Zappa’s Stravinsky Borrowings (part 1)

Andre

I recently finished up a draft of a dissertation chapter looking at Zappa use music by Stravinsky. “Status Back Baby,” from Absolutely Free (1967), is the centerpiece of my analysis.: the melodic fragments from Petrushka that constitute the guitar solo in the bridge and the way in which they interact with their new context form a wonderful venue for exploring Zappa’s motivations and intentions. But there are a heck of a lot of other Stravinsky borrowings as well! Zappa borrowed from a number of Stravinsky compositions and did so with remarkable consistency throughout his career. Tracking these moments in his music has been a big part of my research for this chapter.

In a follow-up post, I’ll put up a table of Stravinsky borrowings that appear in Zappa’s music. Román García Albertos’ website, “Information Is Not Knowledge”–the work of a number of contributors including myself–includes an extensive, cross-referenced discography of Zappa’s work. It has been a wonderful resource for tracking musical borrowing. Much of my table is derived from Román’s site, but some of my own observations appear as well.

More importantly, I’ve made an attempt to construct a taxonomy of compositional strategies for how Zappa goes about using this material. Earlier discussions of musical borrowing have tended to use “quotation” as an umbrella term. J. Peter Burkholder has pointed out, however, that “quotation” is but one type of borrowing practice.[1] Burkholder argues that, in order to decipher the intended purpose and implicit meaning of a borrowing, we must understand exactly how it works on a technical level. Categorizing instances of musical borrowing illuminates these technical details. By doing this with Zappa, I’m able to highlight large-scale trends in his compositional history and draw conclusions about what the act of musical borrowing means (to Zappa and to us).

For the most part, Zappa’s various approaches can be accounted for by using terms developed by Burkholder in his work on Charles Ives. [2] The following list paraphrases Burkholder’s terminology, adapting it to better fit Zappa’s music.

  1. Modeling: A work which bears resemblance to its source on a large-scale or structural level. This may be with regards to the textual content, melodic material, or a number of other parameters.
  2. Paraphrasing: An instance in which melodic material is shortened, abbreviated, or otherwise truncated. In most cases, the source material is still highly identifiable.
  3. Arrangement: A rescoring of the musical forces. (Since the borrowings listed in the tables below inevitably require different instrumentation than Stravinsky’s originals, I reserve this term for instances in which no other term applies or where the change in instrumentation is essential to the nature of the borrowing.)
  4. Setting: Providing a new accompaniment for borrowed melodic material.
  5. Medley: An instance of two or more borrowings appearing in close succession.
  6. Quodlibet: A combination of two or more sources simultaneously, often for the sake of humor or ironic juxtaposition.
  7. Stylistic allusion: A reference to a specific work or style, but not necessarily appropriating any traceable melodic, harmonic, or rhythmic material from the source.
  8. Programmatic quotation: Instances in which a quotation (usually melodic) illustrates a part of the text.
  9. Extended paraphrase: An entire work derives its melodic content from a paraphrase of an existing melody.

Of course, not all of Ives’ techniques can be found in Zappa’s work. They are different composers, after all! I’ve omitted the strategies listed by Burkholder that don’t apply.

There are also a couple of techniques that Zappa uses which none of Burkholder’s terms can adequately accommodate. For this reason, I need to supplement the list with some terms of my own:

  1. Riffing: a type of paraphrasing characterized by repetition and the gritty, cathartic feel of a rock guitar solo.
  2. Spontaneous paraphrase: borrowings in improvised music that do not appear to have been premeditated.

In most cases, borrowing in Zappa’s music is never as cut and dried as any one of these strategies would imply. Borrowings are usually characterized by aspects of several compositional techniques simultaneously.

In my next post, I’ll put these terms to use. I’ll provide a table (three, actually!) that will account for most (if not all) instances of Stravinsky borrowing in Zappa’s music. Stay tuned…

References:
[1] J. Peter Burkholder, “The Uses of Existing Music: Musical Borrowing as a Field,” Notes 50.3 (March 1994): 851-870. (Article here.)
[2] Ibid., 854.
Zappa’s Stravinsky Borrowings (part 1)

13,193 thoughts on “Zappa’s Stravinsky Borrowings (part 1)”

  2. gobulon

    97 gull svart pastel r贸偶owy converse wysoki tops washington redskins snapback sapka hi vis messenger sac brandy robbie vestito new era 膷epice germany

  3. vanandark

    carvela alice czerwony p谩nsk茅 slip resistant obuv near me minnesota golden gophers 47 ncaa tayor 47 closer cap pantaloncini nike decathlon jordan 1 blanc et marine jordan superfly 5 po zwart en goud

  4. tubesalot

    svart ribbed maxi kjole 5.11 rush 12 schwarz tuta adidas nera e rosa nike air max axis 2018 gris running chaussure mujer nike air max 95 zapatillas dallas mavericks city series 9fifty snapback berretto

