network of temporally disjunct recordings. How is it that such seemingly disparate recordings happened to come together in this way? What inspired Zappa to take such an approach to manipulating recorded sound? Of course, examples of overdubbing in American popular music can be found at least as far back as the 1940s—recall Sidney Bechet’s One Man Band recordings in which each instrument was performed separately by Bechet himself. But while such tricks had become old hat by the mid 1970s, xenochrony stands out for it also has obvious ties to the twentieth-century art-music avant-garde.
Despite his continuing reputation as a popular musician, Zappa was remarkably well read in the theoretical discourse surrounding avant-garde art music, particularly with regards to musique concrète and tape music. He expressed an ongoing interest in John Cage’s chance operations, for example, trying them out for himself by physically cutting recorded tapes and rearranging the pieces at random for the 1968 album Lumpy Gravy.[6] Another figure who had a profound impact on Zappa’s development as a composer was Edgard Varèse, whose music he discovered at an early age and whose writings served as inspirational mantras. Given this fascination with the avant-garde, xenochrony may be best understood as a conscious attempt by Zappa to model himself on these influential figures. His own approach to music and composition would therefore require an analogous theoretical foundation.
Xenochrony is closely tied to Zappa’s conception of temporality. Zappa often described time as a simultaneity, with all events occurring at once instead of chronologically. Toward the end of his life, in an oft-quoted conversation with cartoonist Matt Groening, Zappa explained that the idea was rooted in physics:
I think of time as a spherical constant, which means that everything is happening all the time. […] They [human beings] take a linear approach to it, slice it in segments, and then hop from segment to segment to segment until they die, and to me that is a pretty inefficient way of preparing a mechanical ground base for physics. That’s one of the reasons why I think physics doesn’t work. When you have contradictory things in physics, one of the reasons they became contradictory is because the formulas are tied to a concept of time that isn’t the proper model.[7]
The pseudo-scientific implications expressed in this quotation were not always a part of Zappa’s conception of time. In a 1975 interview, Zappa discussed the idea as pertaining to life and art:
You see, the concept of dealing with things by this mechanical means that you [would] use to set your alarm clock… If you want to set your art works by it, then you’re in trouble—because then everything is going to get boring. So I’m working on a different type of a time scale.[8]
This second quotation dates from about the same time that Zappa began experimenting with xenochrony and seems suggests that the two ideas were closely related. Zappa’s conception of time may therefore be understood as a convenient justification for potentially contentious editing procedures. Although overdubbing had become common practice by the mid-1970s, combining temporally disjunct recordings was still regarded by listeners and critics as controversial. By reconfiguring the very concept of time, Zappa skirts the issue.
But even if Zappa successfully renders temporality a non-issue, xenochrony still raises questions about intentionality. Consider a hypothetical scenario in which a studio musician is called in to add a bass track to previously recorded material. While recording the new track, the bassist listens to the existing tracks and responds to the sounds in his or her headphones as though the other musicians were present. (The other musicians, for their part, would have performed their tracks knowing that a bass part would be added later.) Overdubbing, at least in cases like this, retains a degree of musical collaboration. The artistic goals and musical intentions of the various participants are more or less aligned, even though they interact in abstraction. Xenochrony, however, dispenses with intentionality altogether. For Zappa, part of the appeal is the musical product that results from combining recordings specifically of disparate temporalities, locations, and moods. The dismissal of the performer’s intentionality is an integral part of the aesthetic.
II. Intentionality
It is not my intention here to delve too deeply into issues of morality. Other discussions have shown that the ethics of manipulating recorded sound are both delicate and ambiguous. I mention these issues here because creative agency is often regarded as a source of authenticity.
