Zappa’s Stravinsky Borrowings (part 1)

Andre

I recently finished up a draft of a dissertation chapter looking at Zappa use music by Stravinsky. “Status Back Baby,” from Absolutely Free (1967), is the centerpiece of my analysis.: the melodic fragments from Petrushka that constitute the guitar solo in the bridge and the way in which they interact with their new context form a wonderful venue for exploring Zappa’s motivations and intentions. But there are a heck of a lot of other Stravinsky borrowings as well! Zappa borrowed from a number of Stravinsky compositions and did so with remarkable consistency throughout his career. Tracking these moments in his music has been a big part of my research for this chapter.

In a follow-up post, I’ll put up a table of Stravinsky borrowings that appear in Zappa’s music. Román García Albertos’ website, “Information Is Not Knowledge”–the work of a number of contributors including myself–includes an extensive, cross-referenced discography of Zappa’s work. It has been a wonderful resource for tracking musical borrowing. Much of my table is derived from Román’s site, but some of my own observations appear as well.

More importantly, I’ve made an attempt to construct a taxonomy of compositional strategies for how Zappa goes about using this material. Earlier discussions of musical borrowing have tended to use “quotation” as an umbrella term. J. Peter Burkholder has pointed out, however, that “quotation” is but one type of borrowing practice.[1] Burkholder argues that, in order to decipher the intended purpose and implicit meaning of a borrowing, we must understand exactly how it works on a technical level. Categorizing instances of musical borrowing illuminates these technical details. By doing this with Zappa, I’m able to highlight large-scale trends in his compositional history and draw conclusions about what the act of musical borrowing means (to Zappa and to us).

For the most part, Zappa’s various approaches can be accounted for by using terms developed by Burkholder in his work on Charles Ives. [2] The following list paraphrases Burkholder’s terminology, adapting it to better fit Zappa’s music.

  1. Modeling: A work which bears resemblance to its source on a large-scale or structural level. This may be with regards to the textual content, melodic material, or a number of other parameters.
  2. Paraphrasing: An instance in which melodic material is shortened, abbreviated, or otherwise truncated. In most cases, the source material is still highly identifiable.
  3. Arrangement: A rescoring of the musical forces. (Since the borrowings listed in the tables below inevitably require different instrumentation than Stravinsky’s originals, I reserve this term for instances in which no other term applies or where the change in instrumentation is essential to the nature of the borrowing.)
  4. Setting: Providing a new accompaniment for borrowed melodic material.
  5. Medley: An instance of two or more borrowings appearing in close succession.
  6. Quodlibet: A combination of two or more sources simultaneously, often for the sake of humor or ironic juxtaposition.
  7. Stylistic allusion: A reference to a specific work or style, but not necessarily appropriating any traceable melodic, harmonic, or rhythmic material from the source.
  8. Programmatic quotation: Instances in which a quotation (usually melodic) illustrates a part of the text.
  9. Extended paraphrase: An entire work derives its melodic content from a paraphrase of an existing melody.

Of course, not all of Ives’ techniques can be found in Zappa’s work. They are different composers, after all! I’ve omitted the strategies listed by Burkholder that don’t apply.

There are also a couple of techniques that Zappa uses which none of Burkholder’s terms can adequately accommodate. For this reason, I need to supplement the list with some terms of my own:

  1. Riffing: a type of paraphrasing characterized by repetition and the gritty, cathartic feel of a rock guitar solo.
  2. Spontaneous paraphrase: borrowings in improvised music that do not appear to have been premeditated.

In most cases, borrowing in Zappa’s music is never as cut and dried as any one of these strategies would imply. Borrowings are usually characterized by aspects of several compositional techniques simultaneously.

In my next post, I’ll put these terms to use. I’ll provide a table (three, actually!) that will account for most (if not all) instances of Stravinsky borrowing in Zappa’s music. Stay tuned…

References:
[1] J. Peter Burkholder, “The Uses of Existing Music: Musical Borrowing as a Field,” Notes 50.3 (March 1994): 851-870. (Article here.)
[2] Ibid., 854.
Zappa’s Stravinsky Borrowings (part 1)

13,193 thoughts on “Zappa’s Stravinsky Borrowings (part 1)”

  1. adgarplaza

    champion attribute duffel torba huawei p smart cover case leer hip zak with leg strap pen臎啪enka pouzdro huawei p20 pro mint zelen谩 tutu 拧aty baylor bears new era ncaa 9fifty snapback berretto

  2. sensepeanut

    azul negro blanco nike air max 90 brooks koepka nike cappello n艖i nike air max 90 feh茅r 茅s fekete fekete dip hem ruha adidas summer chapeau nokia 105 back d忙ksel pris

  3. halsteadtyres

    mens bottoms 1 smart home televisions home kitchen box springs 1 industrial scientific dropping bottles industrial scientific patient positioners tools home improvement deck boxes

  4. tonykrank

    flip kryt for samsung a70 asos maternity leopard 拧aty padres carhartt cappello hiking and trekking shoes herren leder hiking sandalen apple leer dekking iphone x

