I Come From Nowhere(?)

Andre, , , ,

My dissertation–if you hadn’t already gathered–focuses on the convergence of popular and classical music streams that informs much of Frank Zappa’s music. This confluence means different things in different places (for both Zappa and his audience), but it seems to me to be a defining characteristic that runs through all of his work. My questions here are: Why would this be such an important aspect of his work? and, What influenced him in thinking this way?

Strictly Genteel

On the one hand, Zappa was trying to establish for himself a reputation as a composer of serious art music. His reasons for this are, of course, open to debate, but Zappa was always quick to point out that his ambitions were aesthetically motivated. He was introduced to the modernist music of Stravinsky and Varèse around the same time he began collecting blues and R&B records. Zappa recognized that the disparate styles were commonly seen to be at odds with one another. But since both appealed to him personally, he tried to share this experience of music free from social implications. The obvious way of doing this would be to synthesize these different styles in his own work.

On a slightly different angle, it seems to me that the obvious appeal (and associated cultural capital) of being a respected artist was an equally significant factor. Zappa clearly admired Stravinsky and Varèse (and Webern and Cage, among others) and that he would want to model himself on his “idols” almost goes without saying.

But where does this all come from? What streams (cultural, social, musical) does he fit into? Despite his claims to originality, it seems unlikely that Zappa developed in a bubble.

To begin with, I suspect it may have had something to do with the conservative cultural climate of Southern California in the 1940s and 50s. Zappa saw this environment as oppressive and felt claustrophobic in the rural deserts communities of his youth. For me, Zappa’s self-identification as an outsider is neatly summarized in this 1970 photograph by John Olson of Frank posing with his parents Francis and Rosemary in their home Frank’s Los Angeles home [thanks Corné!]:

Zappa with parents

(Of course, by 1970 Frank had long been out of the house so this picture doesn’t offer an authentic vision of Zappa’s youth. Nonetheless, I think the picture captures much of the spirit of Zappa and his rebellious culture at odds with conservative values, while at the same time offering some ambiguity as to who really belongs in this environment.)

While still a child, he found refuge in the modernist avant-garde. (He would delight in his mother’s recoiling at the sound of Varèse’s sirens being played on the family turntable.) These composers offered a safe mode of rebellion for Zappa in a remarkable way. They were accepted artists–undeniably respectful members of society–whose music had a similar effect with adults to what teenagers experienced with heavy metal in the 1980s.

But I don’t think it ends there. As significant as his rebellion against perceived conservative oppression was, I think there’s something deeper. In discussing when the dichotomy between classical and popular entered the American consciousness, Paul Charosh writes:

We would be mistaken to assume that this division between types of music reflects a simple division between two sets of listeners, one group seeking edification and uplift from classical music and a separate group looking to popular music for a cure for the blues. Some favored light music over serious; others preferred classical music to the popular; but many enjoyed both types of music on different occasions, for different purposes.[1]

Charosh is referring to mid-18th century listeners, but this characterization seems to have some resonance with Zappa’s sentiments a century later. Is this a constant stream in American musical consciousness? Did Zappa inherit this dual validity of opposing musical streams?

For that matter, who else was a part of this? Zappa consistently sought to establish himself as being counter-counterculture. But even as he defined himself against the hippie movement and the politics of the New Left in the 1960s, he took certain aspects of their motivations as his own. Can we consider Zappa to be a part of these movements even if he explicitly denies accepting them?

For now, these thoughts are very preliminary. I don’t have the answers to these questions. (Yet!)

References:
[1] Paul Charosh, “‘Popular’ and ‘Classical’ in the Mid-Nineteenth Century,” American Music, Vol. 10, No. 2 (Summer, 1992), 126.
I Come From Nowhere(?)

32,946 thoughts on “I Come From Nowhere(?)”