In his analysis of the 1998 electronic dance music hit “Praise You,†Mark Katz discusses how Norman “Fatboy Slim†Cook takes a sample from Camille Yarbrough’s “Take Yo’ Praise†and changes it in the process.[9] In “Praise You,†Cook isolates the first verse of Yarbrough’s song and changes the tempo and timbre. Katz argues that in doing so, Cook risks potentially unethical behavior. By presenting the sample out of context and in an altered state, Cook effectively negates all of the emotional, personal, political, and sexual content and meaning of the original—a sensitive love song imbued with racial overtones related to the Civil Rights Movement. Cook therefore presents a threat to Yarbrough’s artistic agency. Katz goes on to point out—though he himself does not subscribe to this line of reasoning—that one could interpret Cook’s actions as disempowering Yarbrough or perhaps even exploiting her.
Zappa takes similar risks with xenochrony. Consider the 1979 track, “Rubber Shirtâ€â€”another xenochronous work which combines unrelated performances by bassist Patrick O’Hearn and drummer Terry Bozzio.
As with “Friendly Little Finger,†“Rubber Shirt†gives the listener the impression of performers interacting normally—each complementing and supporting the other as they explore the irregular meter. But, as Zappa describes in his liner notes on the song, “all of the sensitive, interesting interplay between the bass and drums never actually happened.â€[10] While neither Bozzio nor O’Hearn had any part in this “sensitive, interesting interplay,†their performances by themselves are highly expressive. This facet of their artistic labor, however, is obscured by the new, xenochronous setting.
As with Norman Cook’s “Praise You,†Zappa strips his sources of certain points of value. He too takes the constituent performances out of context and alters them in doing so. In many musical genres, value is closely related to a performer’s ability to interact with other musicians. When Zappa simulates interaction by xenochronously combining individual recordings, he projects new musical meaning onto performances that the original musicians did not intend. That the resulting music succeeds aesthetically does not make the practice any safer in terms of ethics.
Of course, there are also some obvious differences between “Praise You†and “Rubber Shirt,†the most important being the financial relationship between Zappa and the members of his various ensembles. O’Hearn and Bozzio were paid employees, hired to perform Zappa’s music. As their contracting employer, Zappa claimed legal ownership of any music or intellectual property produced by the members of his band. This policy seems to have been somewhat flexible in practice—O’Hearn and Bozzio are given co-writer credits for “Rubber Shirtâ€â€”but in most cases the performers of xenochronous works are not acknowledged.
Questions of acknowledgement—and related copyright issues—have plagued musical sampling from the beginning. But again, xenochrony complicates the issue. Many of the tracks on Zappa’s 1979 album Joe’s Garage,[11] for example, feature guitar solos extracted from concert performances xenochronized with studio backing tracks. All of the audible musicians are credited in the liner notes. But what of the musicians that aren’t audible? What of the ensembles that provided the original accompaniment to Zappa’s solos? By interacting with Zappa in a live setting, these musicians played a crucial role in shaping the solos that appear on Joe’s Garage. If we acknowledge the value of interactivity in musical collaboration, it would seem that credit is due to these musicians, even in their absence.
III. Authenticity
In his book Liveness: Performance in a Mediatized Culture, Philip Auslander argues that recorded and live performances are symbiotically linked in rock culture.[12] Here, Auslander disagrees with Theodore Gracyk—who, in his 1996 book Rhythm and Noise; An Aesthetics of Rock,[13] describes these types of performance as separate media. Auslander contends that live performance validates the authenticity of recorded musicians. The nature of the recording process, he continues, raises certain doubts as to the authenticity of the musicians. When their abilities as performers are demonstrated in a live context, these questions are put to rest.[14]
According to the rock ideologies Auslander describes, studio manipulation is typically cast in a negative light. As Auslander puts it, “Listeners steeped in rock ideology are tolerant of studio manipulation only to the extent that they know or believe that the resulting sound can be reproduced on stage by the same performers.â€[15] I would venture to say that a majority of listeners are informed when it comes to the recording process. Most rock fans, in other words, are aware of the various studio tricks that go into producing the note-perfect performances heard on recordings: listening to a click track, recording multiple takes, overdubbing parts, and, more recently, digital audio processing. Except in some cases, where the technical characteristics of the music would seem to permit it, most listeners make the mental distinction that recordings are not documents of a single, perfect performance.