  5. rainslibrary

    symmetry series case for iphone xs max alexander wang ace crossbody zak samsung smart kryt note 8 tropical cold shoulder 拧aty jordan cappelli amazon vivobarefoot evo pure

  6. tipofthearrow

    dsw weekender bag navy blue adidas sweatpants adidas printed t shirt womens personalized bags for gifts nike navy blue troy aikman backer nfl 8 dallas cowboys t shirt black nike flyknit vapormax

  8. zhimzone

    baby girls skirt sets 5 tools home improvement railings 2 industrial scientific lab swabs mens boots motorcycle combat 2 industrial scientific industrial vibration sensors womens lingerie bra extenders 2

  9. cadhomeplan

    otterbox pouzdro samsung s10 膷ern谩 sequin tulle 拧aty toronto blu jays 47 mlb cooperstown 47 clean up berretto white stuff aimee wedge fu脽ballschuhe unter 30 euro heavy duty protective phone hoesje

  10. jgbello

    adidas ultra boost feh茅r z枚ld missguided zebra print ruha maharishi bucket chapeau the ace family phone sag hoka buty plantar fasciitis lane bryant rosa lace kjole

  11. wanderislands

    marvel wallet phone case zwart billabong rugzak lg g7 pouzdro near me dolce a gabbana ruched tulle 拧aty vintage detroit lions cappello black character tap shoes

  12. aklperu

    womens satchels 2 toys games miniatures home kitchen place mats 7 automotive axle flange toys games padded shorts home kitchen pillowcases 4

  13. gigaradios

    my kohls portfel huawei rio l01 back cover simply noelle portemonnees spring 2019 pouzdro mate folio little burgundy 拧aty oklahoma city thunder mitchell ness nba heather metallic snapback berretto

  14. chscbd

    puma enzo noir rojo air force 1 zapatillas champion golf cappello air max vapor plus f茅rfi midi boho wedding ruha ellesse trucker casquette

  15. ecoshadedubai

    mcm sling tasche herren maglia adidas bianca e verde dad chaussure puma nike air jordan 1 negro toe bajo washington wizards oro word 9fifty snapback berretto nike air max one narancs

  16. holasmoothie

    plus size sequin fit a flare 拧aty new york rangers new era nhl gray nero 59fifty berretto high top school shoes hoka trail schuhe herren huawei mate 20 pro hoesje dekking nfl eric fisher black 72 kansas city chiefs nike name number logo long sleeve t s…

  17. piumissimo

    womens promise rings home kitchen throw pillow covers 3 tools home improvement stone tiles home kitchen novelty flatware womens pearl strands necklaces 7 home kitchen beach towels 4

  18. eduprospector

    cases for galaxy j7 refine disney neck portemonnee rock pouzdro for iphone x backless 拧aty sexy bianca pittsburgh pirates cappello steve madden cliff neon green

  19. wefesttickets

    啪lutè°© a 膷ernè°© animal print 拧aty houston astros new era mlb authentic collection 59fifty berretto most expensive basketball shoes tommy hilfiger sandalen g眉nstig oppo a3s glass back dekking pirates 25 gregory polanco gold flexbase authentic collection s…

  20. pronghornpix

    guess gray torba xr iphone phone case herschel little america oranje avengers iphone se pouzdro printed chiffon maxi 拧aty unc bucket cappello

  21. polymeur

    boston college knit cappello asics gel lyte fekete feh茅r piros 茅s fekete sweater ruha vintage timberwolves chapeau lumee selfie sag merrell chameleon hiking buty

  22. dothosnet

    automotive strut compressors industrial scientific regulators home kitchen box springs 1 home kitchen ceiling fan blades industrial scientific hydraulic lifting cylinders 1 womens denim shorts 1

  23. velvetdev

    nike pegasus 89 vert nike air max react 270 mujer dallas cowboys new era nfl team basic 59fifty berretto adidas predator 18.3 feh茅r 茅s piros feh茅r lace bohemian maxi ruha syracuse baseball casquette

  24. freshcutsltd

    ariat baseball berretto mini melissa flox pink collection by clarks herren mini cooper iphone x hoesje grizzlies 10 mike bibby green throwback stitched nba jersey kipling crossbody mini torba

  25. michellerohen

    sequin bucket cappello f茅rfi new balance 420 edz艖k lilac ruha size 16 titans camo chapeau nike phone sag iphone 6 sanda艂y dzieci臋ce z zakrytymi palcami

  26. socialtonik

    n铆zk媒 cut long 膷ern谩 拧aty nypd baseball berretto geox infant lloyd stiefeletten samsung p580 hoesje nike youth eddie george limited light blue jersey tennessee titans nfl 27 rush vapor untouchable

  27. untyinglove

    justin turner kids jersey neck wallet badge holder nike wallet with money clip cute overnight bag dr martens magdalena everson griffen mens limited purple jersey nike nfl minnesota vikings rush vapor untouchable 97

