Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

Reading through the first few years of the Los Angeles Free Press has already been very fruitful exercise! In addition to making (what I consider to be) a major breakthrough, I’ve started to find answers to some earlier questions too.


David Tudor (left) and John Cage performing at the 1971 Shiraz Art Festival. (source)

In my post from November 6, I tried to track down the source for a story that Zappa often told about John Cage. He recalled attending a concert in which he witnessed Cage drinking carrot juice with a contact microphone attached to his throat:

A short time after that, John Cage came to Claremont College and he was giving one of his … he does these performances with a throat microphone. He’d put this thing on his throat and drink a quart of carrot juice, or read something to you while he was drinking the carrot juice. [1]

I determined that the piece in question was 0’00”–in which the performer is instructed to, “in a situation provided with maximum amplification (no feedback), perform a disciplined action”–and went on to suggest that Cage’s November 26 and 27, 1965 concerts at the Harper Theater in Hyde Park were the source of Zappa’s recollection. Cage gave a performance matching Zappa’s description there and, given that the score indicates that “no two performances [may] be of the same action,” I figured that this must be the source. (Curiously, after posting a query to silence, the John Cage mailing list, I received several responses that suggested Cage did the carrot juice thing on more than one occasion.)

As it turns out, I was incorrect.

In the January 29, 1965 issue of the Los Angeles Free Press, Michael Agnello reports on a concert Cage gave with David Tudor at the Pasadena Art Museum, now the Norton Simon Museum (click on the image to the right to read the whole article):

LAFP 2-5 p5It was a common swivel chair which the man (John Cage) sat on. Whenever he moved, I heard a grating sound of metal against metal. I then discovered that he had a contact microphone attached to the swivel of the chair (just as the microphone discovered the sounds contained in the knot which joins the two parts of the chair together). The man then strapped a similar type of microphone around his neck, and proceeded to cut carrots, apples and green peppers into pieces, using an amplified knife. As the knife penetrated, I noticed that there was a commotion resulting from the instrument breaking through the fibers of which these plants are composed. My eye saw and my ears heard and at one point I was moved to say to myself, “This is ridiculous, what possible purpose could there be to all this madness?” At that point a fellow named Snyder began to expound a variety of attempted witticisms; no, he was not intended to be part of the show—–and my eyes saw and my ears heard. After the man was finished cutting, he put each piece into the electric juicer. After each piece of carrot, green pepper and apple, he lowered a microphone down into the machine so we could witness at least the aural part of their metamorphosis. Altogether, it was a happy experience and it fittingly concluded with the sound of the juice passing through the man’s throat. [2]

The description matches Zappa’s perfectly. And given that this performance took place so close to where Zappa was living at the time, it seems the obvious source for Zappa’s story.

The article does not mention the specific date of the performance, only that it was at the Pasadena Art Museum. A quick search on ProQuest revealed the following confirmation:

LA Times - 'Experiments' in New Music to Be Heard - Jan 1, 1965 pSG8John Cage, one of the country’s new musical experimenters, will present three of his compositions at the Pasadena Art Museum in two performances, 7:30 and 9:30 p.m., Thursday, Jan 7.

This will be the second in a series of musical events presented by the museum in cooperation with the Coleman Chamber Music Assn. and the Pasadena Music Teachers Assn.

The series, called “Encounters,” is designed to bring together outstanding composers and performers and their listeners who seek to gain an insight into original works.

To encourage rapport between the performer and listeners, the setting is informal. The compser or performer will speak before his works will be played.

Cage’s works will include “Variations II,” “Zero Zero Zero,” and “Duet for Cymbals.” Pianist will be David Tudor. [3]

I can’t say for certain if Zappa actually attended the concert or simply read the Free Press review–he did, after all, remember the concert as having took place in Claremont–but I would be inclined to take his word for it and assume the former.

