Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

Reading through the first few years of the Los Angeles Free Press has already been very fruitful exercise! In addition to making (what I consider to be) a major breakthrough, I’ve started to find answers to some earlier questions too.


David Tudor (left) and John Cage performing at the 1971 Shiraz Art Festival. (source)

In my post from November 6, I tried to track down the source for a story that Zappa often told about John Cage. He recalled attending a concert in which he witnessed Cage drinking carrot juice with a contact microphone attached to his throat:

A short time after that, John Cage came to Claremont College and he was giving one of his … he does these performances with a throat microphone. He’d put this thing on his throat and drink a quart of carrot juice, or read something to you while he was drinking the carrot juice. [1]

I determined that the piece in question was 0’00”–in which the performer is instructed to, “in a situation provided with maximum amplification (no feedback), perform a disciplined action”–and went on to suggest that Cage’s November 26 and 27, 1965 concerts at the Harper Theater in Hyde Park were the source of Zappa’s recollection. Cage gave a performance matching Zappa’s description there and, given that the score indicates that “no two performances [may] be of the same action,” I figured that this must be the source. (Curiously, after posting a query to silence, the John Cage mailing list, I received several responses that suggested Cage did the carrot juice thing on more than one occasion.)

As it turns out, I was incorrect.

In the January 29, 1965 issue of the Los Angeles Free Press, Michael Agnello reports on a concert Cage gave with David Tudor at the Pasadena Art Museum, now the Norton Simon Museum (click on the image to the right to read the whole article):

LAFP 2-5 p5It was a common swivel chair which the man (John Cage) sat on. Whenever he moved, I heard a grating sound of metal against metal. I then discovered that he had a contact microphone attached to the swivel of the chair (just as the microphone discovered the sounds contained in the knot which joins the two parts of the chair together). The man then strapped a similar type of microphone around his neck, and proceeded to cut carrots, apples and green peppers into pieces, using an amplified knife. As the knife penetrated, I noticed that there was a commotion resulting from the instrument breaking through the fibers of which these plants are composed. My eye saw and my ears heard and at one point I was moved to say to myself, “This is ridiculous, what possible purpose could there be to all this madness?” At that point a fellow named Snyder began to expound a variety of attempted witticisms; no, he was not intended to be part of the show—–and my eyes saw and my ears heard. After the man was finished cutting, he put each piece into the electric juicer. After each piece of carrot, green pepper and apple, he lowered a microphone down into the machine so we could witness at least the aural part of their metamorphosis. Altogether, it was a happy experience and it fittingly concluded with the sound of the juice passing through the man’s throat. [2]

The description matches Zappa’s perfectly. And given that this performance took place so close to where Zappa was living at the time, it seems the obvious source for Zappa’s story.

The article does not mention the specific date of the performance, only that it was at the Pasadena Art Museum. A quick search on ProQuest revealed the following confirmation:

LA Times - 'Experiments' in New Music to Be Heard - Jan 1, 1965 pSG8John Cage, one of the country’s new musical experimenters, will present three of his compositions at the Pasadena Art Museum in two performances, 7:30 and 9:30 p.m., Thursday, Jan 7.

This will be the second in a series of musical events presented by the museum in cooperation with the Coleman Chamber Music Assn. and the Pasadena Music Teachers Assn.

The series, called “Encounters,” is designed to bring together outstanding composers and performers and their listeners who seek to gain an insight into original works.

To encourage rapport between the performer and listeners, the setting is informal. The compser or performer will speak before his works will be played.

Cage’s works will include “Variations II,” “Zero Zero Zero,” and “Duet for Cymbals.” Pianist will be David Tudor. [3]

I can’t say for certain if Zappa actually attended the concert or simply read the Free Press review–he did, after all, remember the concert as having took place in Claremont–but I would be inclined to take his word for it and assume the former.