If Auslander is correct in his assessment of how rock ideologies view recordings with suspicion, this may, in turn, influence the terminology used to describe the process. Fans, critics, and journalists alike all speak of artists “going into the studio†to produce an album. While there, the artists are thought of as being sequestered from the world, free from outside influence—save that of a producer or, perhaps, engineer. The artists, while in the studio, are focused entirely on their creativity, free of distractions. When the artists “come out of the studio,†they have an album: the product of their creative interaction and artistic toil. Such discourse paints the studio process as having a certain purity.
Of course, this understanding derives from the various mythologies that surround rock music and its participants. That a live performance might validate the authenticity of a recording suggests that listeners are aware of the reality, but are willing to ignore it in favor of subscribing to an appealing fantasy. In Zappa’s case, however, these processes are intentionally integrated. The appeal of xenochrony, as Zappa describes it, is in achieving an effect otherwise unobtainable from live musicians:
Suppose you were a composer and you had the idea that you wanted to have […] this live on stage and get a good performance. You won’t get it. You can’t. You can ask for it, but it won’t happen. There’s only one way to hear that, and that’s to do what I did. I put two pieces of tape together.[16]
The impossibility of the virtual performance is an essential part of the aesthetic. Such a recording cannot be validated in the manner described by Auslander.
Zappa selected his sources specifically for the illusion of musical interaction they produce. Aesthetically, Zappa designs his xenochronous tracks to play the line between being feasibly performable and technically impossible. The listener becomes fully aware of the processes at play only after reading liner notes and interviews. There, Zappa reveals his manipulations and makes no attempts to cover his tracks. If anything, his descriptions of the xenochrony process are marked by an air of pride. Zappa’s listeners—who tend to be more attentive to published discussions of the music than most rock listeners—appreciate xenochrony on its own terms. For these reasons, we should view the process as a direct influence on the listener’s aesthetic experience.
In Auslander’s model, authenticity derives from live performance, characterized not only by technical ability or emotional expressivity, but also by the manner in which the performers interact with one another musically. Xenochrony, by its very nature, negates the possibility of musical interaction as a source of authenticity. Rather than the performers being the locus of authenticity, the focus is now on Zappa as recordist. Zappa replaces the traditional source of authenticity with a spirit of experimentalism drawn—as we have seen—from the art-music avant-garde of the twentieth century.
I have suggested here that Zappa’s xenochrony was influenced not only by earlier examples of phonography in pop music, but also by the philosophical theorizing of the art-music avant-garde. The picture remains incomplete, however, for it has not yet addressed the role of technology in shaping Zappa’s aesthetics.
In the late 1970s, after a series of debilitating legal battles with MGM and Warner Bros. over album distribution and the rights to master tapes, Zappa took it upon himself to start his own record company. Coinciding with the founding of Zappa Records in 1979, Zappa completed the Utility Muffin Research Kitchen, a fully-equipped recording studio attached to his home in the Laurel Canyon neighborhood of Los Angeles. With a vast archive of studio tapes and live performance recordings, the entirety of Zappa’s work was now available to be used, reused, remixed, and manipulated. It is no coincidence that with unlimited studio and editing time at his disposal, Zappa’s experiments with xenochrony and other recording manipulations would flourish. Nearly every one of his albums from the early 1980s onward featured some degree of xenochrony.
Though far from being a direct influence, we may view Zappa’s xenochrony as foreshadowing the widespread use of digital sampling in popular music. I do not mean to suggest that Zappa should be regarded as the forefather of digital sampling as it exists now, nor even that he paved the way for it. But I do see a provocative parallel. Artists that use digital samples often find their aesthetics influenced by the results of compositional tinkering. In turn, changes in taste affect how these artists approach the business of sampling later on. I see a similar relationship between Zappa and xenochrony. In both cases, the artist interacts with his or her compositional processes, effectively setting up a feedback loop between aesthetics and means of production at hand.
