I Come From Nowhere(?)

My dissertation–if you hadn’t already gathered–focuses on the convergence of popular and classical music streams that informs much of Frank Zappa’s music. This confluence means different things in different places (for both Zappa and his audience), but it seems to me to be a defining characteristic that runs through all of his work. My questions here are: Why would this be such an important aspect of his work? and, What influenced him in thinking this way?

Strictly Genteel

On the one hand, Zappa was trying to establish for himself a reputation as a composer of serious art music. His reasons for this are, of course, open to debate, but Zappa was always quick to point out that his ambitions were aesthetically motivated. He was introduced to the modernist music of Stravinsky and Varèse around the same time he began collecting blues and R&B records. Zappa recognized that the disparate styles were commonly seen to be at odds with one another. But since both appealed to him personally, he tried to share this experience of music free from social implications. The obvious way of doing this would be to synthesize these different styles in his own work.

On a slightly different angle, it seems to me that the obvious appeal (and associated cultural capital) of being a respected artist was an equally significant factor. Zappa clearly admired Stravinsky and Varèse (and Webern and Cage, among others) and that he would want to model himself on his “idols” almost goes without saying.

But where does this all come from? What streams (cultural, social, musical) does he fit into? Despite his claims to originality, it seems unlikely that Zappa developed in a bubble.

To begin with, I suspect it may have had something to do with the conservative cultural climate of Southern California in the 1940s and 50s. Zappa saw this environment as oppressive and felt claustrophobic in the rural deserts communities of his youth. For me, Zappa’s self-identification as an outsider is neatly summarized in this 1970 photograph by John Olson of Frank posing with his parents Francis and Rosemary in their home Frank’s Los Angeles home [thanks Corné!]:

Zappa with parents

(Of course, by 1970 Frank had long been out of the house so this picture doesn’t offer an authentic vision of Zappa’s youth. Nonetheless, I think the picture captures much of the spirit of Zappa and his rebellious culture at odds with conservative values, while at the same time offering some ambiguity as to who really belongs in this environment.)

While still a child, he found refuge in the modernist avant-garde. (He would delight in his mother’s recoiling at the sound of Varèse’s sirens being played on the family turntable.) These composers offered a safe mode of rebellion for Zappa in a remarkable way. They were accepted artists–undeniably respectful members of society–whose music had a similar effect with adults to what teenagers experienced with heavy metal in the 1980s.

But I don’t think it ends there. As significant as his rebellion against perceived conservative oppression was, I think there’s something deeper. In discussing when the dichotomy between classical and popular entered the American consciousness, Paul Charosh writes:

We would be mistaken to assume that this division between types of music reflects a simple division between two sets of listeners, one group seeking edification and uplift from classical music and a separate group looking to popular music for a cure for the blues. Some favored light music over serious; others preferred classical music to the popular; but many enjoyed both types of music on different occasions, for different purposes.[1]

Charosh is referring to mid-18th century listeners, but this characterization seems to have some resonance with Zappa’s sentiments a century later. Is this a constant stream in American musical consciousness? Did Zappa inherit this dual validity of opposing musical streams?

For that matter, who else was a part of this? Zappa consistently sought to establish himself as being counter-counterculture. But even as he defined himself against the hippie movement and the politics of the New Left in the 1960s, he took certain aspects of their motivations as his own. Can we consider Zappa to be a part of these movements even if he explicitly denies accepting them?

For now, these thoughts are very preliminary. I don’t have the answers to these questions. (Yet!)

References:
[1] Paul Charosh, “‘Popular’ and ‘Classical’ in the Mid-Nineteenth Century,” American Music, Vol. 10, No. 2 (Summer, 1992), 126.
I Come From Nowhere(?)

32,946 thoughts on “I Come From Nowhere(?)

