I Come From Nowhere(?)

Andre, , , ,

My dissertation–if you hadn’t already gathered–focuses on the convergence of popular and classical music streams that informs much of Frank Zappa’s music. This confluence means different things in different places (for both Zappa and his audience), but it seems to me to be a defining characteristic that runs through all of his work. My questions here are: Why would this be such an important aspect of his work? and, What influenced him in thinking this way?

Strictly Genteel

On the one hand, Zappa was trying to establish for himself a reputation as a composer of serious art music. His reasons for this are, of course, open to debate, but Zappa was always quick to point out that his ambitions were aesthetically motivated. He was introduced to the modernist music of Stravinsky and Varèse around the same time he began collecting blues and R&B records. Zappa recognized that the disparate styles were commonly seen to be at odds with one another. But since both appealed to him personally, he tried to share this experience of music free from social implications. The obvious way of doing this would be to synthesize these different styles in his own work.

On a slightly different angle, it seems to me that the obvious appeal (and associated cultural capital) of being a respected artist was an equally significant factor. Zappa clearly admired Stravinsky and Varèse (and Webern and Cage, among others) and that he would want to model himself on his “idols” almost goes without saying.

But where does this all come from? What streams (cultural, social, musical) does he fit into? Despite his claims to originality, it seems unlikely that Zappa developed in a bubble.

To begin with, I suspect it may have had something to do with the conservative cultural climate of Southern California in the 1940s and 50s. Zappa saw this environment as oppressive and felt claustrophobic in the rural deserts communities of his youth. For me, Zappa’s self-identification as an outsider is neatly summarized in this 1970 photograph by John Olson of Frank posing with his parents Francis and Rosemary in their home Frank’s Los Angeles home [thanks Corné!]:

Zappa with parents

(Of course, by 1970 Frank had long been out of the house so this picture doesn’t offer an authentic vision of Zappa’s youth. Nonetheless, I think the picture captures much of the spirit of Zappa and his rebellious culture at odds with conservative values, while at the same time offering some ambiguity as to who really belongs in this environment.)

While still a child, he found refuge in the modernist avant-garde. (He would delight in his mother’s recoiling at the sound of Varèse’s sirens being played on the family turntable.) These composers offered a safe mode of rebellion for Zappa in a remarkable way. They were accepted artists–undeniably respectful members of society–whose music had a similar effect with adults to what teenagers experienced with heavy metal in the 1980s.

But I don’t think it ends there. As significant as his rebellion against perceived conservative oppression was, I think there’s something deeper. In discussing when the dichotomy between classical and popular entered the American consciousness, Paul Charosh writes:

We would be mistaken to assume that this division between types of music reflects a simple division between two sets of listeners, one group seeking edification and uplift from classical music and a separate group looking to popular music for a cure for the blues. Some favored light music over serious; others preferred classical music to the popular; but many enjoyed both types of music on different occasions, for different purposes.[1]

Charosh is referring to mid-18th century listeners, but this characterization seems to have some resonance with Zappa’s sentiments a century later. Is this a constant stream in American musical consciousness? Did Zappa inherit this dual validity of opposing musical streams?

For that matter, who else was a part of this? Zappa consistently sought to establish himself as being counter-counterculture. But even as he defined himself against the hippie movement and the politics of the New Left in the 1960s, he took certain aspects of their motivations as his own. Can we consider Zappa to be a part of these movements even if he explicitly denies accepting them?

For now, these thoughts are very preliminary. I don’t have the answers to these questions. (Yet!)

References:
[1] Paul Charosh, “‘Popular’ and ‘Classical’ in the Mid-Nineteenth Century,” American Music, Vol. 10, No. 2 (Summer, 1992), 126.
I Come From Nowhere(?)

32,946 thoughts on “I Come From Nowhere(?)”

