Most of you are probably already familiar with the following videos:
(The remainder of Zappa’s performance can be found here.) These videos have made the rounds numerous times over the years, but I don’t know if anyone’s ever looked into any possible connections between Cage and Zappa. To me, these two performances and their respective contexts are too similar to be coincidental. I think it’s very likely that Zappa saw Cage’s appearance on television and modeled his own performance on it. Even if there isn’t such a direct connection between the two videos, I think it’s more than likely that Zappa at least had some of Cage’s theory in mind.
I think there’s a lot to say here, so I’ll limit my discussion here to a little background info on the two videos. I’ll follow up in a second post with a brief analysis of Zappa’s discourse regarding Cage.
The first video shows John Cage in his February 24, 1960 appearance on the CBS game show I’ve Got a Secret. Typically, the show features contestants with unusual, amazing, embarrassing, or otherwise humorous secret. A panel tries to guess their secret using only yes/no questions. The host, Garry Moore, considered Cage’s secret–
I’m going to perform one of my musical compositions … The ‘instruments’ I will use are: a water pitcher, an iron pipe, a goose call, a bottle of wine, an electric mixer, a whistle, a sprinkling can, ice cubes, 2 cymbals, a mechanical fish, a quail call, a rubber duck, a tape recorder, a vase of roses, a seltzer siphon, 5 radios, a bathtub, and a grand piano.
–to be intriguing enough to forgo the game in hopes of allowing time for the entire piece to be performed (with the further hope of a Q&A afterwards).
Floorplan for Cage’s Water Walk [1]
The piece Cage performed, Water Walk, was an adaption of his earlier piece Water Music (1952) which is generally thought of as the first of Cage’s so-called “theater pieces.” Cage originally adapted the piece for a performance on a different game show, the Italian program Lascia o Raddoppia (loosely translated: “double or nothing”) in January of 1959.
John Cage on Lascia o Raddoppia with host Mike Buongiorno
On Lascia o Raddoppia, contestants answered questions on a topic of their choice. If they were successful, they were invited back the following week to answer harder questions for progressively larger winnings. A contestant who made it through all five weeks stood to win five million lire (approximately eight thousand dollars). Cage, an accomplished mycologist, answered questions about mushrooms with the aid of an interpreter. Cage made it through all five weeks and bought a new piano with his winnings upon returning home. More significantly, Cage was also invited to perform one of his compositions each week of show. Water Walk adapted the earlier Water Music to be more appropriate to the televised medium.
Detail of the score for Water Walk [2]
Compared to Water Music, Water Walk is much simpler. Cage’s specifications for the timing of various events are much less specific. More significantly, however, Cage seems to have introduced a greater degree of humor to the second piece, pandering to the lighthearted nature of television and its audiences. I think the added humor was something that would surely have appealed to Zappa.
(The only other performance of Water Walk by Cage was done on The Henry Morgan Show in June of 1959.)
In the other video, we see Zappa performing on The Steve Allen Show three years later. Zappa’s piece, a “concerto for two bicycles, a pre-recorded tape and the musicians in the back” is much more improvised. As Zappa points out in the pre-performance interview, he hadn’t been playing the bike very long.
Jerry Hopkins, the show’s talent coordinator recalls how Zappa landed the gig:
The rules for my job were simple. Get someone who was genuinely eccentric or who did something at least a little strange or out-of-the-ordinary, but never make fun of them—the idea was to have fun with them. And, no fakes, no frauds, no bogus acts looking for exposure and willing to do anything to get it, no put-ons or send-ups, no cons. Because, Steve assured me, they never, ever worked, and they embarrassed everyone.
Only once did I ignore his advice and that was when I got a call from a young man who identified himself as Frank Zappa. He said he wanted to teach Steve how to “blow bicycle.” “Blow bicycle,” I repeated.
“Yeah, you know, like, the bicycle is a musical instrument.”
(You can read the rest of Hopkins’ account here.)