  1. 2020 liberty iso

    baby blue cropped cardigan gold snapback hats 2020 adidas cf plus wool black sweater pink and green windbreaker balenciaga triple s front red chief furo shoes beige nike shoes yeezy 700 v2 static

  2. 蟽蠀蟽魏蔚蠀伪蟽蟿喂魏蠈 vacuum 蟽伪魏慰蠉位蔚蟼 魏蔚谓慰蠉 魏伪喂 蟽伪魏慰蠉位蔚蟼 蟺位伪蟽蟿喂魏苇蟼

    barbie lutka sa fiat 500 automobilom mattel kupovina ru膷na transportna magacionerska kolica za horizontalni ili vertikalni transport ozdoby weselne do w艂osè´¸w testovi za trudno膰u salomon tenisice speedcross 3 br. 43 ford predstavio najsna啪niji mustang d…

  3. carregador para celular original

    damenuhren angebote samsung galaxy 7s edge plus sofa眉berwurf eckcouch fodere divani elasticizzate furniture stores in brisbane australia tiendas de sofas baratos nike crossfit masculino franca sapatos para revenda superstar azuis chandal bulls nike

  4. cavissa jumpsuit by mads norgaard clothing

    nike air max motion lw dame fritidssko dame lene bjerre jessie 9cm fyrfadsstage college bomull jakker herre the new t shirt i ré…¶dstribet essenza sengeté…¶j burberry kaxholmen fleecefilt med gosedjur kanin bonde og voel vaskede den sidste ajax plet vå¿™k sm…

  5. pantalon corto deporte mujer el corte ingles

    abbigliamento taglie comode giovanile bauletto elvstræžšm zucca fai da te halloween alpargata night market gorras new era hornets zapatillas vikky platform pantalones ltb para mujer valverde del camino sandalias tejidas para bebe varon

  6. kors hvitt gull

    nutramino whey protein vanilje 500 g smæ°“ treklyper ré…¶d 20pk barneklå¿™r gutt hatt fedora vintage black bergans vattert jakke dame plantoys badelegeté…¶j god klapvogn til at sove i inspirasjon fra ellingsen mé…¶bler i drammen. slettvoll

  7. adidas nmd azul

    kæ‹§iltovky santa cruz zbo啪铆 dè°©msk茅 jarn铆 a podzimn铆 bundy burton boardstar lidl spouæ‹§t铆 dal拧铆 retro t媒den crazy d臎tsk茅 boty na such媒 zip geox kabè°©t dè°©msk媒 æ‹§ed媒 na zavazovac铆 pè°©sek sasoo usb flash disk s redukc铆 na micro usb harvia saunov茅 kameny 膷erven茅…

  8. giacche di pelle donne online

    zapatos para falda lapiz vans todos azules the best last minute christmas gifts with next day delivery superdry abrigo coreano hombre sudaderas house of fluff vestidos bed j.w. ford sudaderas para equipos de futbol scarpe con zeppa interna ash rebecca…

  9. ab wheels og kettler trå¿™ningsbå¿™nke

    mads né…¶rgaard georgette jumpsuit mæžšrkblæ°“ inwear lå¿™derjakke style gwenda lå¿™derjakke badekæ°“be lasarito pink 8 hæ°“ndklå¿™der fra georg jensen damask gavepartner astronaut kostume fra melissa og doug udklå¿™dning til bé…¶rn fastelavn halloween drenge vest med sé…¶m…

  10. what are reborn dolls an intro to the movement paradise

    ké…¶b chevron bluse af fub hos haus jonathan 102 rain jacket regnté…¶j blæ°“ lego wear oakley holbrook prizm polarized cat 3 14 vlt solbriller holbrook steel glas daily cat 3 vlt 14 mens denim jacket with fur collar retro ripped fleece jeans jacket and coat…

  11. vestidos para fiestas de graduacion

    garmin fenix 3 natacion piscina zapatillas nike jordan fly lockdown zapatillas puma rsx attack do titan so莽aite mizuno tenis polo ralph lauren feminino offset umbrella base cover round table cloth south africa kenner cal莽ados

  12. pink jacquard vestito

    sport i elegancja. nowe zegarki marki lorus zegarki m臋skie abrigo corto gris mujer vodot臎sn媒 outdoorov媒 batoh dè°©msk茅 d铆v膷铆 dvoud铆ln茅 plavky modr茅 unisex oble膷en铆 a obuv mè´¸dn铆 zna膷kov茅 oble膷en铆 za skv臎l茅 ceny juxtapos茅 calibre 10 lè°©mpat铆pusok belt茅ri vi…

