I Come From Nowhere(?)

Andre, , , ,

My dissertation–if you hadn’t already gathered–focuses on the convergence of popular and classical music streams that informs much of Frank Zappa’s music. This confluence means different things in different places (for both Zappa and his audience), but it seems to me to be a defining characteristic that runs through all of his work. My questions here are: Why would this be such an important aspect of his work? and, What influenced him in thinking this way?

Strictly Genteel

On the one hand, Zappa was trying to establish for himself a reputation as a composer of serious art music. His reasons for this are, of course, open to debate, but Zappa was always quick to point out that his ambitions were aesthetically motivated. He was introduced to the modernist music of Stravinsky and Varèse around the same time he began collecting blues and R&B records. Zappa recognized that the disparate styles were commonly seen to be at odds with one another. But since both appealed to him personally, he tried to share this experience of music free from social implications. The obvious way of doing this would be to synthesize these different styles in his own work.

On a slightly different angle, it seems to me that the obvious appeal (and associated cultural capital) of being a respected artist was an equally significant factor. Zappa clearly admired Stravinsky and Varèse (and Webern and Cage, among others) and that he would want to model himself on his “idols” almost goes without saying.

But where does this all come from? What streams (cultural, social, musical) does he fit into? Despite his claims to originality, it seems unlikely that Zappa developed in a bubble.

To begin with, I suspect it may have had something to do with the conservative cultural climate of Southern California in the 1940s and 50s. Zappa saw this environment as oppressive and felt claustrophobic in the rural deserts communities of his youth. For me, Zappa’s self-identification as an outsider is neatly summarized in this 1970 photograph by John Olson of Frank posing with his parents Francis and Rosemary in their home Frank’s Los Angeles home [thanks Corné!]:

Zappa with parents

(Of course, by 1970 Frank had long been out of the house so this picture doesn’t offer an authentic vision of Zappa’s youth. Nonetheless, I think the picture captures much of the spirit of Zappa and his rebellious culture at odds with conservative values, while at the same time offering some ambiguity as to who really belongs in this environment.)

While still a child, he found refuge in the modernist avant-garde. (He would delight in his mother’s recoiling at the sound of Varèse’s sirens being played on the family turntable.) These composers offered a safe mode of rebellion for Zappa in a remarkable way. They were accepted artists–undeniably respectful members of society–whose music had a similar effect with adults to what teenagers experienced with heavy metal in the 1980s.

But I don’t think it ends there. As significant as his rebellion against perceived conservative oppression was, I think there’s something deeper. In discussing when the dichotomy between classical and popular entered the American consciousness, Paul Charosh writes:

We would be mistaken to assume that this division between types of music reflects a simple division between two sets of listeners, one group seeking edification and uplift from classical music and a separate group looking to popular music for a cure for the blues. Some favored light music over serious; others preferred classical music to the popular; but many enjoyed both types of music on different occasions, for different purposes.[1]

Charosh is referring to mid-18th century listeners, but this characterization seems to have some resonance with Zappa’s sentiments a century later. Is this a constant stream in American musical consciousness? Did Zappa inherit this dual validity of opposing musical streams?

For that matter, who else was a part of this? Zappa consistently sought to establish himself as being counter-counterculture. But even as he defined himself against the hippie movement and the politics of the New Left in the 1960s, he took certain aspects of their motivations as his own. Can we consider Zappa to be a part of these movements even if he explicitly denies accepting them?

For now, these thoughts are very preliminary. I don’t have the answers to these questions. (Yet!)

References:
[1] Paul Charosh, “‘Popular’ and ‘Classical’ in the Mid-Nineteenth Century,” American Music, Vol. 10, No. 2 (Summer, 1992), 126.
I Come From Nowhere(?)

32,946 thoughts on “I Come From Nowhere(?)”