FURTHER UPDATE (December 11, 2009):

In trying to track down some more information about Cage’s performance, I took it upon myself to contact the Pasadena Art Museum (now the Norton Simon Museum). I promptly received a very helpful email from curatorial assistant Tom Norris confirming the date and the compositions performed. According to a PDF of the museum’s member newsletter and calendar, which Mr. Norris was kind enough to send me, Cage gave:

Two performances January 7, Thursday evening: 7:30 p.m. and 9:30 p.m. An encounters concert featuring the composer and David Tudor, pianist. Tickets $2.50, students $1.50.

Not a bad deal! The newsletter describes the program thusly:

Whenever contemporary experimental music is discussed, the name of John Cage is sure to be mentioned. The “prepared piano,” chance music, choice music, superimposition of different layers of sound, extension and modification of sound through mechanical media–these are all fields in which Mr. Cage has taken the lead. Even silence as an element of composition has been provocatively explored by this restlessly inventive composer.

Encounters will bring John Cage and David Tudor to the Pasadena Art Museum on Thursday, January 7th, for two performances at 7:30 and 9:30 p.m. The program will consist of Duet for Cymbal, Variations II and Zero’ Zero Zero”.

[1] Den Simms, “An Evening With Pierre Boulez and Frank Zappa,” T’Mershi Duween 9 (October 1989). (Text here.)
[2] Michael Agnello, “John Cage at Pasadena,” Los Angeles Free Press 2.5 (January 29, 1965): 5. (Scan of article here.)
[3] “‘Experiments’ in New Music to Be Heard.” Los Angeles Times (1965, January 1): SG8. (Full text here.)
Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

4,522 thoughts on “Gargling Carrot Juice (UPDATE)

  1. flstudiopro

    nike short sleeve shirt cincinnati reds franchise hat online pandora old lady charm chivas club world cup jersey long sleeve nike workout cap tiffany rose gold ball earrings

  2. tlclease

    coach big tote jordan 1 zoom black blanc nike sock dart nero acquistare baltimore ravens merchandise devils green jersey for cheap nike shox air ultra

  3. gradingpen

    atlanta braves hat toddler ornament ray ban wayfarer xl girls red moncler coat moncler alyx puffer jordan retro 12s black blanc davids bridal wine dress

  4. tenminutemba

    black grey blue adidas predator 18.1 new balance 574 dragon schwarz army body warmer louboutin trademark chicago blackhawks 65 andrew shaw red womens jersey w 2015 stanley cup champion patch mens asics gel kayano 22 gold

  5. dramony

    adidas superstar shoes amazon blanc womens red bottoms james harden nets jerseys nfl cowboys knit hat kitty boston red sox cap uk 2014 adidas superstar ninja noir

  6. starori

    oakland athletics womens hats queen nike roshe hvit swoosh quinnen williams jersey jets for cheap coach tabby puffy nike hypervenomx finale 2 all gold nike air max 90 negro wolf gris

  7. bitencore

    nike short sleeve shirt cincinnati reds franchise hat online pandora old lady charm chivas club world cup jersey long sleeve nike workout cap tiffany rose gold ball earrings

  8. cubedsteps

    pandora gold pendants used bridesmaid dresses ebay sunny kiss oversized tee in black cosmos game brandon graham mens jersey philadelphia eagles 55 road white nfl red bottom trainers louboutin boat shoes

  9. wpmashin

    dallas mavericks jason kidd jersey 35t0sy9n1b kd trey 57 black and red yeezy cream white fake broncos throwback uniforms coach pride reversible tote

  10. cognisiveit

    moncler marque navy moncler off white puffer jacket fitflop talia leather loafers best amazon party dresses lfc black goalkeeper shirt for cheap original jumpman shoes

  11. mobilfonn

    reebok houston texans andre johnson 80 red replica jerseys sale mens nike free run 3 black orange notre dame fighting irish 47 ncaa kids clean up wingfold evr ssense moncler jacket moncler white mens jacket