  5. homaarq

    tommy jeans crest sac 脿 dos mini shirt vestito utah jazz youth on court collection 9fifty snapback 膷epice ensemble survetement homme puma heavenly soles leisure zapatillas sell dooney a bourke kabelky

  6. lbiforshore

    survetement nike a capuche plata foldable flats tommy hilfiger crossbody ta拧ka p谩nsk茅 champion 銈点兂銉€銉?銉栥儵銉冦偗 air force 1 utility nero footlocker platform converse kvinner

  7. figgyp

    create your own iphone 7 plus sag wszystko czarny balenciaga triple s svart turtleneck under kjole topshop marissa tasche felpa psg nera air max 97 blanc et gray

  8. edcooleymedia

    texas rangers new era mlb 膷ern谩 series 59fifty 膷epice puma astro cup 膷ern谩 bleu prom chaussure for homme ecco f茅rfi cage flexfit hatter jordan adidas predator 18 zapatillas

  9. painmm

    aldo scammell tasche vestiti sportivi adidas noir et rose puma chaussure nike presto fly todas blanco notre dame football berretto asics gel excite 6 sp n艖i

  10. aebdep

    chaussure air max 2018 air jordan future bajo negro blanco kansas jayhawks new era ncaa training 39thirty berretto adidas zx 500 rm n艖i fekete maxi ruha with piros flowers nike sun protect casquette 2.0

  11. bementesofa

    boho cloth ta拧ky 100 銉偠銉?闈?/a> puma carson rosso flyknit racer hvit gum ultra boost bia艂y szary nationals fitted sapka

  12. pmlhandyman

    decimas zapatillas mujer tenth ted baker 拧ed谩 makeup ta拧ka senso 銉涖儻銈ゃ儓 銇嬨亱銇?/a> donna tutti nero ultra boost nike air force 1 07 lux hvit beige kvinner hypervenom phantom 3 czerwony

  13. bibleclues

    kvinner nike zoom gravity adidas originals zx flux junior czarny colorado avalanche knit sapka sac a roulette vaiana valentino nero lace vestito chicago bulls mitchell ness nba natural camo snapback 膷epice

  14. adsldati

    bucket chapeau costume kvinner nike air max 279 converse grijs helemaal star frilly thrills ox trainers nicht gerade weiss jordan 11 niedrig z艂oto air max 97 m臋skie nike featherlight running sombrero

  15. wocketapparel

    kentucky wildcats nike ncaa aerobill classic sideline swoosh flex cap marine dad chapeau hvit air force 1 for babies wit pharrell nmd jordan 8 herren powder niebieski converse wysoki tops

  16. drainprolv

    nike sb homme sweat pattern cuero zapatillas 膷ern谩 diamond street creek 24 tommy jeans city 銈广儖銉笺偒銉?/a> converse x nero sabbath converse 1970 off hvit

  17. artlabsco

    cincinnati bengals new era kids official nfl sideline 59fifty sapka adraolla sac 脿 dos marina militare e bianca crochet vestito utah jazz heather metallic 9fifty snapback 膷epice robe longue adidas femme zapatos mujer tenis

  19. ficommodities

    szary suede buty damskie svart velvet draped wrap detail bandeau maxi kjole geldbæžšrse herren mit klammer offerte abbigliamento nike adidas superstar 80s half heart chaussure new balance mujer 860v7

  20. abelmoto

    custom adidas sapka samsonite roll top sac 脿 dos nero e verde striped vestito designer beanies d谩msk茅 survetement barcelone vaporknit zapatos aldo hombre precios

  21. johnaustince

    safety buty for civil engineer paul smith p谩nsk茅 chelsea boty arizona cardinals baseball cap felpe adidas su zalando nike air max 270 tout blanc homme nmd 1 zwart

  22. junkmansports

    vapormax 2 racer rose womens adidas originals precurved washed strapback hat cincinnati bengals new era nfl heather vize 9fifty snapback casquette adidas nmd r1 flyknit hvit blauw en roze nike air max 270 lila 6 rings jordans

  23. aolfight

    magliette adidas corte nike air max 90 wolf gris noir university rouge adidas neo gris zapatillas nike l91 tech berretto jordan 11 k茅k fekete homecoming ruha shopping near me

  24. arcmaniac

    us 銉嶃偆銉撱兗 donald duck 甯藉瓙 for 銈汇兗銉?/a> basketball outdoor schuhe jordan retro 12 schwarz wei脽 und gold skechers persistent p谩nsk茅 cowboy klobouky near me new balance running obuv zelen谩

  25. flodepo

    kd 11 r贸zsasz铆n footlocker shona joy lace cocktail midi ruha noir clover fitted chapeau lg g6 sag with card holder mint zielony chunky obcasy hvit sleeveless midi kjole

  26. dottrusso

    cip艖 the bear new york yankees 47 mlb heather front snapback hatter hombre nike pegasus 35 negro aleader water scarpe retailers mavic tempo mtb schoenen asos nike air 97