  1. Popular Case For Galaxy Alpha Note 10 Pro A10 A20 A20E A30 A40 A50 A60 A70 A80 A90 M10 M20 M30 M40 Various Stars

    Bride Of Frankenstein TPU Pattern For Galaxy Note 10 A10E A10S A20S A30S A40S A50S A6S A70S A730 A8S M10S M30S Lite Plus Soft TPU Cell Case Weed Leaf Grass Huf For Galaxy Alpha Note 10 Pro A10 A20 A20E A30 A40 A50 A60 A70 A80 A90 M10 M20 M30 M40 TPU De…

  2. Positive Good Vibe Only Love Happy Trust Quote Glass Pendant Necklace Handmade Half Pendant Rectangle Necklace For Unisex

    Yoga Studio Printed Glass Pendant Galaxy Pendant Necklace Women Steel Plated Necklaces Jewelry For Girls Gifts For Galaxy Note 10 A10E A10S A20S A30S A40S A50S A6S A70S A730 A8S M10S M30S Lite Plus Skin Pattern Cute Flowers 1 Transparent Soft Shell Piz…

  3. jednodielne plavky biele

    collar para perros para que no ladren mapa valparaiso santiago luces led philips para autos ropa bebe 0 meses herramientas de taladrar yorkshire comida falda para danza cristiana productos para manicure chile pulover v茅膷ko biely ara sandè°©le biele dè°©msk…

  4. pollution mask for daily use

    fila disruptor mirror asics hiking shoes matalan black maxi dress under armour mens camo 2.0 cap barren charcoal black osfa under armour ua charged core grey orange red mens trail running shoes hiking boots mens ua unstoppable move light crew red long…

  5. 4 unids set para AUSTAR de rueda con buje llantas para HSP HPI TAMIYA KYOSHO YOKOMO 1 10 RC en carretera a la deriva coche Hub

    nike air max 1 premium sc black metallic silver white 2018 pas cher femme baskets basses converse ctas sawyer cvs 4PCS 1 9 Metal Beadlock rueda llanta para 1 10 RC Crawler Traxxas Hsp Redcat Rc4wd Tamiya Axial Scx10 D90 Hpi neumè°©tico Accesorios chaussu…

  6. monopoly najnovije i naj膷itanije vijesti

    versa orologio parete peonfly lungo cardigan femminile 2018 ha lavorato a maglia un bicchiere di vino rosso 猫 stata punta vuota di sale exquisite slipon in camoscio scarpe italiane per donna blu tommy hilfiger active city sneaker 990 pj masks naljepnic…

  7. real viking armour

    under armour adult hustle soccer shorts soccer equipment under armour boys ua match play polo under armour micro g speed swift running shoes ladies grey under armour x project rock range duffel cheap party decorations respirador 6200 3m completo mascar…

  8. bikini estampado floral verano 2019

    jungs skull hoodie blau kids hits ab wann baby kissen abendkleid ballkleid spitze party kleid shirt mit spitze an den seiten gr.s h m obsessive damen string unterhose spitze unterw盲sche obsessive 853 online shop per rechnung ba帽ador hombre turbo waterp…

  9. stanley bostitch fn1664k replacement blow molded

    brio 33512 vl谩膷kodrè°©ha velkè°© s v媒hybkami dè°©mskè°© kotn铆kovè°© obuv zna膷ky westport l 82 119 171 97 opasky pro plno拧t铆hl茅 啪eny a d铆vky 廿毓賱丕賳 毓賳 賵馗賷賮丞 賲丿賯賯 丿丕禺賱賷 賱賱賴賷卅丞 賲賵賯毓 禺亘乇賳賷 賮賱丕賷 噩賵乇丿賳 賳賮賷 賮爻丕 è³·è³³ 爻賴乇丞 賱賱亘賷毓 賮賷 賲丿賷賳丞 丕賱賰賵賷 爻賵賯 丕賱賴賵丕 è³® .. 丕賱氐賷賳賶 賷丨賰賲 賵丕賱…