  13. 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 10l 姘寸潃 銉儑銈c兗銈广儠銈°儍銈枫儳銉?銇€氳博

    aimer 銈ㄣ儭 aimer 姹犺銉儫銉嶅簵 姹犺銉儫銉嶅簵 銈便兗銈?鎵嬪赋鍨?銈儶銈搞儕銉?鎵嬪赋鍨嬨偙銉笺偣 銉炪偘銉嶃儍銉堛偪銈ゃ儣 leopard gekko02 銈偆銉曘偐銉? swisswin 銉儱銉冦偗銈点儍銈?澶у閲?銉°兂銈?銈广儩銉笺儎 銈偊銉堛儔銈?闃叉按 浜烘皸 瀹夈亜 sw8350 mont blanc black mens leather wallet for informal wallet bjæžšrn borg polyamid shorts sp…

  14. ppt beste spy shop online i norge powerpoint presentation

    145 2 sukienka z koronki bordowa numoco postnord læ°“ng tid konsumentr盲tt blè°©zek b艖rtè°©ska oldaltè°©ska ba 2924 po ka艧e manto model ve fiyatlarè°‹ tè°©ska karen bordè´¸ virè°©g rostb艖r n艖i kicsi 020 ye艧il uzun erkek mont at mix from italy halterneck kl盲nning pink c…

  15. lee cooper erkek chap yelek 161 lcm trendyol

    銉兂銈般儔銉偣 鍏湰鏈ㄣ儔銉偣銈枫儳銉冦儣 銉儑銈c偑銉笺儘 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 鍋忓厜銈点兂銈般儵銈?æ¶“?銉栥儵銉炽儔銈兗銈儶銉?銇€氳博 vans era 銉嶃偆銉撱兗 銉曘儶銉炪偄銉椼儶 銉┿偗銉?鏂板搧 maccheronian 銉炪偒銉儖銈兂 銈广儖銉笺偒銉?銈搞儯銉笺優銉炽儓銉兗銉娿兗 wht 銈点偆銈?4 鐙北甯傚競姘戜細椁?/a> kanguru cepl陌 ceket adidas basketball james harden vol.1 red white s…

  16. lacoste damska bluza z kapturem z d艂ugim r臋kawem czarna

    銈枫儯銉嶃儷 闄愬畾 璨″竷 榛?銈儠銈枫儳銉?銈儯銉愬 澶т汉 銈儯銉愩偍銉偓銉炽儓銉夈儸銈?銉兂銉?銈儯銉愩儔銉偣 銉曘儶銉炪偄銉椼儶 銉┿偗銉?/a> 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銈ゃ兂銉濄兗銉?姘寸潃 銈广兗銉?銈汇儍銉堛偄銉冦儣 銉°兂銈? petite set med kjol och topp med dekorativa knappar boohoo puma 306083 09 kè°‹rmè°‹zè°‹ erkek spor ayakkabè°‹ amazon win 銉欍儞銉?銈儍銈?璧ゃ…

  17. divatos f茅rfi t谩sk谩k

    2016 adidas krampon modelleri adidas bayan sneaker beyaz alkalmi ruha vè°©sè°©rlè°©s online armani erkek kaban armani kaban 100 陌ndirimli gardrops kurtka lekka graff 608 c n艖i ecco biom slip on ecco outdoor cip艖 kiè°©rus铆tè°©s 銉娿偆銈?銈ㄣ偄銉炪儍銈偣 1 銈ㄣ儍銈汇兂銈枫儯銉?銉併儯銉兂銈…

  18. dirndlbluse kariert off shoulder

    inflation hip hop harem jogger hosen 2018 m盲nnliche hosen badeanzug mit schwimmerr眉cken schwimmanzug gr. 140 cardigans sweaters womens clothing gucci gucci bamboo eau de parfum 30ml 写邪屑褋泻懈 锌邪褉褎褞屑 fendi rhinoshield s8 plus louis vuitton phone cases sams…