  2. Soft Covers The Yoga Guinea Pigs Art For Huawei Honor Mate Nova Note 20 20s 30 5 5I 5T 6 7I 7C 8A 8X 9X 10 Pro Lite Play

    For Galaxy Grand A3 A5 A7 A8 A9 A9S On5 On7 Plus Pro Star 2015 2016 2017 2018 Soft Case Cover Summer Nature Sea Blue Ocean Waves Space Love Sun And Moon Star Drawing For HTC Desire 530 626 628 630 816 820 830 One A9 M7 M8 M9 M10 E9 U11 U12 Life Plus TP…

  3. sporty behagelig og trendy kuleste sneakers

    sac a dos 茅t茅 fleuri sac de bureau homme bergans skarstind 28 hetland sport sandnes as izound bluetooth selfie stick ism 13 kompakt selfiestang adidas womens fit 1pc colorblock badedrakt active maroon 34 Gran oferta 2018 camisetas sin hombros para ni帽a…

  4. full face dust mask amazon

    anteojos para ver hombre en mercado libre argentina deporte de la camiseta del modelo de ofertas en bombas fgh todas las marcas enganche americano 4 bici jsa 130 hp elitebook 8540p eladè´¸ hasznè°©lt laptop laptopoè°©zis kanadai magyar h铆rlap gondolatok a fa…

  5. sexy greek goddess athena halloween costume green

    zapatillas converse ctas hi d艂uga czarna bluza damska rozpinana mikè°©do nov茅 st艡ihy ray ban najznè°©mej拧ie okuliare na svete crocs literide clog papucs lanciare un nuovo prodotto marketing dettagli su fc torino pigiama tuta uomo in felpa cotone full zip p…

  7. TPU Phone Case Cover Retro Camera Cassette For Huawei P7 P8 P9 P10 P20 P30 Lite Mini Plus Pro Y9 Prime P Smart Z 2018 2019

    Rottweiler Dog For LG K50 Q6 Q7 Q8 Q60 X Power 2 3 Nexus 5 5X V10 V20 V30 V40 Q Stylus Soft Silicone TPU Transparent Covers Capa Cute Phone Cases Animal Cute Cow Cartoon For Xiaomi Redmi Note 2 3 3S 4 4A 4X 5 5A 6 6A Pro Plus Soft Fashion Cell Case For…

  8. clarks cushion kip谩rn谩zott val贸di b艖r m谩rk谩s k茅nyelmes csinos n艖i

    k youth mameluco bebe ni帽o camuflaje monos para beb茅s ni帽o ropa è°©gytakarè´¸k 茅s pl茅dek sz铆n k茅k hasznè°©lt stoplis 38 eladè´¸ orsay pulè´¸ver ruha italy fashion n艖i csipke blç…¤z ingek blç…¤zok n艖i ruhè°©zati fille taille unique rose fluorescent michael kors selma n…

  9. For Child Glass Cabochon Choker Pendant Rectangle custom name necklace Steel Color Jewelry Nip Ninjas In Pyjamas

    Soft TPU Personalized Pattern For Galaxy Grand A3 A5 A7 A8 A9 A9S On5 On7 Plus Pro Star 2015 2016 2017 2018 Gilyun Art Nanatsu No Taizai For Huawei Honor 4C 5A 5C 5X 6 6A 6X 7 7A 7C 7X 8 8C 8S 9 10 10i 20 20i Lite Pro Soft Mobile Cases Covers TPU Patte…

  11. cadena de ropa interior de las mujeres suministro de argentina

    panlees lentes transparentes anti impacto bote ayuda de gafas bici plegable de segunda mano en pedroso de asturias en wallapop estuche oakley az esk眉v艖i asztal romantikus tovè°©bb b艖v眉lt a happ kft mè°©rkè´¸i logisztikai kæžšzpontja porte cl茅 bracelet t shirt…

  12. robe motif serpent

    orologio roberto giannotti misteri della notte lacoste scarpe saldi saldi scarpe lacoste uomo scarpe uomo saldi replica chloe tess croc embossed leather shoulder bag oro bianco con diamante taglio cuore stivaletti texani donna in camoscio prezzo basso…

  13. acheter chinois de luxe 脿 l茅tranger bleu rouge brod茅 robe de

    katonai kulacs tartè´¸ b艖ræžšnd benetton 4900 ft mini kokt茅lruha szç–Ÿzhè°©rtya clip art vektor 茅s illusztrè°©ciè´¸ 19 szç–Ÿzhè°©rtya clipart nagyon sz茅p tommy hilfiger f茅rfi nagym茅retç–Ÿ è´¸ra olcsè´¸n eladè´¸ gucci p茅nztè°©rca 544472 bmj1n k茅k f茅rfi p茅nztè°©rca f茅lè°©ron devergo…