  10. herramienta electrè´¸nica

    fritzi aus preu脽en oble膷enie pre deti nov茅 detsk茅 mè´¸dne trendy na jar 2018 pre v拧etky 啪eny bez rozdielu veku pr铆vesok na mobil flower light rose swarovski elements sw088 ruksak vans realm backpack rose checkerboard lee cooper high cut 1 lcw 19 530 041…

  11. how to choose a good camera for youtube video recording or streaming

    拽讬讚讜诐 讗转专讬诐 讘讘讬谞讙 讛砖讜讜讗讛 讘讬谉 讘讬谞讙 my goodies 讗讜讚讜转讬谞讜 诪讜爪专讬诐 诪讬讜讞讚讬诐 砖拽 砖讬谞讛 诇住诇拽诇 讗驻讜专 砖讬诇讘 hella lygter til lastbiler hæ°“rbé…¶rste ghd serenze. 2019 erkek hæ°“rband i sammet fl盲ta wine accessoarer bosch su拧ilica rublja wtx87eh0eu epilujeme bez bolesti a ç…¤…

  12. bois autoclave avec toboggan portique

    nenuco le landau pas cher achat vente pu茅riculture poup茅es air force 1 43 velo route giant 2019 costume femme halloween pas cher marcas de bambas deportivas mtb economicas linternas potentes recargables en el vibrant 2019 maillot basket nba nba chicago…

  13. lowepro flipside 200 aw ii fekete lo37125 fotè´¸s hè°©tizsè°©k

    nem sz茅les铆ti a cs铆p艖t a anita 3514 amica komfort fç–Ÿz艖 sk8 hi uniszex b艖r tornacip艖 vans got2b powderful dç…¤s铆tè´¸ hajformè°©zè´¸ por testreszabott nem szæžšvæžštt bevè°©sè°©rlè´¸tè°©ska laminè°©lè´¸ beszè°©ll铆tè´¸kkal è°©rkè°©d cip艖boltok blouson femme ixon torque lady cuir col v f…

  14. Design Fashion Vintage Glass Women Rectangle Necklace Pendants For Women Girls Handmade Cool Art Astronaut Space Moon

    Jewelry With Steel Plated Glass Cabochon Choker Long Pendant Rectangle Necklace For Women Men Blue Marble Pattern Print Design Screen Hannibal Eat The Rude Diy Painted For Galaxy Note 10 A10E A10S A20S A30S A40S A50S A6S A70S A730 A8S M10S M30S Lite Pl…

  15. hebillas militares de segunda mano en valencia en wallapop

    adidas adiease f茅rfi cip艖 feh茅r floral desigual piros æžšv basic æžšvek hè°©tizsè°©k nike ba5405 622 cahier des charges de la r茅gion alsace mercato webshop term茅k jb gorjuss laptop tè°©ska l botas nieve ni帽o decathlon ropa masculina una bufanda para un d铆a fr铆o.…

  16. vache jouet

    tornillos easy.cl venta de gafas de realidad virtual compra chujian lavabo plegable for moto de bateria recargable con luces led sexy traje de ba帽o hombre ac marca 2017 traje de ba帽o de los vendo top house led 40 se va con zapatillas adidas golf mujer…

  17. women saucony high jump spikes

    forever free felvarrè´¸ shark n roll hausmeister hm8200 h艖sugè°©rzè´¸ media markt online vè°©sè°©rlè°©s n艖i s es fekete v茅kony kæžštæžštt kardigè°©n 1089 ft ç…¤j inox 6 lè°©ngos ipari gè°©ztç–Ÿzhely 7 kw os 茅gæžškkel garanciè°©val bershka sorte sté…¶vler med hé…¶je hå¿™le let dunjakke fr…

  20. pme legend skymaster obv

    san francisco giants hawaiian shirt large dare to wear glitter marc opolo badjas miro offwhite le chic winterjas kopen collectie 2019 2020 ishrana u trudno膰i za zdravu majku i bebu dobre kalorije stanmore zimska radna jakna 3u1 radne jakne radna odje膰a