  12. almaretravel

    navy san francisco giants hat linux distros affordable mens sunglasses tiffany and co loyalty program airpods max pro case lebron 8 south beach 13 red sox baseball caps wholesale numbers

  13. rivacover

    pandora 20th anniversary heart charm womens camo boston red sox hat custom adidas ace 16 red bottoms boys taylor redskins jersey for cheap jordan jumpman stretch cap download

  14. conseilsturf

    nhl jerseys tampa bay lightning 91 steven stamkos black third jerseys nike lunarepic low flyknit mens running up pandora 596586fpc khaki day dress macys dockers classic fit nike premier 2.0 white metallic gold for cheap

  15. novaapk

    chinese collar wedding dress air jordan 4 triple nero oakland as beanie hat 5000 flutter sleeve floral dress michael kors wallet nordstrom rack nike roshe one nm schwarz

  16. crimsoku

    new balance 420 all white gold raptors 39thirty for sale nike flex tr7 nike air max command blanc cuir punk t shirt dress christian louboutin pvc heels

  17. sureshbursu

    coach big tote jordan 1 zoom black blanc nike sock dart nero acquistare baltimore ravens merchandise devils green jersey for cheap nike shox air ultra

  18. dinkartimes

    louboutin studded sandals steph curry 2 usa shoes mens v neck sweater vest adidas zx flux nero harga fall dress with leggings adidas messi 16.2 white

  19. dorichon

    louboutin studded sandals steph curry 2 usa shoes mens v neck sweater vest adidas zx flux nero harga fall dress with leggings adidas messi 16.2 white

  20. creativehauz

    air max 90 sail cool gris infrarouge vintage barato nike free run 2 hombres nike new orleans saints 10 brandin cooks white limited kids jersey coach hallie wallet long sleeve under short sleeve button up texas rangers baseball straw hat for sale

  21. saponions

    alabama crimson tide nike ncaa col cap tiffany medical id bracelet charm jiminy cricket boston red sox cap utah update 51 cheap all white nike tanjun slip unisex christian louboutin rubber sole protector

  22. stylepoznan

    dallas mavericks jason kidd jersey 35t0sy9n1b kd trey 57 black and red yeezy cream white fake broncos throwback uniforms coach pride reversible tote

  23. wlcventures

    wonder woman tee los angeles dodgers custom hats 8th grade fitted white midi dress wi 574 new balance mens denali 2 jacket north face christian louboutin sandale du desert

  24. cairnsparency

    penguins lace up hoodie for cheap christian louboutin red bottom shoes 11 citrus low ralph lauren womens short sleeve oxford shirt air jordan 4 retro union off noir mens silk dress short

  25. wishpaleo

    drawstring ruched mini dress 597225cbk st. louis rams critical victory nfl t shirt orange mens nike dallas cowboys 17 dwayne harris game white throwback alternate nfl jersey sale that sell louboutins christian louboutin lace

  26. lottolucker

    womens stretch down north face jacket which heels have red soles limited clyde gates womens jersey new york jets 10 alternate navy blue nfl original red grey adidas copa 18.1 fg shoes texas rangers reflective hat yulee florida womens tns

  27. marvslater

    anine bing t shirt dress michael kors iphone 8 plus phone case mercurial vapor academy 13 adidas ace 17.1 indoor mavericks earned jersey women 2012 new nfl jerseys pittsburgh steelers 43 popamalu pink jerseys

  28. albiseyler

    nike blazer mid metric sort buy boston bruins nathan horton 18 black authentic jersey sale leather bedford legacy dome satchel couple floral outfit nike free run zapatos mujeres dan depalma white jersey 15 game youth nike new york giants nfl jersey sti…

  29. crazypraisy

    tiffany platinum wedding ring is cincinnati reds hat a gang affiliation meaning balenciaga sneakers outlet wedding dress boho sleeves nike cortez schwarz and gold damen air jordan 13 retro gs black black white red cheap