Zappa’s performance even got a write up in a local Cucamonga newspaper:
“Ontario Composer, Steve Allen To Play Wacky Duet”
Frank Zappa, 22, Ontario resident and composer of music, serious and otherwise, will be seen on television tomorrow night playing a bicycle concerto for two with Steve Allen. The show is at 11 p.m., Channel 5. “It’s very funny,†said Zappa. “You play a bicycle by plucking the spokes and blowing through the handle bars.†Other methods of producing “cyclophony†is to stroke the spokes with the bow of a bass fiddle, twirl the pedals and let air out of the tires. The Zappa-Allen concerto will be abetted by a man in the control room fooling around with a tape recorder and by a jazz group which will supply toneless background noise. Zappa studied music and art at Chaffey College. He wrote the score for “The World’s Greatest Sinner,†a low-budget tale about a sacrilegious imposter who repents. “Sinner†had its premiere at Vista-Continental Theater, Hollywood, and opened Wednesday at the Ken Theater, San Diego. Zappa writes musical commercials for TV and radio. They are recorded at Pal Studio, Cucamonga. [3]
These videos both provide neat examples of how the frequently-opposed worlds of art and pop occasionally intersect. A lot of the responsibility for these meetings can be placed on television. I haven’t quite worked this out completely yet, but it seems that for Zappa, the added visual dimension of televised performance goes hand in hand with what he thought about Cage.
In both of these videos, what interests me is the awkward mix of polite respect and anxious laughter on the parts of the hosts and the audiences of each show. I think that these two videos give us an intimate glance a very specific moment in the history of avant-garde music. Audiences (and television programmers) were still receptive to experimental ideas, which themselves hadn’t yet been relegated to exclusive academic circles.
From my perspective, nearly fifty years later, it’s remarkable how adventurous television programming was in the middle of the twentieth century. It’s easy to complain about the lack of this sort of programming nowadays, but I think these examples might give us a better understanding of the current situation.
nsfoil
automotive overhead consoles industrial scientific foam tape 3 girls athletic running 2 home kitchen chip dip sets girls fashion hoodies sweatshirts 2 toys games aircraft landing gear
watertowerinn
moto g4 plus pouzdro bebe 啪lut谩 拧aty beanie cappello ralph lauren gold sandals for wide feet 2976 cherry rot huawei p smart 2019 hoesje aliexpress
anylearner
note 9 pouzdro luxury disney belle 拧aty rockabilly cowboy cappello clarks karely wedge fashion schuhe damen pixel 2 xl otterbox defender hoesje
pickahomepage
nokia 6.1 lifeproof pouzdro light nachov媒 拧aty with sleeves clint nero cowboy cappello ecco biom hybrid 2 spikeless golf shoes schwarz damen fila disruptor galaxy s9 alcantara dekking
chipsgratis
nike sb zoom gts negro h眉lle mate tough mag iphone 8 plus nike presto black orange nike air force 1 low x virgil abloh nike zoom rev blanco
lepantouflard
gecko waterproof phone hoesje turkey 17 calhanoglu home soccer country jersey jr torebki authentic apple smart case iphone 7 dkny crossbody zak bruin camera pouzdro iphone x
alhaqeqa
mochi leather slippers ara mokassin schwarz iphone 8 silicone hoesje purper nfl womens nike new york jets 28 curtis martin ash backer t shirt fossil skè´¸rzany travel torba samsung galaxy s7 wireless charging case
feministfred
kd 11 r贸zsasz铆n footlocker shona joy lace cocktail midi ruha noir clover fitted chapeau lg g6 sag with card holder mint zielony chunky obcasy hvit sleeveless midi kjole
walkupright
cute school tassen for hoog school ipad 9.7 kryt modern boho wedding 拧aty mexican vaquero cappelli flex sole shoes margiela hologram schuhe
minikperi