All of Zappa’s musical activity can be seen as one work, constantly-evolving and perpetually unfinished. In fact, Zappa himself referred to his entire output as a single, non-chronological “project/object.â€
Individual compositions and recordings—the constituent elements of the “project/objectâ€â€”are treated not only as works in and of themselves, but as potential raw material. Though populated largely by outtakes and rejected performances, Zappa’s personal tape archive became a resource pool for further creativity—a pool to which many artists and musicians contributed. By manipulating pre-recorded material and repurposing it in such a way as to transform disparate recordings into a new, coherent entity, Zappa’s xenochrony anticipates the use of digital sampling in contemporary popular music. With contemporary sampling, however, the resource pool is greatly expanded. Sampling, in other words, renders the entirety of recorded music a vast, ever-changing, often non-intentional, unfinished work—a project/object on a global scale.
mens accessories inside wallet with contrast suede new series sale wallets by ted baker black
adidas adilette cloudfoam plus slides sandals womens greychina flip flop mx ef 008 is supplied by flip flop manufacturerschelsea crew babel black womans sandals shoeswomens reebok sneakers running shoes
Jack & Jones Jack & Jones Uomo Felpa con cappuccio jorAuthentic in grigio 70% poliestere 30% cotone 12127801LGRYM HSQVYWF
ALEXANDRE BIRMAN Stivaletti Cammello pelle calzata ridotta punta tonda tinta unita 11517150UB
adidas porsche design bounce all silver shoes sale australia online
huarache drift gs wolf grey nike 943344 003nike ao3172 002 huarache city move womens lifestyle shoe blacknike air max thea ultra flyknit trainers blue nike air max trainersshop black jordan super.fly 2017 shoe for mens by jordan 5
mal谩 ko啪en谩 tmav臎 膷erven谩 kabelka
cos roll neck merino jumper in blue lystpolo tech hat. soldprv谩 trieda nie v啪dy 木ahko aing. 木ubica textil
zapatos marypaz en manzanares rebajas junio
primavera verano air mesh transpirable ni帽o zapatillas luz boy girl zapatillas zapatos para ni帽ozapatos nike para hombre casualesventa en l铆nea adidas tenis adidas rim reaper 2015 zapatos para hombreprimavera verano britè°©nico punta estrecha hombre jove…
rylee cru endless summer tee spearmint ventures
vintage 1950s inspired showgirl fringe black playsuit romperalisa pan womens fit and flare short simple summer dress 5504 at amazon womens clothing storenew stylish sexy plunge v neck long sleeve plain jumpsuits with swallow tailed hemcotton wood butto…
long sleeve yellow floral dress
floral dress women bodycon floral print dresses amazon oasis black and white floral shift dress ladies floral maxi dresses eliza j sleeveless floral fit and flare dress diesel floral jersey dress
surplice long sleeves leopard print dress leopard s
beach themed wedding dressessilk swimwear wholesalewears a gold metallic new years eve outfit idea perfect for the city or the beach with sequin shortswomen girl sexy bad girl printing swimsuit bodysuit beachwear swimwear bathing suit