  1. Landscape Scenery Mountain Mount Fuji Japan For Huawei Honor Mate Nova Note 20 20s 30 5 5I 5T 6 7I 7C 8A 8X 9X 10 Pro Lite Play

    Supernatural Art Jewelry With Steel Plated Glass Cabochon Choker Long Pendant Rectangle Necklace For Kids Beads Luxury King Queen Crowns Silicone Cases Covers For Galaxy J1 J2 J3 J330 J4 J5 J6 J7 J730 J8 2015 2016 2017 2018 mini Pro TPU Coque For LG G2…

  2. ropa interior de mujer para hombre

    superdry toppi top damen schwarz bekleidung shirts tops bugatti mokassins aus leder in braun online kaufen teenager m盲dchen schulrucksack frauen nylon rucks盲cke geldbeutel esprit schæžšne damen top oberteil gr s styleboom fashion damen handtasche braun b…

  3. asics zapatilla running hombre gel exalt 4 negro gris

    ropa de encaje de mujer en mercado libre argentina timber camiseta corta de manga larga zhuikun pantalones fitness de pitillo name it schlafoverall mit fuss 2 er normani schulter umh盲ngetasche slingfit suprima 4740 druckknopf horarios de apertura kiabi…

  4. BAMOER 925 Sterling Silver Sparkling Mermaid s Tail Blue Enamel Charms Beads fit Bracelets Jewelry Accessory SCC1067

    puma 1 shoulder backpack womens womens urban sports full zip hoodie french terry xs puma kids future 18.1 netfit fg ag shoes puma mens tsugi netfit evoknit camo quiet shade asphalt 12 cheap puma golf shirts spac铆 pytel p茅艡ov媒 pincel winsor newton rolle…

  5. meg茅ri a p茅nz茅t a legjobb laptopok 1

    continental mountain king 2.3 29×2.3 protection l茅gpè°©rnè°©s bubor茅kos bor铆t茅kok m茅rete scheppach sc 40 p benzinmotoros joyer铆a de gargantillas de cinta online cherry wall mount necklace holder bar 20 mejores imè°©genes de modelajes flores cordè´¸n pulsera de…

  6. optimalna rutina njege za zdravu ko啪u osoba s

    5 best toddler suitcases herschel heritage kids backpack black 6 best iphone contact apps to manage your address book 2019 nero giardini nero polacchine scarpe donna bambini converse chuck taylor bambina white sneaker primavera estate briggs and riley…

  7. isy klebebefestigung iaa 1000 f眉r gopro kameras online

    wie erstelle ich eine sitemap meiner website frag sistrix pè°©rty stan nepromokav媒 hoja design obal na jogu vyhledè°©vè°©n铆 na postel z masivn铆ho dubu model sposa zakrsl铆 krè°©l铆ci vzkazy jak si doma vyb臎lit zuby je to samolepky na zdi do d臎tsk茅ho pokoje bezpe…

  8. For Huawei Nova 2 V20 Y3II Y5 Y5II Y6 Y6II Y7 Y9 G8 G9 GR3 GR5 GX8 Prime 2018 2019 Soft Capa Case Anime Mob Psycho 100

    For Huawei Honor 4C 5A 5C 5X 6 6A 6X 7 7A 7C 7X 8 8C 8S 9 10 10i 20 20i Lite Pro Soft Capa Broken Screen Pattern New Personalized Phone Accessories Case For Xiaomi Redmi Note 2 3 3S 4 4A 4X 5 5A 6 6A Pro Plus Mountains Bamboo Case For Galaxy J1 J2 J3 J…

  9. elegantn铆 voln谩 prodlou啪en谩 d谩msk谩 halenka tunika b铆l谩

    pè°©nsk茅 tenisky nike sb zoom stefan janoski barva noise aqua tehotensk茅 3 4 nohavice fabiana jeans s l dè°©msk茅 zimn铆 boty do sn臎hu a vysokè°© zimn铆 obuv hi tec italian army training tracksuit peter grimm ford drifter hat dark brown velkoobchod bi啪uterie a…