  27. atlanticcwm

    petite rosso strappy plunge bodycon vestito 3930 膷epice ensemble psg jordan bebe egg beater pedals zapatillas joules hello sunshine ta拧ka pearl izumi overshoes

  28. daytimeshop

    noir mesh sac 脿 dos nike free people nero sweater vestito minnesota united klobouky t shirt adidas jaune femme gray zapatillas polish d谩msk茅 marvel pen臎啪enka

  29. slicezombies

    pearl geldb枚rse pantaloni sportivi nike donna nmd human race vert 720 rojo y blanco miami marlins new era mlb clubhouse 59fifty berretto 97 air max k茅k 茅s piros

  30. pmlambert

    ultra boost core negro active p煤rpura shock rojo detroit tigers 47 mlb nero on nero clean up berretto nmd r1 sz眉rke feh茅r torrid feather ruha 2000x cowboy chapeau iphone xr sag cute

  31. woodpetsteps

    alexander mcqueen 銇嬨亱銇?less 闈?/a> asics uomo cumulus 19 neutral running scarpe puma joggesko hvit og gr酶nn converse 偶贸艂ty 1970 atlanta braves new era trucker sapka popular quilted sacs

  33. brazilianmenu

    bady sleep soothers industrial scientific drilling holders industrial scientific vests 6 tools home improvement split system 3 mens earmuffs 3 arts crafts easel pads

  34. sliptest

    tools home improvement deadbolts 1 home kitchen bakeware edible ink printers automotive steering covers 4 industrial scientific drill adapters home kitchen table skirts 2 home kitchen footboards 5

  36. bmigaming

    industrial scientific hand reamers womens lingerie panties hipsters 3 home kitchen novelty serveware womens clutches 5 boys athletic racquet sports 2 home kitchen home d茅cor snow globes

  37. kompositt

    home kitchen mug hooks automotive outdoor furniture chairs 1 industrial scientific stretch wrap dispensers 2 toys games plates industrial scientific dissolved oxygen meters accessories home kitchen mixed drinkware sets 1

  38. youlubetube

    home kitchen waffle irons boys suits automotive suspension bumpers tools home improvement diamond blades home kitchen bar refrigeration bady playard bedding 3

  39. vlpatron

    golden dress zapatillas rhinestone rivet alto tacones rebecca minkoff star belt ta拧ka 銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?fresh foam vongo v2 nike nmd grigio nike air max 97 menn gull mcq puma buty

  40. dukhachviet

    iphone 7 3d hoesje nfl dj humphries mens limited red jersey 74 arizona cardinals nike home vapor untouchable czarny cotton tote cell phone cases for lg6 nike sports rugzak basketball samsung galaxy a50 k暖啪e back kryt

  41. diabetesinnj

    industrial scientific shirts womens pumps 8 industrial scientific quick change discs industrial scientific vests 6 baby care pacifiers 3 baby girls pants 8

  42. metsapolku

    polo ralph lauren duffle torba free gift huawei p8 lite flip case heart coin handtas sony xperia xzs flip kryt lurex mini 拧aty atlanta braves cappelli through the years

  43. milanobahis

    nike swoosh berretto donna jordan retro 13 fekete alexander wang tweed ruha new york yankees new era mlb team classic 39thirty casquette iphone 6 self charging sag frozen dress buty

  44. analizkolik

    striped denim pinafore ruha stretch snapback chapeau motorola turbo sag neonowe buty sportowe herve leger marinen kjole leder passcase brieftasche

  45. nowruzhaly

    zilver diamond hoog hakken nike cortez basic black puma black ribbon grigio philadelphia eagles cappello 97 nike chaussure toronto blue jays 47 mlb khaki 47 clean up cap

  46. aglatt

    nike zoom kd 12 university rojo alexander wang bucket cappello puma f茅rfi running cip艖 elad谩s leopard maxi ruha nike dri fit chapeau homme uag p20 sag

  47. windowtabs

    nike jacksonville jaguars critical victory nfl t shirt grey mini trunk clutch volcom hip pack sally backpack canvas loafers gerald mccoy jersey

  48. zacutofilms

    adidas barricade rugzak samsung s7 rear kryt 啪lut谩 a 拧ed谩 maxi 拧aty los angeles chargers new era nfl salute to service 59fifty berretto little girls snow boots sansibar gummistiefel damen

  49. zumaoc

    pure blanco retro 3 boston rosso sox tutti star game 9twenty strapback berretto new balance n艖i cip艖k with memory foam ez眉st 茅s fekete striped ruha under armour sc casquette brun l忙der iphone xs max sag

  50. cockvibrator

    dr martens schwarz pascal lifeproof hoesje iphone 7 fre dustin hopkins washington redskins youth game burgundy team color nike jersey red cos plecak skè´¸rzany wf plaid phone case mini chain rugzak

Comments are closed.