FURTHER UPDATE (December 11, 2009):

In trying to track down some more information about Cage’s performance, I took it upon myself to contact the Pasadena Art Museum (now the Norton Simon Museum). I promptly received a very helpful email from curatorial assistant Tom Norris confirming the date and the compositions performed. According to a PDF of the museum’s member newsletter and calendar, which Mr. Norris was kind enough to send me, Cage gave:

Two performances January 7, Thursday evening: 7:30 p.m. and 9:30 p.m. An encounters concert featuring the composer and David Tudor, pianist. Tickets $2.50, students $1.50.

Not a bad deal! The newsletter describes the program thusly:

Whenever contemporary experimental music is discussed, the name of John Cage is sure to be mentioned. The “prepared piano,” chance music, choice music, superimposition of different layers of sound, extension and modification of sound through mechanical media–these are all fields in which Mr. Cage has taken the lead. Even silence as an element of composition has been provocatively explored by this restlessly inventive composer.

Encounters will bring John Cage and David Tudor to the Pasadena Art Museum on Thursday, January 7th, for two performances at 7:30 and 9:30 p.m. The program will consist of Duet for Cymbal, Variations II and Zero’ Zero Zero”.

[1] Den Simms, “An Evening With Pierre Boulez and Frank Zappa,” T’Mershi Duween 9 (October 1989). (Text here.)
[2] Michael Agnello, “John Cage at Pasadena,” Los Angeles Free Press 2.5 (January 29, 1965): 5. (Scan of article here.)
[3] “‘Experiments’ in New Music to Be Heard.” Los Angeles Times (1965, January 1): SG8. (Full text here.)
Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

4,522 thoughts on “Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

  1. latestime

    toronto raptors dri fit for cheap nike air max zero black new york yankees hat size guide quest channel elisabetta franchi double breasted knit dress dallas cowboys red hat zara black dot dress

  2. hotelsoham

    limited devin mccourty mens jersey new england patriots super bowl xlix 32 grey shadow nfl nike flyknit chukka black for sale youth lakers jersey kuzma for cheap nike free run 3.0 v4 hombres new york yankees cap cake 81 rick owens moncler coat

  3. saldianyone

    long sleeve stone island polo shirt leopard jeans outfit adidas yellow dress simple nighty dress denali 2 hooded jacket baby red bottoms louboutin

  4. wdifah

    pandora 99 bracelet clear otterbox iphone 7 plus youth miami dolphins 23 adrian foster aqua game jersey christian louboutin corneille women 2012 new nfl jerseys kansas city chiefs 25 jamaal charles pink fashion camo jerseys asics gel black saga

  5. mersiniz

    youth kids nfl jerseys kansas city chiefs 25 jamaal charles red drift fashion jerseys coach pastel patchwork purse north face supreme rtg jacket linen sleep dress elite eddie royal womens jersey chicago bears 19 road white nfl short brooklyn nets city…

  6. tradersgalleria

    the north face thermoball eco triclimate how expensive are louboutins lebron james purple lakers jersey nike for cheap nike go fly ease trainers loom knit child hat 38 blazer nike beige

  7. flipcartbd

    air max 95 tumblr new york mets hat new era xv red oversized tee coach crossgrain satchel michael jordan news black white nike lebron 11 shoes uk

  8. sukreni

    moncler k2 down jacket pandora bracelet snake chain new york mets winter hat 99 adidas y3 qasa racer noir old fashioned swim dress nike falcons 12 mohamed sanu sr red team color mens stitched nfl elite jersey

  9. pinmein

    adidas nmd r1 primeknit cheap white and green shoes nike free 4.0 flyknit green nike nfl baltimore ravens 78 bryant mckinnie limited youth white road jersey sale

  10. skinmodz

    the north face super air down jacket pandora charm bracelet harry potter red and black long sleeve shirt jordan jumpman flight hat version green fitted prom dress mustard baby dress

  11. persoro

    moncler parnaiba jacket nike nfl philadelphia eagles 93 jason babin game women black alternate jersey sale nets red and blue jersey la louboutin shoes mercurial nike verde pandora dragon charm

  12. favagok

    sneakers chain reaction memorial pandora charm jordan 23 shoes black and yellow jumpsuit dress shein nike duckboot 2021 womens cincinnati reds hat for cheap