  10. 魏伪蟻蠈蟿蟽喂 魏萎蟺慰蠀 85l 79蠂57蠂71.5 cm

    丕噩賲賱 亘賳丕胤賷賱 丕爻賰賷賳賷 賲卮賱禺 2019 氐賵乇 噩丿賷丿丞 賱亘賳胤丕賱 噩賷賳夭 賱賱氐亘丕賷丕 氐賵乇 賮爻丕 è³·è³³ 丕胤賮丕賱 2020 丕丨賱賶 賲賵丿賷賱丕 賮爻丕 è³·è³³ 丕胤賮丕賱 賲氐乇丕賵賶 丕賱卮丕賲賱 shoe of the day aquazzura tequila crystal studded leather new womens retro 60s court shoes heels mod target madcap vintage penny red…

  11. Hot Super Baby Mom Girl Boy For Huawei P7 P8 P9 P10 P20 P30 Lite Mini Plus Pro Y9 Prime P Smart Z 2018 2019 TPU Cases

    Airplane Cockpits For Huawei Honor Mate Nova Note 20 20s 30 5 5I 5T 6 7I 7C 8A 8X 9X 10 Pro Lite Play TPU Screen Protector For Kids Beads Vintage Jewelry Steel Plated With Glass Cabochon Choker Long Pendant Rectangle Necklace Sleeping Beauty Aurora Mob…

  12. nahaufnahme von sonnenlicht filterung

    caso profi folienbeutel 20x30cm braun rasierer 9365cc s9 silber nobel metall logo sweatshirt calvin klein billig naketano dunkelgr眉n jacken damen online t shirts und bekleidung g眉nstig selbst gestalten und bedrucken language is not innocent dovo soling…

  14. geldbæžšrse tommy hilfiger

    nike air max jewell premium chilirose corsage cr4320 creme creme in oberbekleidung bolso bandolera bandolera militar 300 bolsas friselina 45×40 ecolè´¸gicas personalizadas once irresistibles en la playa zapatilla mujer 0111 burdeo poeme zapatilla mujer 0…

  15. gyç–Ÿrt aljç…¤ szaggatott farmer nadrè°©g

    leo sz艖rme gall茅ros ræžšvid fazonç…¤ n艖i kabè°©t 19950 ft fjall raven 2in1 extra profi l茅legz艖 a legjobb csalè°©di programok h茅tv茅g茅re anteojos masculinos con iman en mercado libre argentina selyem kæžšntæžšs szett webdivat webè°©ruhè°©z szaunaszoknya frott铆r n艖i n茅vr…

  16. kinbor metal negro armario rack de almacenamiento organizador

    napozè´¸sz茅k napoz贸谩gy strandsz茅k nyugè°©gy k茅k feh茅r tenger茅szcs铆kos bauer vapor 1x luistimet sr captain hockey verkkokauppa vahvistetut pinnat 36kpl borg toilettilaukku bx160405 musta banggood akciè´¸s telefonok elektromos autè´¸pè°©lya jè°©t茅k move kontroller p…

  17. qoqa grandhall gril è„¿ gaz t 2

    donna cardigan in lino misto cotone tshirt personalizzate per donna con point de vente discount v锚tements femme sarah pacini pantalon7 8 kit mad prise usb 2.0 茅tanche fixation guidon high tech moto manteau de ski alpin descente layla il marchio del mad…

  18. under armour thin blue line hoodie

    boho chiffon wedding dress motorcycle footwear under armour ua mens baseline tank top basketball tank top under armour black high tops girls new under armour 1269693 highlight molded football cleats men size 10 navy white under armour girls color block…

  19. chaussons ballerines isotoner en coton velours prune i igert

    redondo marco lente transparente gafas guantes barato oneal digger glove accesorios turquesa ropa de juneo tk901 tkstar dieb mini traceur en temps r茅el portable nike 270 corail speed wave tè°©virè°©ny铆tè´¸s hajè´¸ jamara mç–Ÿanyag è°©ll铆thatè´¸ è´¸ra hot eye care mask…

  20. dirkje steppelt kisl谩ny kab谩t 116 sz眉rke

    style co. petite dresses shopstyle beaded gold embroidered bodice quinceanera dress gl2208 64 dark green deep v sexy evening dress with high collar neck disney soy luna hè°©zi papucs fanni cip艖 茅s mesebolt large spiked leather dog collar red oak dark bro…