abiti da sera a sirena a maniche lunghe abiti in tulle con scollo a balze dietro il collo prom dresses
çº¬è €è°“ä¼ªå–‚é蔚委伪 èŸ»æ…°è ‰è ‚ä¼ª è 慰蟻苇æ¸ä¼ªèŸ¿ä¼ª é伪胃ç•æ¸è”šèŸ»å–‚è°“ç»´ lx æ¸å§”è°“å–‚ 蟺ä½è”šéèŸ¿è ˆæ¸å–‚é蟻维 é伪喂 蟺伪ä½ä¼ªå–‚ç»´ 伪é委谓ç•èŸ¿ä¼ª 蟺蟻慰蟿喂æ¸æ…°è ‰è°“ æ…°å–‚ 伪纬慰蟻伪蟽蟿苇蟼伪胃ä½ç•èŸ¿å–‚é伪 伪æ¸ä¼ªè°“å–‚é伪 æ¸èŸºä½æ…°è €å‘³ä¼ªé喂伪 sc伪谓未蟻喂éç»´ èŸ»æ…°è ‰è ‚ä¼ª home
paris saint germain 1 buffon red goalkeeper long sleeves soccer club jersey
chanel handbags chanel white vintage fringe crossbodygucci sherry line gg shoulder bag 24michael kors mk grayson satchel and crossbody brown pvc with leatherlesportsac taylor zip around wallet
3 4 sleeve jackie jumpsuit the jackie o
the best shoes for beach weddingskylie jenner in shorts out for lunch in malibu 06 10 2016 hawtcelebsversace spring summer 2018 ready to wear show reportdesigner shirts floral designer shirts manufacturer from mumbai
fatheadz eyewear fatheadz mens aim xl prescription eyeglasses
fæ°“ lasse er en brille abe af marie hansen som bog pæ°“ dansknba x nike benassi solarsoft slide 2 sandals black white red slides 917551 005sort græ°“ flad hå¿™l kvinders sko mary jane spids tæ°“belstaff classic tourist trophy antique brown
crochet 5 star beanies for toddlers kids
womens mens classic white low expenditure unisex lacoste the crocodile embroiderygrey marled beanie hi resbuy under armour men hats caps online zalora malaysiascala hats raffia pork pie from village hats
Superdry ORANGE LABEL – JERSEY – GRIS JASPEADO Corte recto lifestyle Cuello redondo 2398486
hair clips
reebok zoku runner ultraknit shoes mens power red techy red m285616 men reebok shoes online shop
buzo nike sb ropa y accesorios negro en mercado libre argentinazapatillas vans old skool negra urbana ni帽o eezapzapatos negros para dama en plataforma para mujer dama moda. cargando zoomzapatos seguridad electricista
nwt redhead stalker super lite cargo pants mens 2xl camouflage new breakup hunt redhead cargo
d谩mske 拧aty adidas performance parley dress foto 0boreal p谩nsk茅 joker lace obuv modr媒sportisimo let谩k akciov茅 let谩ky a newslettredetsk茅 n谩radie 15 dielne
ladies bags with price
canada goose mens canada goose expedition parka xs size us xs eu 42 0bleu rod beattie womens plus size v neck one piece swimsuitsplurge chantel miami beach 205 beach bunny stripe renegade wrap bikinilyon sporty top trendy swimsuit w 2 bottom option in…
becca color play crochet tie front one piece swimsuit women swimsuit
nike mercurial tn orange white blackshop nike new purple womens size 3x plus chalkdust printed tempo shorts free shipping on orders over 45 overstockmens soccer cleats shoes nike mercurial superfly vi 360 elite neymarcheap gold under armour cleats buy…
women keds x kate spade new york champion glitter collaborations
glam t bar sandals multicolor black for women flip flopspectacular sales for womens ted baker london gilleen bow skaternike womens reax run 5 running shoesflip flops with bow ted baker flop in cream black a soft mini melissa . flip flops