  19. za拧膷ita za varnostni pas

    plain nero lungo frock blæš–za mikina 3d potisk kon臎 missguided modrozelen茅 pouzdrov茅 krajkov茅 æ‹§aty na ram铆nka xxl new york yankees no shot captain kæ‹§iltovka dark teal domy valaæ‹§sk茅 klobouky na prodej vestiti to wear to a casual abiti da sposa converse c…

  20. nike lebron 15 en ucuz erkek basketbol ayakkabè°‹larè°‹

    姘存吵 甯藉瓙 濂虫€?/a> adidas neo erkek ayakkabè°‹ indirim online www kup ciep艂e swetry damskie zakupy online z orsay 姝h鍝?coach 銈炽兗銉?銉忋兗銉堝瀷銈兗銉涖儷銉€銉?銉斻兂銈?銈炽兗銉?samantha tiara 浼婂嫝涓?銈汇兗銉┿兗銉犮兗銉?銈点優銉炽偟銉嗐偅銈儵 璧ゃ仭銈冦倱 瀹ゆ俯 nike tiempo mystic iv halè°‹ saha ayakkabè°‹sè°‹ 70…

  21. asics 銉愩儍銈枫儱 閫氳博

    80 talets mode kvinnor stil klasyczna elegancka bluzka damska 50 浜烘皸鑺歌兘浜恒亴鐫€鐢ㄣ仐銇熴儔銉偣銈掔潃銈堛亞 銇撱倢銇俱仹鑺歌兘浜恒伀鐫€鐢?/a> collana grigia tricotin gioielli realizzati alluncinetto bergans down youth girl jacket dunjakke beet red solid charcoal 128 durex intense d…

  22. mcdavid hex teflx leg sleeves 6446x black

    2018 new winter baby dress children cotton thickened kids lace dress toddler clothes girls christmas dress henbury wicking polo shirt funny slogan shirts coffee shirts funny shirts work out shirts 2018 summer kids boy t shirt fortnite ninja clothes pri…

  23. sony wi c200 bluetooth f眉lhallgat贸 fekete

    orecchini raspini corallo p茅nztè°©rca marina galanti 56 147 1 vilè°©gos barna kè°©rtyatartè´¸s dont moose with me n艖i nyè°©ri pizsama tuta adidas uomo grigia tappetino fitness pieghevole trespass pantaloni donna sci hogan scarpe uomo interactive pelle come fare…

  24. 銈汇兗銉?nike 銉娿偆銈?銈枫儱銉笺偤 銈偢銉ャ偄銉?銉娿偆銈?銈裤兂銈搞儱銉?812654 101 銉°兂銈?銉涖儻銈ゃ儓 銉栥儵銉冦偗

    mima ormari akcija 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 姘寸潃 銈儵銉笺儘銈ゃ儞銉?銈儍銈?銈儍銈?銉欍儞銉?銉戙兗銈兗 銈般儶銉笺兂 銈兗銈?绶戣壊绯?銉曘偂銉冦偡銉с兂閫氳博 zozotown 娴锋按娴?銉撱偔銉?鐢?6浜?銇敾鍍忕礌鏉?瀹舵棌 浜洪枔闁總 浜虹墿銇?amazon 銈兗銈儶銉?oakley 銈点兂銈般儵銈?oo9275 銉°兂銈?銈儯銉湇 black queen 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銈儯銉?姘寸潃 璋烽枔 姘寸潃鐢?鑳搞儜銉冦儓 銈枫偋銉儜銉冦儔 camper t…

  25. kari traa rose tube

    dame vesker nettbutikk mc hjelm fullface simpson venom carbon bukse tiro19 sr rbk shop kick off for fotball 2019 inderé…¶y idrettslag bergans nordkapp jr 18 l sekk vask og rengjé…¶ring av mc trå¿™ hamre hoslars alt i legeté…¶j rubens baby therapy doll nora by…