  30. mtdbpro

    adidas predator soccer boots noir jonathan abrams raiders jersey plus size black brides pandora shine openwork flower charm laurent robinson jersey jacksonville jaguars 81 youth green limited jersey nike nfl jersey sale all red louboutin

  31. dostindian

    cheap atlanta braves fitted hats design jordan 10 blue legend michael kors md satchel nike washington wizards jersey reformation meadow dress pandora blue square ring

  32. retraitors

    black halo gypsy rose dress adidas samba og men blanc winnipeg jets heritage classic hat for uk grey crew neck sweater mens coach crossbody pouch black acronym x nike lunar force 1

  33. tonatsuma

    tyson pronovias small zip around wallet in signature leather chicago cubs 23 ryne sandberg 1984 white button throwback jersey all green new nike air yeezy ralph lauren fleece shorts moncler janvry jacket

  34. vastewine

    air jordan 6 retro air jordan 2 men black green shoes the north face himalayan down parka louboutin collection nashville predators jersey 35 pekka rinne black 2016 all star stitched nhl jerseys air jordan 17 grey

  35. easycarup

    fleece lined bobble hat womens 锘縩ike air max 95 mens shoes white purple gray st. louis rams 13 curt warner white throwback jersey grey and white michael kors purse wedding frocks white nike roshe run hyperfuse gold and schwarz

  36. evpsistemas

    new york mets winter hat menu oakley juliet earsocks daybreak undercover lucky green adidas juventus limited edition for cheap nike san francisco 49ers 7 colin kaepernick 2013 drift fashion white elite jersey kansas city royals hats 59fifty for eu

  37. trangmuaban

    silver louboutin heels luka doncic all star jersey christian louboutin half shoe americas cup sneaker prada thrasher sleeveless shirt plus longline gilet

  38. ecovinowines

    loubifunk nike dunk sort gum sole white adidas dragon trainers tommy hilfiger slim fit long sleeve t shirt mcm bucket hat uk careers all star dunk gs

  39. cissemosse

    adidas zx 750 herren schwarz acg long sleeve rb2143 wayfarer popular tiffany bracelets celtic fc third kit balmain x psg long sleeve

  40. leneuf

    religious pandora charms straw beret hats tiffany and co silver cross pendant richardson 112 hats embroidered new york yankees on field cap guns saint laurent sneakers low top

  41. lcdtvservisi

    nike air presto black white qs predator tango 18 indoor moncler maya jacket red jersey de troy polamalu black crop top long sleeve red sox memorial day hat ebay

  42. belpages

    ladies long length polo shirts j1 not for resale gold dress shirt womens puma x kidsuper vtg ralph lauren fleece shorts flynn raptors jersey

  43. fundamitre

    polo voor lange mannen adidas crazy move studio metallic thread shirt dress lebron rams jersey mens red pj bottoms broncos pajama pants mens

  44. lvdbulb

    duke hats new era patriots winter hat mens n3xt l3v3l captain america style cap for men hardy amies london jacket dansko sophie multi stripe

  45. marenahomes

    best oakley ski goggles tiffany smile necklace mini rose gold a50s back cover say yes to the dress lancashire see through dress ny yankees fitted cap for eu pink dresses for teenager

  46. fildupuis

    dior x nike air force 1 noir vintage hartford whalers hat billionaire boy outfits wi 574 new balance places to get cheap prom dresses christian louboutin sandale du desert

  47. nembutalfso

    nike jordan mars low louboutin eloise 100 ranking nfl uniforms lebron james jersey retirement nfl salute to service knit hat quizlet nike x off white dunk low 2021

  48. lialusin

    difference between radar ev path and pitch moncler mythos moncler coat cleaning chanel glasses 3281 satin wrap midi dress the north face mens apex elevation jacket

Comments are closed.