  21. baskets basses fille pas cher vans old skool soldes

    sac de voyage en cuir pour femme symbole de polo ralph lauren la marque phare de la soci茅t茅 converse chuck taylor all star ox vert t 44 1 2 Emmababy 2019 nuevos calcetines de algodè´¸n de dibujos animados para beb茅 Chico ni帽a ni帽o peque帽o hasta la rodill…

  22. new balance 490v6 mens acteva athletic running shoes

    corona krisen tvinger wagner baby buddy magisk talende spejl laptop madeinnorway instagram posts té…¶j pæ°“ afbetaling tienda botas hombre billeteras y accesorios para hombres burberry 555573 qxuornt camiseta jurassic park t.rex vintage comprar agora bandu…

  23. TPU Print Phone Cover Case For LG G2 G3 G4 G5 G6 G7 K4 K7 K8 K10 K12 K40 Mini Plus Stylus ThinQ 2016 2017 2018 Colorful Geometry

    For Galaxy Grand A3 A5 A7 A8 A9 A9S On5 On7 Plus Pro Star 2015 2016 2017 2018 Soft TPU Cool Best French Bulldog Dog Pug Jimin Handsome For Huawei Honor Mate 7 7A 8 9 10 20 V8 V9 V10 V30 P40 G Lite Play Mini Pro P Smart Silicone Case Soft Fashion Origin…

  24. miu miu shoulder bag sale

    vestidos zara fiesta vestidos de mujer azul marino en vila viseeba dress vestido de tubo clematis blue jersey sonia by sonia rykiel mujer vestido en lana mezclada negro promotion dress llovizna hermoso 3d flor cordè´¸n franc茅s panasonic be啪i膷ni telefon k…

  25. For HTC Desire 530 626 628 630 816 820 830 One A9 M7 M8 M9 M10 E9 U11 U12 Life Plus Soft TPU Capa Cover Days Gone

    Fashion Necklace Handmade Rectangle Shape Choker Necklace Jewelry Multi Designs For Women New Pug Puppy Dog One Piece Luffy Anime For Huawei Honor 4C 5A 5C 5X 6 6A 6X 7 7A 7C 7X 8 8C 8S 9 10 10i 20 20i Lite Pro Silicone Phone Cover For Huawei Honor Mat…

  26. under armour gemini 2.5 women gold

    polka dot dress rust ecg instrument accessoire de rangement salle de bain buy matrix online ted baker light blue bag under armour ua coldgear infrared softershell jacket for women nike shox n4 nike therma hood best face protection cold weather toscana…

  27. n95 mask pm2.5

    la france è„¿ la coupe du monde de foot quechua szandè°©l huoju 12 couleurs de maquillage liquide coussin bain soleil pas cher detalles detalles para hombre botella set vino abalibodas bufanda de invierno 2016 nueva caliente mujer zapatos de tacè´¸n venta bi…

  28. elgydium 慰未慰谓蟿慰尾慰蠀蟻蟿蟽蔚蟼 慰未慰谓蟿蠈尾慰蠀蟻蟿蟽蔚蟼

    ply拧ovè°© my拧 malè°© 14cm ræš–zn茅 barvy black signature logo t shirt front ruched cowl velvet midi dress champagne by npire london free tote beauty samples with 125 purchase 丕賱毓丕亘 卮乇丕亍 賲賱丕亘爻 兀胤賮丕賱 亘丕乇亘賷 丕賱乇噩丕賱 賲賳 丕賱賲乇賷禺 賵丕賱賳爻丕亍 賲賳 丕賱夭賴乇丞 丨賯賷亘丞 爻賵賯 賳爻丕卅賷丞 乇丕卅…

  29. disfraz unicornio

    women global sales puma vikky platform ribbon p sneakers buy puma ferrari 18.5 ltrs black casual backpack 7395202 running shoes puma mobium elite v2 lazy girl running authentic women cherry tomato puma pants puma x ader error puma ignite evoknit kids p…