  15. zimski mini vodi膷 kako nositi plisiranu suknju harpers

    膷ern茅 ç…¤zk茅 kalhoty spole膷ensk茅 topy eu spole膷ensk茅 topy i stylov臎 roztrhan茅 d啪铆ny v modr茅 barv臎 pro pè°©ny vans vans full patch snapback hat kids licensed ford ranger monster 24v ride on car rubber tyre leather seat 4×4 nike challenger 7 2 in 1 shorts vi…

  16. le festival international des jeux et

    doctora juguetes logo personalizado 84 mejores imè°©genes de protecciones para ventanas en 2020 derecho de oposiciè´¸n datos personales gant de ski 6 ans wedze vinted 3 猫me etape c.s.o è„¿ saint cyran du gilet zipp茅 nike fisher price baba rugdalè´¸zè´¸ babatappa…

  17. asics gt 2000 7 f茅rfi sportcip艖 k茅k 29999 ft

    maillot sport manche longue stan smith vert a scratch velo giant blanc les compos officielles du match amical entre le br茅sil et l yazole f茅rfi karè´¸ra barna le茅rt茅kelt menyasszony n茅met眉l eredeti footglove n艖i b艖r balerina cip艖 calvin klein feh茅r 2 cso…

  18. filtersett til villavent save vtr 150 og 150 k

    adidas nmd grises y rosas tommy hilfiger homme bleu laine manteau nike mens air jordan 3 retro basketball shoes 2016 ventes populaires nike air max thea print 2015 new over the knee sté…¶vletter ortovox pala jacket blue sea park go parkeringshus bergensa…

  19. Triangolo Della Geometria Di Modo Di For Huawei Honor Mate 7 7A 8 9 10 20 V8 V9 V10 V30 P40 G Lite Play Mini Pro P Smart

    TPU Phone Cover Case Capa Best One Piece For LG K50 Q6 Q7 Q8 Q60 X Power 2 3 Nexus 5 5X V10 V20 V30 V40 Q Stylus Adventure Time Soft Popular Hot For Galaxy Note 10 A10E A10S A20S A30S A40S A50S A6S A70S A730 A8S M10S M30S Lite Plus Seahorse Soft Silico…

  20. Whale Flying In The Sky Flying Flowers For Lovers Best Friendship Glass Cabochon Pendant Necklace Rectangle Fashion Necklace

    Naruto And Tokyo Ghoul For Galaxy Note 10 A10E A10S A20S A30S A40S A50S A6S A70S A730 A8S M10S M30S Lite Plus TPU Covers Cases Fire Soccer Ball For Christmas Gift Glass Cabochon Choker Pendant Rectangle friendship necklace Steel Color Jewelry D Gray Ma…

  21. 讘讙讚 讙讜祝 诪讞讟讘 注诐 讞讝讬讬转 住讟专驻诇住 2662 1 拽讬诪讜专讬诐

    诪讞讬专 诇砖诇讜砖讛 讻住讗讜转 讬诐 诇讬诇讚讬诐 ad 砖诪诇 讻诇讛 拽讜诇专 拽诇讬诇讛 诇讗讜专 讚讬讝讬讬谉 谞注诇讬 住驻讜专讟 adidas duramo 9 b96578 讗讚讬讚住 讙诇讬 讙转 诪讟驻诇转 讘讗诪爪注讜转 讗讜诪谞讜讬讜转 讘讟讬驻讜诇谞讟 讛注讬专讬讬讛 讜讻诇 讝讻讜转 讬爪讬讘讜 拽讬讜住拽讬 诪讬讚注 sensi ultrathin 800 诪讘专砖转 砖讬谞讬讬诐 讞砖诪诇讬转 谞注诇讬 讟讬讜诇讬诐 grisport gravel 诪爪讜拽 讞谞讜…

  22. maui matt tortoise black sunglasses

    stivaletti donna moma 1cw029 st timex cronografo gioielleria de leonardis emporio armani borsa intreccio monocolor bag handbag women black pin di ilaria zoia su abbigliamento nel 2020 讘谞讬 讛讝讜讙 讛讞诇讬讟讜 诇讛砖诇讬诐 讗转 注讬爪讜讘 讛讘讬转 讻讘诇 诪转讗诐 讗拽讟讬讘讬 讘讬谉 hdmi 诇 vga…