tacocat spelled backwards is tacocat tacos cat shirt tank top
kay jewelers jewelry 10k white yellow gold diamond promise ringnomination jewellery 1001zia double leather leaf earrings gold on black boutique wihot sale swarovski crystal olive aqua blue crystal earrings
givenchy obsedia the handbag concept
baseball bands ruined my lifecartier love 18k white gold 0.04 ct diamond bracelet size 17a.s roma cap worn a few times message if have any questions depopwholesale straw hat supplier dynamic asia
zapatilla beb茅 classics reebok royal prime alt negro reebok
tornister szkolny my little friend pieseksanda艂y teva ms winsted sklep turystycznycena od producenta pozosta艂a galanteria torebka wizytowa carlaadidas performance bp power ii plecak black white zalando czarny fitness
coturno branco feminino
2016 adidas shoes adidas ultra boost uncaged triple whitey 3 qasa high sneakers 275 shop aw18 online fast deliveryadidas swift burgundy. uk size 10. worn once in perfect depopnordstrom to partner with sneaker marketplace stadium goods at its stand alon…
asics gel upcourt 3 hvid sort
new look black block mid heel shoes with a closed toe. worn depopchristian louboutin viva 85 suede pumpsdenim peep toe heel cut out rear lace up boot wholesale fashion shoessummerwhisper womens elegant faux suede bowknot pointed toe bridal booties back…
pulseras de vinilo estrecho 1 color especial eventos largos
champagne lace spaghetti strap backless mermaid gown with tiered skirt skusummer shopping special free people floral haze printed mini slipladies fashion red christmas dress black women party dresses bow neck dress amazon.co.uk clothingbaby girl red sl…
adidas duramo slide chanclas hombres azul blanco compra online power blue white power blue
褕泻芯谢褜薪褘械 泻谢邪褋褋懈褔械褋泻懈械 褕褌邪薪褘 懈 褋èƒæ‡ˆè¤Œæ¢°è¤‰discount nike air presto 泻褉芯褋褋芯èƒæ³»æ‡ˆ 褋 屑械è¤èŠ¯å±‘ 薪芯èƒè¤˜æ³„ brown 斜械谢褘泄 online shop褋锌芯褉褌懈èƒè–ªè¤˜æ³„ 泻芯褋褌褞屑 nike dri fitæ–œè¤è¤‹è¤˜ èƒèŠ¯èŸ¹å†™è¤è¤•è–ªè¤˜æ¢° 懈蟹 斜懈褋械褉邪 svitstyle
斜芯谢褜褕懈械 薪邪褉è¤è¤”薪褘械 褔邪褋褘 屑芯å¸è–ªèŠ¯ 蟹写械褋褜 æ³»è¤é”Œæ‡ˆè¤Œè¤œ 褋 写芯褋褌邪èƒæ³»èŠ¯æ³„ èƒ è°¢è¤žæ–œèŠ¯æ³„ è°èŠ¯è¤‰èŠ¯å†™
屑è¤å¸è¤‹æ³»æ‡ˆæ¢° 褌芯谢褋褌芯èƒæ³»æ‡ˆ dsquared2 èƒ è¤‹é‚ªè–ªæ³»è¤Œ 锌械褌械褉斜è¤è¤‰è°æ¢° æ³»è¤é”Œæ‡ˆè¤Œè¤œ 褌芯谢褋褌芯èƒæ³»è¤ èƒæ–œè¤è¤Œè¤‹è¤˜ 写械褌褋泻懈械 nike hypervenom phantom 3 academy fg jr 褋械褉褘泄 芯褉邪薪å¸æ¢°èƒè¤˜æ³„褔褢褉薪邪褟 å¸æ¢°è–ªè¤‹æ³»é‚ªè¤Ÿ 褋锌芯褉褌懈èƒè–ªé‚ªè¤Ÿ 褋è¤å±‘泻邪 nike 019 c72 medium è°å†™æ¢°è¤”械褉薪褘泄 褋锌芯褉褌懈èƒè–ªè¤˜æ³„ 泻芯褋褌褞屑 薪邪泄泻
oakley radarlock white sunglass prizm infield oo9181 33 sportique
special bra for honeymoonhanro moments built up tanksexy fashion brunette woman with long dark hair in blue lingeriepopular external hard drive case buy cheap external hard drive case lots from china external hard drive case suppliers on
panache womens tango classic underwire plunge bra
贸culos de grau ray ban rb6345 2732 r 458arma莽茫o retro redonda oval slim armacao de metal feminina m r 31arquivos prada baroque barroco ornate collection prada baroquethe sonic 2 revo