  30. Moon Spells Makeup Diy Painted Beautiful For Galaxy Grand A3 A5 A7 A8 A9 A9S On5 On7 Plus Pro Star 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Design Fashion Vintage Glass Women Rectangle Necklace Pendants For Unisex Gift Smoking Lion Man Woman Colourful Style Ladybug TPU New Arrival For Xiaomi Redmi Mi 4 7A 9T K20 CC9 CC9e Note 7 8 9 Y3 SE Pro Prime Go Play TPU Mobile Cases Covers For HTC De…

  31. jordan 12 pink and gold

    nike duckboot low 2020 waterfall coat rebecca vallance flores slip dress adidas zx 750 white blue helios type 69 preamp and eq collection vans ua style 73 dx sneaker nordstrom official new york rangers gear 2020 nike uptempo ebay nike vapormax moc blac…

  32. annova and partners at nab 2018

    acra vesta reflexn铆 b臎啪eckè°© 2 druhy cestovè°©n铆 po africe zv铆艡ata v媒chodn铆 samsung 4k fernseher 300 euro bettvolant betthusse spannbetttuch abschlu脽test schritte2 a1.2 dezinfekce anti covid 500 ml rozpra拧ova膷 sheron nike 拧ed茅 pè°©nsk茅 tenisky z brou拧en茅 d艡…

  33. green bay packers alumni folding camping chair

    mondaine heren horloges kopen gratis levering gewa klarinet gigbag koffer bestellen online via much up to 48 off on womens fitness themed t shirt groupon goods nova e mail adresa podru啪nice gradska groblja zagreba膷ki crna bomber jakna movida dje膷je zim…

  34. long sleeve beaded ball gown champagne

    pantalones para hombre azul de jeans jeans rasgados rectos catalogo vanesa duran 2019 pdf catalogos online hubsch tischlampe gr眉n metall 25w h眉bsch deckenleuchte h盲ngeleuchte esszimmer lampe pendelleuchte magna 45 kupfer matt beleuchtung divat 茅kszer a…

  35. 转住转讻诇讜 讗讬讝讛 诪讘爪注 诇讞讬讬诇讬诐 fxp

    descargar libros gratis 50 mejores pintura de rodas grafite pre莽o s茫o bernardo do campo pintura de billige toiletmé…¶bler ildfaste skæ°“le plateau traiteur inox poli miroir gn1 1 stl sarl materiels installation dextinction automatique par gaz. gaz modulair…

  37. 砖诪诇转 注专讘 拽爪专讛 转讞专讛 砖讞讜专讛

    pasternak martine. 爪诪讬讚 讝讛讘 讗讚讜诐 注讬爪讜讘 诪讬讜讞讚 诪讘讬转 讛讬爪专谉 讛诪讜讘讬诇 诪爪讘专 讘专讞讜讘讜转 诇专讻讘 诇讗讜驻谞讜注 讜注讜讚 砖讬专讜转 注讚 讗诇讬讻诐 24 砖注讜转 砖专砖专转 讗专讜讻讛 专讬讘讜注讬诐 诪讬谞讬 爪讬驻讜讬 讝讛讘 讻诇 讛砖专砖专讗讜转 lenovo laptop urban backpack blue 15.6 讛砖讜讜讗转 诪讞讬专讬诐 讜住拽讬专讜转 诪讻讜谞转 转住驻讜专转 wahl classic s…

  39. 煤j 眉l茅srendet vezethet be a wizz air a j谩rv谩ny ut谩n

    comparatif et avis juventus maillot manches longues juve protocole de routage bas茅 sur des bicicletas de paseo diesel diesel chrono dz4308 f茅rfi è´¸ra timecenter diesel è´¸ra f茅rfi feh茅r deszkè°©s cip艖 owya shop guantes barato oneal digger glove accesorios t…

  40. ly啪a艡sk茅 boty sportovn铆 pot艡eby daruji za odvoz

    herbst fr眉hling cartoon casual langarmshirts jungen m盲dchen print emperita corsage fashionmoon 膷铆na nejlep拧铆 jednorè°©zov茅 prost臎radla dodavatel茅 a v媒robci toothbrush icon toothpaste symbol flat stockfotos toothbrush kost眉m tiger f眉r kinder online kinder…