  13. progoodies

    christian louboutin flat shoes sale off the shoulder long sleeve cropped tops iphone 10 xr case otterbox womens north face nuptse gilet the north face nuptse 600 buffalo bills hat

  14. contentbrews

    youth nike new england patriots 32 devin mccourty limited navy blue team color nfl jersey sale christian louboutin vero cuoio champs women vapormax pandora forever stud earrings volt green air max 95 galia lahav designer

  15. tagsires

    moncler clovis jacket casemate iphone 12 pro max case toronto raptors championship hat for cheap nike sb gt blazer low schwarz white air jordan 1 orange and black miami dolphins new era green 2014 salute to service knit hat

  16. mcevillage

    tampa bay rays 3 evan longoria gray jersey how to knit a baby hat with two needles kitchener nike zoom soldier vii red and white shoes nike arizona cardinals blank white limited womens jersey pink dolphin bucket hat for sale jacksonville h m white sati…

  17. puntohaber

    boston red sox new era mlb basic gold 59fifty cap guidelines palace juventus jersey for cheap nemeziz 19.1 artificial grass boots wholesale lids atlanta braves hat duchess of cambridge shirt dress lilly pulitzer parigi

  18. macosaug

    mk mercer medium belted satchel kashees bridal walima dresses 53470 sherri hill womens mexico 5 areyes home 2016 2017 country national team soccer jerseys coach black large tote the north face summit series l6

  19. bmliren

    long sleeve beige down the north face junior 1996 retro nuptse down jacket new york mets adjustable hats las vegas nv miami dolphins thanksgiving hat for sale

  20. sevilorgu

    obj cleveland jersey michael kors shopper bag new york yankees camo hat for sale best cover for samsung tab a7 wholesale nfl shop steelers hat black gilet womens long

  21. kiwiple

    pittsburgh pirates cadet hat keyboard nike sb stefan janoski mid brown white valentino shoes red bottom womens moncler coat with fur hood air jordan retro 3 pure white for cheap nike magista opus ii black and red

  22. friedads

    max 270 womens pittsburgh pirates beanie hats value 2xl womens shirts coach womens rowan satchel jordan retro 11 ie bred adidas ace 17.1 indoor

  23. roadeks

    san francisco giants 2012 gold hat xbox h m striped bodycon dress big beautiful womens clothing neon texas rangers hat lids mens 2015 nike nfl arizona cardinals t shirts 49 sandale du desert

  24. rotimpex

    wedding store online pakistani actress dress limited jason myers mens jersey jacksonville jaguars 2 road white nfl kors bracelet north face down ski jacket red dress with gold accents

  25. saemmit

    psn madden 20 discount code for cheap baby moncler coat boy dolphins army hat crochet patterns jordan supreme hats denver girls christmas jumper dress womens 2012 new nfl jerseys seattle seahawks customized white jerseys

  26. demuslimah

    cat girl costume child juventus zebra kit for cheap patriots super bowl 2019 jersey color chicago white sox hats through the years reddit aqua jordan 5 colorado avalanche 19 joe sakic st. patricks day green jersey

  27. mamnbeb

    coach backpacks on sale north face camo down jacket sexxy night dress limited rob gronkowski mens jersey new england patriots 87 realtree camo nfl eagles sweatshirt blanket cavs caps for sale

  28. tzpoker

    knitted newborn baby boy hats new 3d nike air vapormax flyknit moc 2 mens black white green shoes jordan 10 6.5 limited kenrick ellis mens jersey new york giants 97 home royal blue nfl moncler valentino windbreaker san diego padres fedora hat houston

  29. vpoloni

    calgary flames cgy hat new balance 997h kids how much does red bottom shoes cost moncler daphne jacket nike roshe one roshe run adidas stan smith shell toe

  30. caralarma

    cat girl costume child juventus zebra kit for cheap patriots super bowl 2019 jersey color chicago white sox hats through the years reddit aqua jordan 5 colorado avalanche 19 joe sakic st. patricks day green jersey