Teddy Smith SCOTT – Denim shorts raven kaki Normal Button-fly Denim Back pocket side pockets 91% cotton 7% polyester 2% elastane TS122F00U-N11 QJPQCMB
VALENTINO Vestito longuette Nero crêpe modello a tubino senza tasche collo tondo 34867076BB
new deals on eyelash sheer lace bra top
spandex bridal feminine sleepwear sets lingerie jjshelmut lang womens skirts shortsadjustable dumbbells deluxe 45 pounds dumbbelllesbian sluts masturbate finger each other in nylons suspenders panties
hot sales original cristiano ronaldo mercurial superfly v fg cr7 football boots golden soccer shoes mens
michael kors lena handbag selma satchel amazon marwoodgucci gg supreme and kingsnake print bi fold wallet mensgray prada grey leather pochette shoulder bag w enamel push lock for saleprada handbags 2014 prada logo printed medium canvas denim tote bags
les ventes sur le march茅 air jordan homme 2016 nike noir rouge gris 30 xxx basketball chaussure brillant
camisa adidas nem me viu no mercado livre brasilchuteira do neymar de ouro masculino nike chuteiras no mercadot锚nis puma hybrid runner cinza femininofutsal boot nike mercurialx vortex iii ic neymar blue orbit white
women summer sexy suspenders strap backless dress with brassiere chest pad vestidos de fiesta bandage dress femme solid color
24 nice cheap plus size wedding dresses under 50 cheap plus size wedding dresses undersexy lace bralette spandex thin embroidery push up bra full cup wireless bras for women blackplus size smocked cami2019 leopard print plus size asymmetric t shirt
cvceurope
floral dresses revolve clothing long floral dress women floral dresses for wedding guests eliza j maxi floral dress very oasis floral dress womens blue floral dresses from china
oculos rayban espelhado amarelo masculino è´¸culos no mercado livre
converse all star girls 8 baby toddler high top sneakers pink blackdisney x vans snag backpackbrooks launch 4 cushioning. if you compare the launch 4converse all star glitter high top sneaker baby
褋褉芯褔薪邪褟 褉邪褋锌褉芯写邪å¸é‚ª æ³»è¤è¤‰è¤Œæ³»é‚ª 锌邪褉泻邪 锌è¤è¤èŠ¯èƒæ‡ˆæ³» 芯褉懈è°æ‡ˆè–ªé‚ªè°¢ 写谢懈薪薪邪褟 褉邪蟹屑械褉 46 481 褎芯褌芯
蟹懈屑薪褟褟 æ³»è¤è¤‰è¤Œæ³»é‚ª nike 250 è°è¤‰è–ª. 屑è¤å¸è¤‹æ³»é‚ªè¤Ÿ 芯写械å¸å†™é‚ª37 泻邪褉褌芯褔械泻 èƒ æ³»èŠ¯è°¢è°¢æ¢°æ³»è¤‘æ‡ˆæ‡ˆ 谢械褌薪懈泄 屑è¤å¸è¤‹æ³»èŠ¯æ³„ 褋锌芯褉褌懈èƒè–ªè¤˜æ³„ 泻芯褋褌褞屑泻褉芯褋褋芯èƒæ³»æ‡ˆ 泻邪泻芯泄 褎懈褉屑褘 è°¢è¤è¤”褕械. 褎懈褉屑褘 泻褉芯褋褋芯èƒèŠ¯æ³»æ³»è¤é”Œæ‡ˆè¤Œè¤œ 泻械锌泻邪 薪邪泄泻 褋 锌褉褟屑褘屑 泻芯蟹褘褉褜泻芯屑 芯锌褌芯屑
kit 4 barra 35cm seguran莽a idoso apoio banheiro a莽o inox 30 r 163
gafas de sol modelo aviadorè´¸culos modelo quadrado marc by marc jacobs preto com detalhes em prata è´¸culos marcana hickmann ah 6318 è´¸culos de grau a01 preto brilho lente 5emporio armani 4060 solar cor tartaruga tam 56
æ³»è¤é”Œæ‡ˆè¤Œè¤œ 褋械褉褘械 å¸æ¢°è–ªè¤‹æ³»æ‡ˆæ¢° 泻褉芯褋褋芯èƒæ³»æ‡ˆ 芯褌 799 褉è¤æ–œ èƒ æ‡ˆè–ªè¤Œæ¢°è¤‰è–ªæ¢°è¤Œ 屑邪è°é‚ªèŸ¹æ‡ˆè–ªæ¢°
red tights targetpatterned girls white sheer tights kids liza gabriellalook at this zulilyfind mustard ruffle leggings infantprinted microfibre footless tights multicoloured camouflage
is there a womens only yeezy boost 350 v2 coming sneaker freaker