  28. flcodecamp

    buty zarro oransje fishnet kjole faraday credit card brieftasche adidas felpa nera uomo femme nike air max 97 rouge puma mujer zapatillas sports direct

  29. obxpubcrawl

    roots canada leder taschen pantaloni puma larghi violet suede jordan 11 todas rojo air max vapormax plus custom made ball berretto air max 95 se fekete feh茅r

  30. cbswilm

    nike super bowl lii mens patrick chung elite red alternate jersey new england patriots nfl 23 vapor untouchable cobalt niebieski sk贸rzany torba skinnydip samsung s8 case cotton tassen otterbox pouzdro with pen臎啪enka realisation par slip 拧aty

  31. nbanker

    press play battery hoesje red wings 19 steve yzerman red winter classic ccm throwback stitched nhl jersey personalised sk贸rzany messenger torba samsung a6 cover case quilted overnight zak iphone pen臎啪enka pouzdro near me

  32. ariomusic

    nike air force 1 marr贸n hombre new york yankees trucker berretto ultra boost sz眉rke 茅s z枚ld boden retro pocket ruha oversized bonnet with pom pom iphone 6 sag with glass screen protector

  33. jheuss

    myra gerster shoulder tasche tuta adidas fucsia puma homme enzo nike air max tn hombre zapatillas cool halloween cappelli kyrie 5 f茅rfi basketball cip艖

  34. harleysocal

    patriots super bowl 36 cappello fred perry aubrey grey chelsea boots damen beige nokia 7.1 mobile hoesje mens alshon jeffery limited green nike jersey nfl philadelphia eagles 17 super bowl lii rush vapor untouchable evercat contender 3.0 plecak

  35. bradentondda

    puma ferrari replica plecak samsung tab a 8.0 otterbox case portemonnee sling iphone xr pouzdro funny topshop faux snake pleated shirt 拧aty nero cotton baseball berretto

  36. tacticalhid

    reddit work torba power case iphone 7 danielle nicole tinkerbell rugzak samsung tab a 10.5 pouzdro australia feather wedding 拧aty olive verde champion cappello

  37. youreadopted

    donna coach bucket cappello adidas boost mint vert chicago blackhawks reebok nhl truckn adjustable cap spring training 2019 casquettes nike air force 1 easter kvinner jordan 12 sail rood blauw

  38. youreadopted

    womens chokers necklaces industrial scientific indoor air quality meters automotive sun protection curtains 2 home kitchen throw pillow covers 6 girls sandals 2 automotive pressure in cycle

  39. keltologie

    raffia handtassen iphone x k暖啪e pouzdro apple review mango snakeskin 拧aty nero nike flat bill cappello ecco rivas 45 wedge sandal wilson rush pro 2.0 herren

  40. chickenhead

    pomara艅czowy transparent portmonetka nokia 3310 pouch case north face shoulder handtas iphone xr pouzdro spigen light modr媒 skater 拧aty kids dodgers cappello

  41. gutterkeeper

    lackstiefel blau xiaomi battery hoesje limited nike black mens graham gano jersey nfl 9 carolina panthers 2016 salute to service czerwony bow clutch torba waterproof iphone 6 case for swimming north face diaper zak

  42. tamanbindra

    iphone 7s plus hoesje nfl nike new york giants 94 dalvin tomlinson ash name number logo long sleeve t shirt czarny quilted chain shoulder torba samsung s9 leather back cover guess transparent rugzak samsung galaxy s5 shockproof pouzdro

  43. isychedelic

    kotyl 5891 bright rosa ruffle kjole diaper tasche items felpa puma nera e bianca new balance 608 blanc rose yeezy 700 utility negro retail precio

  45. askforedhelp

    tools home improvement pipe heat cables 4 baby boys gloves mittens 2 home kitchen throw pillow covers 8 baby boys robes 1 industrial scientific cans girls hiking boots 2

  46. dsnrmg

    fossil explorer portfel 8 plus apple case converse colour block rugzak mous phone pouzdro note 8 kohls fit a flare 拧aty y3 cappello vendita

  47. proyectodono

    nfl barry church womens ash 42 jacksonville jaguars nike backer pullover hoodie tommy hilfiger portmonetka czerwony iphone 6 plus carbon fiber case new look tassen tote htc one x10 pouzdro tommy hilfiger modr媒 lace 拧aty

  48. spaynj

    home kitchen wall lamps sconces automotive full car covers industrial scientific push-in plugs 3 tools home improvement window insulation kits 1 womens sun hats 7 laptop backpacks 6

  49. grafikmoto

    st艡铆brn媒 拧ed谩 拧aty san jose sharks cappello red wing oro russet portage leather mammut mercury mid ii gtx hoesje iphone bape green bay packers aaron rodgers official nike white game women s road nfl jersey

  50. nanomix

    vetements canvas sneakers schuhe ordering sites mous phone hoesje huawei p20 pro adidas wild 22 nino niederreiter green home authentic drift fashion stitched nhl jersey alexander mcqueen czarny torba iphone 7 plus squishy case

Comments are closed.