  41. vestido largo con amarra cuello cintura elasticada rojo

    herm猫s birkin 35 blue orange special order hss bag baghunter yves st. laurent style is eternal the purple lemonade menos por vestidos 200 de euros comuniè´¸n invitaciones en cajita para boda economicas recuerdos pinko scarpe donna autunno inverno 2018 19…

  42. 蟺伪喂蠂谓委未喂伪 lego 纬喂伪 蟺伪喂未喂维 5 蔚蟿蠋谓

    krtek s kulichem 啪luto 膷erv. 20cm ply拧谩k vè°©no膷n铆 dè°©rkov茅 poukazy zas铆lè°©me mailem v pln茅 kvalit臎 pro heart pocket watch tiles lemon pillowcase set michael jordan blue polo shirt 賰賵丿 丕賱丕毓賱丕賳 賲毓賱賵賲丕 毓賳 丕賱廿毓賱丕賳 è³² 噩乇 è³² 賳賵毓 賲賳丿賵亘丞 兀爻毓丕乇 賴賵丕 è³® 丕賱丌賷賮賵賳 丕賱乇爻賲賷丞…

  43. top asym茅trique femme. blanc 3 suisses

    ralph lauren herr træžšja stickat kæžšp pæ°“ tradera s盲ng med madrass græžšn sammet 180×200 cm st盲ms fæžšr fejkade dejtingprofiler. tinders 盲gare lurade best盲lla locktæ°“ng brusreducerande hæžšrlurar b盲st i test ceramic basket liten fl盲tad pantalon homme taille 茅las…

  45. Soft TPU Custom Design Beauty Flower For Huawei Nova 2 V20 Y3II Y5 Y5II Y6 Y6II Y7 Y9 G8 G9 GR3 GR5 GX8 Prime 2018 2019

    The Little Prince For Sony Xperia Z Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Z5 compact Mini M2 M4 M5 T3 E3 E5 XA XA1 XZ Premium TPU Transparent Skin Cover Supernatural Jensen Ackles Jared TPU Protector For Huawei Honor 4C 5A 5C 5X 6 6A 6X 7 7A 7C 7X 8 8C 8S 9 10 10i 20 20i Lite P…

  46. check it out roxy sun hat for 6.99 on thredup

    gucci ace 2019 cruise sneakers 457132 a38g0 9064 zapatillas rhyton blanco anorak broad peak light in de mujer traje de ninja samsung linea blanca vuelos interjet tripie para letrero mejores raquetas de padel calidad precio raza perro chizu control remo…

  47. puppia mountaineer ii dzseki 茅s h谩m

    survetement homme adidas ann茅es 90 vinted appareil auditif france prix digitè°©lis led è´¸ra h艖m茅r艖vel asztali 茅s fali è´¸ra term茅kek valè´¸di sz艖rmebundè°©k progressz铆v lencse è°©rak puma f茅rfi puma epoch storm dzseki xxl masca fashion n艖i term茅kek masca fashion…

  48. 泻褉芯褋褋芯胁泻懈 薪邪泄泻 褝泄褉

    banana split hat puma pu911031002 watches puma men watches at puma evopower vigor 1 ebay jiik 7192 puma bodytrain mesh toning shoes hite purple hats gloves mcelhinneys new era 9forty cap jersey new york yankees grey pa帽uelos seda el corte ingles jbl fl…

  49. vestidos de ba帽o manga larga para dama

    incipio ngp advanced huawei p20 lite case with textured back and honeycombed interior for huawei p20 lite tablet case for ipad pro 12.9 genuine leather case for samsung galaxy s3 s4 s5 mini s6 s7 edge s8 plus note 2 3 4 5 grand core prime benelli defen…

  50. hecht trambulin v茅d艖h谩l贸val 214 cm elektromos kisaut贸k

    knå¿™sokker sté…¶t brysterne ré…¶d seneste new balance 420 pink guld sneakers dame pæ°“ tilbud ké…¶b indendé…¶rs trampoliner pæ°“ t shirt langå¿™rmet tshirt tré…¶je sort carhartt midweight sweatshirt med lynlæ°“s og hå¿™tte mé…¶rkegræ°“ armani exchange con 40 de descuento en ro…

Comments are closed.