comfy stylish sneakers nike id presto react self portrait thea dress fitted tee shirt dress royals 9 drew butera grey flexbase authentic collection stitched mlb jersey womens paul worrilow game black nike jersey nfl philadelphia eagles 48 fashion
tlcaldesnudo
htc desire 530 phone sag pokrowce na buty rowerowe svart ladies kjole jacket nike auralux sonder laptop rucksack tuta adidas jumpsuit nike air max 270 rose jaune
jbodsata
gris air max 97 homme nike felpa nera nike zoom x obuv cena converse ctas waterproof hi f茅rfi boots asics gel fujitrabuco 6 damen
burtonburton
nokia 6.1 lifeproof pouzdro light nachov媒 拧aty with sleeves clint nero cowboy cappello ecco biom hybrid 2 spikeless golf shoes schwarz damen fila disruptor galaxy s9 alcantara dekking
hazelfinch
explorafunk rugzak replica lifeproof 6 plus pouzdro reiss b茅啪ov媒 拧aty detroit tigers classic trucker 9fifty snapback berretto lacoste white rubber shoes boss lederschuhe herren
palmersquare
nike womens ronnie lott ash backer oakland raiders nfl 42 pullover hoodie nike air max side torba beasyjoy iphone 7 plus case secrid slide portemonnee s6 bumper pouzdro ganni modr媒 拧aty
dizimy
girls school uniforms sweaters 8 arts crafts mat cutters blades home kitchen space heaters baby girls short sets 1 mens swim rash guards boys bow ties 4
spiritualrap
ladies pink safety boots sandalen damen 2019 zalando disney iphone plus hoesje nike mens russell okung elite navy blue home jersey los angeles chargers nfl 76 vapor untouchable sog opord plecak huawei mate 20 clear case
kevinphoto
envelope satchel zak moto g6 mobile kryt 膷ern谩 uniform jumper 拧aty hurley destination snapback berretto sugar slip on shoes dark gr眉n niedrig abs盲tze schuhe
externateam
nfl matt judon womens black 99 baltimore ravens nike name number logo pullover hoodie magellan travel portfel lg g3 stylus flip cover transparent tassen target disney protective phone pouzdro 啪lut谩 2 piece prom 拧aty
ilocus
womens nike new york jets 21 ladainian tomlinson white vapor untouchable limited player nfl jersey white lifeproof case iphone 7 nike aerobill featherlight hat denver broncos jared veldheer youth limited orange nike jersey 66 nfl therma long sleeve har…
riskoffall
galaxy tab a 2018 pouzdro topper coat a 拧aty puma sf berretto guess mens white shoes sicherheitsschuhe fersend盲mpfung tab s3 dekking
debooks
unicorn iphone cover fred perry laptop zak iphone se k暖啪e pouzdro 膷ern谩 mini 拧aty rose zlato zoo york baseball berretto steve madden blush pumps
campkentico
new era cappello storage red wing tower climbing boots biker boots mit perlen s10 led back hoesje mens nike new york jets 51 brandon copeland limited camo 2018 salute to service nfl jersey mesh plecak walmart
manipaldubai
s7 pouzdro with card holder 膷erven茅 long ruffle 拧aty under armour berretto size chart shoes for standing up all day blau satin abs盲tze wedding otterbox 6s phone hoesje
ammgmpa
avengers endgame crew hat adidas beckenbauer pantaloni b臎lav谩 converse 70 adidas ultra boost triple fekete n艖i 膷ern谩 casual p谩nsk茅 adidas predator tango 18.3 bianca
cposhop
bruin leer mini rugzak galaxy s9 plus charger pouzdro plus size r暖啪ov媒 skater 拧aty sunbody gus cappello popular shoes of 2018 stella mccartney slip on schuhe
spection
draft cappelli osiris d3 reflective inch blau schuhe rose goud airpod hoesje nfl nike carolina panthers 70 trai turner green salute to service mens pullover hoodie m臋skie travel portfel with chain
proyectodono
uag pen臎啪enka pouzdro iphone x large button 拧aty tampa bay buccaneers fitted cappelli ladies black leather mules duflex schuhe lg k4 hoesje
domicours
s7 pouzdro with card holder 膷erven茅 long ruffle 拧aty under armour berretto size chart shoes for standing up all day blau satin abs盲tze wedding otterbox 6s phone hoesje
kitesurfapp
pantaloncini adidas ragazza decathlon nike hypervenom homme negro adidas tiro 17 p baseball berretto converse cip艖k haditenger茅szet k茅k fit 茅s flare feh茅r midi ruha
giftswiki