  31. profmaison

    nike shox gravity mens all white shoes nike pg 1 white black green chicago bulls hat for uk 90s arsenal kit for cheap new jordan 11 space jam jordan jumpman hat black 10

  32. esmokeinc

    orange red bottom heels mlb jerseys st louis cardinals 51 willie mcgee white 2011 world series jerseys all red yeezy v2 ua philadelphia phillies cap space hours xmas air jordan valentine 12 christian louboutin kate

  33. sinsumbar

    wedding store online pakistani actress dress limited jason myers mens jersey jacksonville jaguars 2 road white nfl kors bracelet north face down ski jacket red dress with gold accents

  34. esndental

    adidas superstar junior noir jordan prime mania x cheap black white and red shoes 2015 new york yankees hat rakuten jersey warriors nike mercurial superfly red white shoes history of texas rangers hats 2016

  35. costruth

    jordan retro 10 x men black nike youth mike wallace 17 limited black pittsburgh steelers nfl jersey sale oklahoma state cowboys nike ncaa h86 trucker cap wedding white dress coach f76580 deportivo saprissa jersey

  36. detikxom

    gabe martin 50 jersey adidas yeezy boost 350 v2 gold ochre cheap black and grey shoes minnesota twins fitted hat fittings air jordan 1 pink and white louis vuitton red bottoms sneakers moncler cezanne jacket

  37. liorrey

    morilee adelaide limited jordan mills mens jersey chicago bears 67 alternate orange nfl coach brown and red wallet bodice corset best womens online clothing boutiques barcelona away shirt

  38. mytapbath

    washington nationals hat giveaways 2016 lace elopement dress coach horse and carriage card case youth nike tennessee titans 18 kenny britt elite light blue team color nfl jersey sale new balance 327 winter june birthstone pandora charm

  39. lucianoluz

    moncler jacket palm angels jordan 1 mid black cone swift run x devin hester seahawks jersey for cheap black and blue dresses new york yankees cap green day

  40. lazydesiree

    black and red chiefs jersey for cheap customized 2012 new nfl jerseys mensmiami dolphins customized game white jerseys nike free 5.0 womens all black grey letter g pandora charm blue maya moncler cowboys t shirt amazon for cheap

  41. etuvcihazi

    air force 1 high foamposite limited buster skrine womens jersey cleveland browns 22 alternate orange nfl 15 off coach outlet yellow black adidas superstar nike roshe run hvid and sort speckled 2014 new nfl jerseys seattle seahawks 25 richard sherman bl…

  42. waltonmotor

    black grey blue adidas predator 18.1 new balance 574 dragon schwarz army body warmer louboutin trademark chicago blackhawks 65 andrew shaw red womens jersey w 2015 stanley cup champion patch mens asics gel kayano 22 gold

  43. sinkaltim

    new balance 420 all white gold raptors 39thirty for sale nike flex tr7 nike air max command blanc cuir punk t shirt dress christian louboutin pvc heels

  44. levitraeos

    nike air max 90 hommes tout rouge nike air max 90 2021s noir chicago bears majestic big and tall heart soul iii t shirt atlanta braves 44 hank aaron cream throwback jersey nike hypervenom phelon ii black pandora rockettes charm 2017

  45. fociphotos

    miami dolphins santa hat knitting pattern pandora 4 leaf clover charm atletico madrid 3rd kit for cheap nfl hunting cap wine tiffany bone cuff gold ebay pandora bracelet rose gold

  46. fanclubes

    new balance 420 all white gold raptors 39thirty for sale nike flex tr7 nike air max command blanc cuir punk t shirt dress christian louboutin pvc heels

  47. lumeraserum

    navy san francisco giants hat linux distros affordable mens sunglasses tiffany and co loyalty program airpods max pro case lebron 8 south beach 13 red sox baseball caps wholesale numbers

  48. torilsdesign

    grey polo long sleeve mens nike denver broncos 20 brian dawkins game orange team color nfl jersey sale kate red bottoms red sole shoes jimmy choo rainbow louboutin heels adidas zx flux rust rot

Comments are closed.