  21. pack calcetines hombre gucci

    TWOTWINSTYLE Mermaid Skirt Female High Waist Bodycon Ruffles Patchwork Irregular Midi Skirts Spring Fashion OL 2020 Clothing TWOTWINSTYLE Mesh Patchwork Women s Dress V Neck Sleeveless High Waist Lace Up Elegant Ball Gown Dresses Female 2020 Fashion UM…

  24. 廿乇 賮丕毓 兀爻毓丕乇 丕賱兀亘賯丕乇 賵丕賱賲賵丕賱賵賳 賷卮 賰賵賳

    è³°è³·è³® 廿賱賶 丕賷賰賱賵賵丿 睾賷賷乇 毓賳賵丕賳 丕賱亘乇賷丿 丕賱廿賱賰 乇賵賳賷 賲賵囟丞 卮 丕亍 2019 丕丨丿孬 賲賵丿賷賱丕 丕丨匕賷丞 賳爻丕卅賷丞 賮賶 賮氐賱 丕賱卮 丕亍 丨匕丕亍 丕賱禺丕氐 亘丕賱兀賯丿丕賲 丕賱丨爻丕爻丞 è³µ 賲乇囟賶 丕賱爻賰乇賷 胤賳胤丕 666632 butterfly embellished mini lady dior bag fashion very rare fossil pocket watch snoopy li limited qu…

  25. Animal Cut Orange Cat Soft TPU Best Cases For Motorola G G2 G3 G4 G5 G6 G7 Plus For Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 8A 8T 10 K30 5G Pro

    For Galaxy J1 J2 J3 J330 J4 J5 J6 J7 J730 J8 2015 2016 2017 2018 mini Pro TPU Phone Cases Original Summer Beaches Surfing Girls You’re My Person Greys Anatomy Soft Pattern Phone For Xiaomi Redmi Mi 4 7A 9T K20 CC9 CC9e Note 7 8 9 Y3 SE Pro Prime Go Pl…

  26. de 3 bedste steder at gemme sex

    stan smith bd7438 easy yellow ftwr ko go n艖i kæžšntæžšs feliratozott mç–Ÿb艖r p茅nztè°©rca æžšræžšmanya ruha molett 16 gyerek emeletes è°©gy modern gyerek 茅s phil n艖i divattè°©ska sæžšt茅tbarna sz铆nç–Ÿ sell艖 flitteres est茅lyi ruha cool fashion gumicsè´¸nak elektromos motorral…

  27. encontrar mè°©s conjuntos de ciclismo informaciè´¸n acerca de las

    t茅l茅viseur 4k smart 55139 cm philips 55pus6804 12 led blouse imprim茅e bleu fille oka茂di oba茂bi jeux plage n艖ies ez眉st karlè°©nc 茅kszerbæžšrze karè´¸ra sport 茅s divatè´¸rè°©k emporio armani retro ar8039 ker茅kpè°©ros ruhè°©zat 茅s kieg茅sz铆t艖k a tej mell艖l kemk blog mas…

  28. TPU Case Crazy Animal City For Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 8A 8T 10 K30 5G Pro For Motorola G G2 G3 G4 G5 G6 G7 Plus

    Loves Heart For Huawei Honor Mate 7 7A 8 9 10 20 V8 V9 V10 V30 P40 G Lite Play Mini Pro P Smart Top Detailed Popular Case For Huawei Honor Mate 7 7A 8 9 10 20 V8 V9 V10 V30 P40 G Lite Play Mini Pro P Smart Soft TPU Print Cover Case Cool Girl Classic So…

  29. busco hombre santiago mujer busca hombre

    top 15 des meilleurs gants moto hiver a szexi hè°©lè´¸ingek divatosak 茅s komfortosak hagyma fesztivè°©l f茅rfi b艖r aktatè°©ska fekete sz铆nç–Ÿ nam lugal zè°©m铆tè°©stechnikai bt min艖s茅gi hasznè°©lt ruha 艖szi t茅li kollekciè´¸ budapest k茅zmç–Ÿves term茅kek c铆mke legfrissebb cik…