  26. fourre samsung

    retro 1 red white black taille pantalon dickies sac a dos eastpak cora bottines 2018 femme tenue femme pour fete location table evenement magasin des chaussures a paris casquette maga new chelsea home shirt small duffel bag with wheels adidas stan miss

  27. Funda fundas de dibujos animados para 6S Plus funda suave TPU con para iPhone XS Max

    爻丕賲爻賵賳噩 賳賵鬲 10 亘乇賵 兀乇亘毓丞 乇賰賳 賵爻丕丿丞 賴賵丕卅賷丞 鬲鬲丨胤賲 賲賯丕賵賲丞 丨賯賷亘丞 賴丕鬲賮 賲丨賲賵賱 兀乇亘毓丞 夭賵丕賷丕 賲賰丕賮丨丞 爻賯賵胤 噩乇丕亘 賴丕鬲賮 賲氐賳賵毓 禺氐賷氐賸丕 Funda silicona la reina Elisabeth II Princesa para Xiaomi Redmi 4A Funda Huawei personalizada funda de silicona la Revoluci\xc3\xb3…

  28. chloe marcie continental zip wallet

    ocean of elegance dress social navy blue wedding guest party long prom dresses a line halter sweep train royal blue satin prom dress with lace baby muslin washcloths and towels deal on amazon coupons baby toddler boys long sleeve solid tee shirt baby s…

  29. 銉娿偆銈?銈枫儳銉笺儓銉戙兂銉?銈点儍銈兗 銉曘儍銉堛儨銉笺儷 銉戙兗銈?ii nb

    bielizna i damskie stroje w lidlu gazetka 18 czerwca 25 y眉nl眉 kap眉艧onlu kaban lacivert takè°‹ma hangi renk gæžšmlek vibratore k1 viola ovo beyaz arkasè°‹ ye艧il spor ayakkabè°‹ plain asymmetriska fæ°“llar snygga kavaj dam pæ°“ n盲tet girocollo cuore in oro 750 bianc…

  30. lacn茅 k煤pe木艌ov茅 skrinky

    氐賵乇 賲賵丕賱賷丿 2017 禺賱賮賷丕 賲賵丕賱賷丿 丕賵賱丕丿 賵亘賳丕 salonke na platformu sa tankom æ‹§tiklom crvene pelota de futbol adidas confederations cup showsport dettagli su copertina neonata uncinetto fatta a mano 100 lana baby merino cuffietta beb猫 love moschino cip艖 tom t…

  31. red v neck floral printed jumpsuits summer casual half sleeve rompers siamese shorts

    inzerè°©ty st艡eæ‹§n铆 nosi膷 skoda octavia bazar a inzerce ko啪enè°© a atestovanè°© obuv zimn铆 dè°©msk茅 koza膷ky 123 na mal茅m pap铆rov媒 ubrus sklè°©dan媒 1 v媒prodej carvingov茅 ly啪e salomon 2v 178 cm inzerce akce b铆lè°© tylovè°© sukn臎 skladem gynekologie uni膷ov cz nepou啪it茅…

  32. gateau anniversaire femme

    chaussure de handball homme asics mango shop en ligne cardigan ralph lauren homme robe 茅t茅 taille empire bambini negozio online gucci gonne lunghe estive echarpe polaire decathlon adidas schuhe m盲dchen 38 besteckset f眉r 12 personen

  33. amazon barbie 銉愩兗銉撱兗銉愩兗銉撱兗銉儑銈c兗銈广儛銉冦偘

    pendente chiave bronze n艖i szabadid艖 meleg铆t艖 beyaz c陌lt spor ayakkabi not just any sunday its mothers day ebbe ebbekids 20th浼佺敾 銉夈儸銈广偄銉冦儣銈儯銉冦儓銉併儯銉笺儬 銉忋兂銉夈儭銈ゃ儔鍝?澶у瀷銉堛兗銉堛儛銉冦偘 銉兂銈枫儳銉儉銉兼帥銇戝彲鑳姐偒銉愩兂 ç»±?銉戙兗銉椼儷 鎵嬩綔銈娿偒銉愩兂 é—‰?銉曘偐銉笺優銉偟銉栥儛銉冦偘 銉斻兂銈?銈儛銉?銉愩儍銈般偒銈搞…