swiftwater river sandal black crocs shoeshanging gardens small suitcase pinkguess womens flip flops 8 sandals leopard black with bow andclarks desert boots sale men clarks originals desert boot black shoes clarks men shoes
unisex fsr racing shoes trend nike lab zoom fly sp flying marathon high jump jogging shoes
alexander wang rie high heel pumpsblack red satin silk colorful crystal embellished bohemia rome sandals furry feather ankle strappy block heels party shoes womanchristian louboutin shoes christian louboutin aketata nude platform pumps 37women slippers…
100 authentic john starks mitchell ness 91 92 knicks
custom personalized thong panties with your words custom printed sexy fun funny customized panty womens thong lingeriebuy women hip pack shapewear padded underwear comfy butt lift brief pants panties online at best prices in india snapdealdenim trouser…
asos design square glasses in black with clear lens
bee print gg supreme zip around wallet gucci womens zip aroundchanel handbags authentic vintage chanel camera bagmichael michael kors jet set travel tz tote irisgucci flora small canvas tote bag in white multi
buy adidas nmd r1 sneakers in india online on amazon. check out the current
new nike womens flex trainer 6 training shoes 831217 100 szthe coverage of nikes spring 2015 n7 footwear collection continuesmens running shoes nike flex contact anthracite grey cool grey jeans bluenike air pegasus 91 womens white leopard air max 90
under armour harper mid red mens baseball cleat main container
chanel caviar quilted medium cc filigree vanity case beige blackchanel black caviar leather classic flap bagmichael kors riley xs satchel shop sud chic inspired bygucci pelham tote bag catawiki
michael kors bags ebay
under armour armour bra 2.0 maximum control wire free sports bra ddfox tail butt anal plug sex toy bullet dog tails buttplug g spot stimulating toys cat tails couple lover sex products sex gameamazon shaves 70 off samsungs massive 512gb evo select micr…
michael kors riley large brown luggage leather backpack tradesy
gucci inspired blind for love walleta shoulder bag featuring the panprada glace calf twin pocket tote bag in off whitechanel classic flap double flap medium large 2.55 gold hardware lamskin 10
get quotations ouxioaz womens tennis shoe laces feathers art print work shoe laces
arena fundamentals boxer navy white swim suit 6 7 yearslace insert embroidered mesh cover up dressla leela hawaiian bathing suit sarong bikini cover up printedmens water shorts
la senza bra for sale in malolos city
mother of the bride big bling t shirthow to wear a bra with a backless dress searslace up push up silicone adhesive brajessica simpson lace trim maternity sleep bra
è´¸culos de sol esportivo hb highlander 3b espelhado hb è´¸tica madri
le bouquet original bain et pr茅sent茅 dans un sac cadeau tr猫s joliecharpe blanche douceles ceintures htc pour hommes en vente sur le site jules jimrobe longue manches courtes en satin avec ceinture brun monoprix