  30. loreal pro fiber maska za obnavljanje 200 ml

    iscream silver metallic weekender bag with rainbow zipper tory burch bags for less acciaio inossidabile anello fidanzamento coppia fedi nuziali ugg ugg snow stivali sheepskin donna delicate colors louis vuitton garment bag for sale craigslist wheeled p…

  31. pull kenzo tiger femme

    Mordedor de madera de haya para beb茅s colgante de denticiè´¸n para ni帽os accesorios para beb茅s 5 pulgadas giratorio original noria marco de foto molinillo con escultura 12 Uds foto decoraciè´¸n del hogar boda fiesta suministros Bolsos de hombro de cuero PU…

  32. denny rose tuta donna abbigliamento

    jag 盲r i fræžš himlen revolution pro foundation drops f1 colombo bandeau crop top black bing padded bandeau soft strech chantelle maternites 65101 005 neon orange bodysuit new with tags thong lace depop buy melissa doug abby and emma deluxe magnetic wood…

  33. garments shop just interior for sale

    cinturino nato pelle beige da 20 mm hx fashion vestiti donna eleganti corti estivi magliette t shirt con tasca laterale nero vestido midi asim茅trico de punto de canal茅 con doble capa en tsuki moda japonesa vestido casual bata holgado bohemio top corto…

  34. zapatillas superstar 80s adidas off 50

    deportivas nike precios camisa casual fashion elegante en color merrell primo breeze ii taupe slip on estilo tradicional. dise帽o sencillo y ummaid mujer zapatos deportivos plano zapatillas de running timberland britton hill wingtip leather chlo茅 lauren…

  35. pro dg jump triple pencil case

    nike zoom kyrie 3 ep youth big white rainbow luminous kid shoes celine bag fashion black designer bag celine my style dje膷ja vre膰a za sjedenje comfort junior oxford black under armour oprema cg armour block gr leg gaming 拧alice i 膷a拧e asos scarpe in sa…

  36. 褕懈泻邪褉薪褘械 斜芯褋芯薪芯卸泻懈 薪邪 褕锌懈谢褜泻械 懈 胁褘褋芯泻芯泄 褋泻褉褘褌芯泄 锌谢邪褌褎芯褉屑械

    gucci 2019 ss unisex street style silver necklaces chokers summer three ways sincerely jules slide de camur莽a com duplo g cè´¸mo vestir en verano sin dejar atrè°©s el estilo women tian soft gg supreme tote puma floral backpacks for womens fitted cap white…

  37. 屑邪谐邪蟹懈薪褘 屑褍卸褋泻懈褏 褎褍褌斜芯谢芯泻 胁 褋褌械褉谢懈褌邪屑邪泻械 胁械褖懈 芯褌 写芯褉芯谐懈褏

    INFLATION Men Hoodies Oversized Men Color block Design Hoodie Drawstring Hood Men Pullover Hoodie For Autumn Winter 9606W INFLATION Men Shirt Funny Cartoon Digital Printing Shirt Men Streetwear Long Sleeve Shirts 2019 AW New Male Shirts 92142W Simplee…

  38. heren new balance sneakers perrysport

    啪enski kaput linda 107.9 km jakne i kaputi old navy rain toddler mens slim fit short sleeve button down dress shirt 2 pack mens adidas diogo dalot red manchester united 18 19 home authentic jersey dallas cowboys fedora hat sport brim holiday birthday g…

  39. 4 gb samsung laptop ram eladè´¸ aukciè´¸

    usaopoly clue the walking dead edition ferme en jouet pas cher nike 270 corail cuisinette bebe fiche technique iris plus pdf asics v锚tements femme running veste accelerate femme 106.99 szoknya velç…¤rb艖r utè°©nzatbè´¸l konyaksz铆n adidas originals pè´¸lè´¸ zæžšld m…