mexican peasant 拧aty new era world series cappelli red t strap sandals schneeschuhe damen wasserdicht samsung tab s4 book dekking kyrie irving swingman black jersey
fmsfonline
拧aty sweatshirt pè°©nsk茅 texas rangers new era mlb oro badge 9fifty snapback berretto caterpillar steel toe tennis shoes plush running schuhe iphone 10 wireless charging hoesje nike youth adam humphries limited orange alternate jersey tampa bay buccaneer…
salondutaxi
fioni night icicle glitter pump schwarz female schuhe s6 phone hoesje portemonnee lindor jersey fila fanny pack rè´¸å¶owy avid 559 phone case
varmanco
felpa adidas rossa zip neon rose converse azul snakeskin retro 11 a flat berretto cool asics cip艖 shein leopard print ruha
kearnyvp
schwarz leder buckle stiefel iphone x lifeproof hoesje review limited womens justin reid pink jersey nfl nike houston texans 20 rush fashion gothic bum torba iphone 8 plus case swarovski zwart diamond fanny pack
donhelps
arts crafts light boxes womens athletic walking 3 industrial scientific wash bottles womens totes 6 automotive lubricants electrical home kitchen bedroom sets 2
zensnepal
carpet zak handles minnie mouse iphone 5s pouzdro 膷ern谩 mandarin collar 拧aty miami marlins 47 mlb on field replica 47 clean up berretto skechers empire slip on trainer ladies sportschuhe herren rot
imambinbaz
two tone blazer 拧aty cowboy cappello shop new basketball shoes peter hahn waldl盲ufer s4 battery hoesje joe theismann washington redskins womens limited burgundy number alternate 80th anniversary nike jersey red gold
wolfslaar
schwarz leder buckle stiefel iphone x lifeproof hoesje review limited womens justin reid pink jersey nfl nike houston texans 20 rush fashion gothic bum torba iphone 8 plus case swarovski zwart diamond fanny pack
coinhamster
nokia 6.1 lifeproof pouzdro light nachov媒 拧aty with sleeves clint nero cowboy cappello ecco biom hybrid 2 spikeless golf shoes schwarz damen fila disruptor galaxy s9 alcantara dekking
notinmycart
kavu clutch portfel lg stylo 4 case military grade goud handtassen new look nba youngboy iphone 7 plus pouzdro burgundy faux k暖啪e 拧aty under armour favorite wordmark berretto
ariomusic
nmd cs2 core noir rose rosado bajo top converse zapatillas georgia bulldogs extra logo snapback berretto n艖i z枚ld converse alacsony tops n艖i fekete tank ruha boston rouge sox 47 mlb kaki snapback casquette
scionnation
a buon mercato fitted berretto apple abdeckung iphone 8 fekete arany sequin ruha carcasa samsung galaxy a5 iphone 7 lå¿™der sag midnight blue mint zielony dress buty
morisonsws
freedom iso mens damen cut out loafers spigen pixel 3xl hoesje nike youth eddie george limited white road jersey tennessee titans nfl 27 vapor untouchable fancy clutch portmonetka iphone 8 loopy case
macrium
phone case with water and glitter inside zak roberto cavalli kryt for iphone 10 hot r暖啪ov媒 fit a flare 拧aty tommy hilfiger fisherman cappello doc martens lace up boots
owlcti
schwarz leder buckle stiefel iphone x lifeproof hoesje review limited womens justin reid pink jersey nfl nike houston texans 20 rush fashion gothic bum torba iphone 8 plus case swarovski zwart diamond fanny pack
ankiworld
nike vapormax flyknit mujer uk hm coral robe wit hoog rise converse chicago blackhawks fitted klobouky new era new balance wx608v4 training sko michigan wolverines present mesh kasket
riezumujyuku
felpa nike nsw puma ferrari chaussure blanc et noir asics gel phoenix mujer tampa bay rays new era mlb team classic 39thirty berretto air force 1 midnight haditenger茅szet feh茅r piros silk ruha
mesimpsonco
leinenschuhe weiten personalized phone hoesje galaxy s9 plus nike womens donovan smith red one color tampa bay buccaneers nfl 76 pullover hoodie sharkk portfel p20 pro glass case brahmin elisa zak
malloferta
home kitchen lidded storage bins 1 girls active top bottom sets 6 mens robes 6 home kitchen travel mugs tumblers 5 toys games balance bikes 3 industrial scientific floor stand signs