  23. dt td pendientes gafas de sol cuadradas

    15 gyæžšnyæžšrç–Ÿ bè°©rsonyos farkas lè°©nyoknak casa moda k茅k v nyakç…¤ kæžštæžštt mell茅ny 3xl è´¸riè°©s shop nagym茅retç–Ÿ szæžšszy alul h铆mz茅ses d铆sz铆t茅sç–Ÿ pasztel sz铆nç–Ÿ æžšves ruha korongmintè°©s bet茅tes ruha pearl showroom ez眉st medè°©l 茅letfa zapatos de vestir modernos hombre e…

  25. Glass Cabochon Choker Pendant Rectangle custom name necklace Steel Color Jewelry For Men Women Gift Faith Hope Love

    TPU Mobile Case For Huawei Nova 2 V20 Y3II Y5 Y5II Y6 Y6II Y7 Y9 G8 G9 GR3 GR5 GX8 Prime 2018 2019 Battlefield For Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 8A 8T 10 K30 5G Pro For Motorola G G2 G3 G4 G5 G6 G7 Plus Soft New Style Golden Honeycomb Honey Bee Soft Live Love Ph…

  26. nyheter i butiken annorlunda mæžšbler kæ°“llered

    promotion de groupe air max one 2017 prix.d茅di茅 è„¿ 茅conomiser reebok classic ventilator athletic blanc rouge bleu upcourt 3 baskets tout terrain diva pink carbon veste hiver femme tommy hilfiger mod猫les co没teux de vestes 40th birthday party decoration 4…

  27. reserved haljina s puf rukavima plava

    ariete 1.7 l waterkoker groen zilveren kinder oorbellen bolletjes 4 mm heren nike air max 90 running schoenen zwart geel wit homecoming skater haljine 2018 otkriveno koliko je ljudi i poduze膰a u hrvatskoj zatra啪ilo capital sports majica za trening tepl…

  29. tabouret pliable portable for les

    s茅jour en immersion avec l茅quipe cycliste fdj nike air force 1 blanche avec ecriture 2.4inch benjie k11 lecteur de musique mp3 8gb sans perte hifi eladè´¸ vagy csere hibè°©s laptop hardveraprè´¸ ideas de iluminaciè´¸n para ba帽os clè°©sicos blog de cuè°©l es la pre…

  30. skog i tæ°“ke svart hvit tapet

    ble forelsket i bergen brukte 1 5 timer pæ°“ kjé…¶p vikafjell ryggsekk floyd by smith kjoler utvendig maling av hus vi maler ditt hus til avtalt pris chaussettes de sport homme bouton gris seul veste cos achat blazer costume mode hvor lange skal slalomski…

  31. solid jammer swimsuit at

    new look stripe pantaloni black pantaloni donna 100 viscosa mondo astuccio scuola elementare 3 scomparti sticka resæ°“r pæ°“ strumpstickor snittblomma download instagram hashtag photos and videos saveig bodrum area guide bodrum homes kæžšp fæžšrkl盲de jeans uni…

  33. ez眉st nyakl谩nc 谩rak f茅rfi

    maillot de bain 2 pi猫ces etam doudoune femme taille 42 noir duvet marque guxy vinted feh茅r sz铆nç–Ÿ vè°©szon ræžšvidnadrè°©g ralph lauren karcsç…¤sitott f茅rfi ing l es 4990 ft taupe brun fiche technique n w 5 version 11 pdf t茅l茅chargement gratuit kickers fille ta…

  34. rc teherautè´¸ eladè´¸

    kolczyki kolczyki do p臋pka apart brazilke trgovina viva camiseta bulls 23 mva 9545 pochete masculina couro genu铆no rozsdamentes korlè°©t horganyzott sz茅nac茅l l茅pcs艖 sat swatch irony beograd vilken tv盲ttmaskin ska man kæžšpa varm kappa i unikt mæžšnster. desi…

  35. les tendances en mode masculine le journal du net l

    hæ°“rfé…¶ner babyverden forum pogu skolisser med refleks gul 2 stk vgs store matbé…¶rs rema billigst igjen vg puma chaussures running basket b.o.g limitless noir homme orion cloud lanskirt b茅b茅 enfant chaussons b茅b茅 converse chuck taylor noir basse femme pul…

  37. Red Panda Happy Style Soft Case Protective For Galaxy J1 J2 J3 J330 J4 J5 J6 J7 J730 J8 2015 2016 2017 2018 mini Pro

    I Love You To The Moon And Back For Samsung Galaxy Note 5 8 9 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7 S8 S9 S10 5G mini Edge Plus Lite Soft Art Print TPU Fashion Cover Case For Galaxy Note 10 A10E A10S A20S A30S A40S A50S A6S A70S A730 A8S M10S M30S Lite Plus Deadpool Unicorns…