  34. bluzka z poliestru mohito cares bia艂y

    siyah deri 陌nce bantlè°‹ y眉ksek topuklu platform ayakkabè°‹ ballers 鏂拌壊銉愩儍銈枫儱銈便兗銈?銉溿兗銉┿兗銈恒伄銉栥儹銈?銇椼伨銈€銈?鍚岀ぞ鍒濄伄銈兂銉┿偆銉炽偡銉с儍銉椼倰銉曘偂銉冦偡銉с兂閫氳博銈点偆銉?/a> coach 銈炽兗銉?銈枫儳銉儉銉笺儛銉冦偘 銈枫偘銉嶃儊銉c兗 銉曘儵銉兗 鑺辨焺 hasè°‹r taba dolgu topuk ayakkabè°‹ 浜烘皸 銈儑銈c儉銈?銉撱儍銈般儣銉兂銉堛偣銈︺偋銉冦儓 銉嶃偆…

  35. deri ceket ve g眉ne艧 g枚zl眉臒眉 ciddi moda model stok foto

    銈广偊銈с儍銉?銉戙兗銈?銉曘儸銉炽儊銉嗐儶銉笺儣銉偑銉笺儛銉?瑁忔瘺 銉熴兂銉?銉戙兗銈兗 10.0銈兂銈?xs s m l xl 銈嗐亞銉戙偙銉冦儓涓嶅彲 au wowma 銉偊銉?reebok 銈儯銉冦儣 銇湡闁撻檺瀹氥偡銉с儍銉椼伅 nike pegasus 32 turuncu sari fosforlu kosu ayakkabisi nike bluza bez kaptura damska welurowa r贸偶owa eight2nine sklep odzie偶 t…

  36. timberland boots business casual

    tondeuse wahl t wide eastpak ek767 tuta mizuno uomo nera puma ignite evoknit mens black optical center perigueux gucci lunette solaire femme coque puma samsung j76 housse iphone 6s cuir boutique havaianas veste homme diesel

  37. pantalon para ejercicio mujer

    zapatos oxford mujer bicolor armani outlet online zapatos deportivos reebok hombre esparde帽as mujer baratas moschino abiti nike force 1 stivali con tacco sotto il ginocchio pure drive 2012 luxusne nausnice bollitore da fornello bialetti

  38. mont kaban modelleri dj plus ka艧e kaban 17 2 tl 陌ndirimde

    estelle 銈ㄣ偣銉嗐兗銉?k10 銉斻兂銈偞銉笺儷銉?銉€銈ゃ儰銉兂銉?銉忋兗銉堛儮銉併兗銉?銉嶃儍銈儸銈?鍘抽伕 銈广儓銉┿儍銉椼儧銉笺儷銇亗銈?iphone 6 plus 銈便兗銈?銈︺儭銉偆銉笺偗 銉曘偂銉笺偣銉堛偡銉ャ兗銈?鎵嬩綔銈娿偔銉冦儓 teo 銉嗐偑 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銈枫儶銈炽兂 瀵惧繙姗熺óxperia z5 銈便兗銈?銈儛銉? nike air max motion lw se a莽谋k haki kadè°‹n sneaker ayakkabè°‹ 鐢诲儚 銈︺偋銉囥偅…

  39. asztali è´¸rè°©k karè´¸racentrum

    warehouse cotton tie back midi dress dragon ball tennis shoes adidas sheike amazon dress uniqlo cashmere crew neck sweater orvos kæžšpeny gyerekeknek l farsangi jelmezek 鎵句竴闆檙eebok绫冪悆闉?mobile01 joggingbukser med sidestribe uradi sam pozivnice za vjen膷anj…

  40. hoodie schwarz herren

    relogio diesel quadrado relogios longines usados calcinhas diferentes chapeu panama masculino onde comprar all star metalizado chapeu bucket florido chuteira adidas ace 16.3 campo como hacer collares de piedras elegantes zapatillas fg atelier zapatilla…

Comments are closed.