  40. cappotti e giacche da donna neri pinko in poliestere

    metallo pieces orecchini gold coloured donna orecchini dettagli su collana oro giallo 750 18 kt rosa dei venti catenina uomo donna nuova gr 6 unutarnja rasvjeta dekorativna led traka sa daljinskim 150 led rgb 5m 膷udesna mo膰 lavande annunci gratuiti mat…

  41. adornos bufandas y pa帽uelos de mujer

    blu amante ez眉st karkæžšt艖 bbr022ah kokt茅lruhè°©k kokt茅lruha 18 211 guess szem眉vegkeret gu2616 50092 n艖i sz铆nes 茅vfordulè´¸ra f茅nyk茅pes bæžšgre pole cyclisme saumurois multifonctions laser monochrome maillot equipe de france vintage adidas training shirt port茅…

  42. mobil beskyttelse 15 x 25 mm

    msgm minijupe 茅vas茅e è„¿ taille haute femme classique jupes edition belfort h茅ricourt montb茅liard le ton monte dans besace homme bandouli猫re robe courte en tricot manches longues col amovible femme ivoire mini robe pour femme pull è„¿ pois imprim茅 pois noi…

  44. Llavero del mundo mejor pap谩 Moom cita llavero de la familia del amor llaveros del coche regalo del D铆a de la madre regalo del D铆a del Padre

    off white stré…¶mpebukse snow fly 84 cm. snowboard og ball aktiviteter spor best pris pæ°“ bjé…¶rn då¿™hlie confidence t skjorte se ta kontakt for tilbud stré…¶mberg badekar dusj vest courte femme vestes en tweed sur mesure montre homme dylan mk8295 bracelet en…

  45. mother daughter bikini swimsuit 2019

    haut femme blanc avec fermeture 茅clair l盲sarnas egna skafferier washing raw denim jeans todd shelton blog nè°©u拧nice z chirurgick茅 oceli d臎tsk茅 giant samolepilne nalepke za kolo blaser boty zimn铆 obuv pro myslivce mysliveckè°© obuv attivare o disattivare i…

  46. tigha heren kleding collectie 2020 goedkoop sale

    fotografija izdelkov lifestyle oprema za pse fotomorgana kineska najbolja crna ko啪na kozmeti膷ka torbica dobavlja膷i 拧kolska torba santoro anatomska new era kids 9forty batman baseball cap comic character grey cowboylaarzen nodig bekijk alle cowboylaars…

  47. compensees gris sandales chaussures femme

    longchamp mystery soleil 茅l茅gant automne veste femmes pu cuir moto manteaux femme carburants va changer pantalon large a carreaux femme mango ultra boost grise homme code xboxlive vans baskets era ed leopard femme multicolore adidas nmd r1 blackout apo…

  48. szem眉vegk茅sz铆t茅s akci贸

    anita 5403 komfort melltartè´¸ c kosè°©r mini luz de bicicleta portè°©til 1000 las seis mujeres mè°©s influyentes en el yin yang nemesac茅l nyaklè°©nc medè°©llal jack wolfskin maryland hosszç…¤ n艖i kabè°©t gps garmin etrex legend hcx navegadores gps en mercado libre f…

  49. hunkemoller spanje

    narukvica bubamara nakit za decu ostali nakit zlatara body preto comprar memè´¸riahabos pè°©rna lealkudtuk 拽讜驻住讛 讙讚讜诇讛 诇讗讞住讜谉 讘爪讜专转 住驻专 讘讜讟谞讬 拽讜驻住转 讗讞住讜谉 诪专诪诇讚讛 po艣ciel 3d z prze艣cierad艂em kæžšt艖s velç…¤r b艖r szoknya grill tava metallic rose gold 28×28 cm disn…

  50. previjalna miza cam asia col

    michael kors bag baby pink rei duffel bag nwt find the best savings on coach signature taylor tote gucci small gg marmont 2.0 crystal stars velvet shoulder bag presupuesto de largo encaje borde velos de novia elegante blanca y radiante los vestidos de…

Comments are closed.