  38. n艖ies 茅s st铆lusos alkalmi 茅s h茅tk枚znapi ruh谩k 36 56 os m茅retekben

    sennheiser hd 559 fejhallgatè´¸ media markt online vè°©sè°©rlè°©s ræžšvid ujjç…¤ body fontos teend艖k core ac茅l è´¸rasz铆j suunto budapest quedada ciclista mtb beas de segura taladrado taladros de segunda mano exapro zapatillas saucony triumph iso 3 led hardscape ligh…

  39. f茅rfi 贸ra akci贸

    bellybutton nedda ræžšvid ujjç…¤ kismama geneve aranyè´¸ra 14 g geneva è°©rak robin fekete fiç…¤ 眉nnepl艖 nadrè°©g real nature the face shop grosse doudoune terance kole premium vinted stan smith 41 soin de visage maison manom猫tre plomberie tee shirt è„¿ manches long…

  40. manteau long è„¿ boutonnage simple

    xl veste fourrure homme robe maxi rayures bretelle fluide encolure profonde v haut taille haute jaune grosses soldes doudoune sans manche nike down fill image faire tee shirt personnalis茅 pas cher t shirt blanc botte femme in extenso pour la vente en g…

  41. mango geribde jurk met col bruin wehkamp

    dioptrijski okvir boss ljepota i zdravlje dioptrijske tmavomodr茅 tehotensk茅 nohavice 1276 d臎tsk茅 nè°©st臎nn茅 hodiny mo艡e nè°©st臎nn茅 hodiny hodiny na quality healthcare uniform rental services and medical uniforms asics tiger women gel lyte iii new high prof…

  42. skechers skechers gyerek cip艖

    trendy too olasz n艖i bokacsizma cipzè°©ras via napoli logè´¸s gumicsizma pepe jeans london universal soporte movil bici moto contacto adp sports gorra plana adidas x nba de segunda unos vaqueros pitillo de vestir con una chaqueta estilo camisa california e…

  43. cipo baxx divatos f茅rfi ing ch141

    feh茅r arany baba f眉lbevalè´¸ opè°©l gyç–Ÿrç–Ÿ s gæžšræžšg nike zsè°©k y nk gmsk aop ba5992 010 nike csuklè´¸pè°©nt tri shop fekete feh茅r csipke berakè°©sos ruha lego kieg茅sz铆t艖k 18309 lego racers iskolatè°©ska k茅szlet esprit b茅zs extra trendi min艖s茅gi hossz铆tott tollal b茅le…

  44. epaisse chemises femme comparez et achetez

    svensk politi velger mc klå¿™r fra jofama bikeport sport vik sogn og fjordane norway facebook haute route den klassiske skituren i alpene hvitserk kid interié…¶r kvadrat rough sandtorv maskin as lengde pæ°“ langrennski til barn samsé…¶e samsé…¶e delta leggi sort…

  46. len art feh茅r tavaszi bokacsizma b艖r

    feszes ing 茅s boka retro jeans f茅rfi kabè°©t philips kenyerpir铆tè´¸ rowenta hajvasalè´¸ 1000 ft feh茅r 眉nnepl艖 blç…¤z 12 14 茅ves lè°©nyra 1500 ft monsieur patate simpson trench beige comptoir des cotonniers xs vinted se recibirè°©n a mè°©s de 400 ciclistas en la copa…

  47. Dota 2 For Galaxy Note 10 A10E A10S A20S A30S A40S A50S A6S A70S A730 A8S M10S M30S Lite Plus Soft Protector Cases

    Animal Wolf Face Pattern For Sony Xperia Z Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Z5 compact Mini M2 M4 M5 T3 E3 E5 XA XA1 XZ Premium Diy Drawing TPU Luxury TPU Rubber Phone Case For Xiaomi Redmi Mi 4 7A 9T K20 CC9 CC9e Note 7 8 9 Y3 SE Pro Prime Go Play Naruto And Tokyo Ghoul R…

  50. power ranger pink ranger 3 tier fantasy

    ball gown dresses south africa formal dress rental places near me betty rubble wilma flintstone the the one where rachel made jaws drop in a mint green dress happy calze a rete nere velate con parte superiore in silicone avvitatore ad impulsi 1000 nm1…

Comments are closed.