Most of you are probably already familiar with the following videos:
(The remainder of Zappa’s performance can be found here.) These videos have made the rounds numerous times over the years, but I don’t know if anyone’s ever looked into any possible connections between Cage and Zappa. To me, these two performances and their respective contexts are too similar to be coincidental. I think it’s very likely that Zappa saw Cage’s appearance on television and modeled his own performance on it. Even if there isn’t such a direct connection between the two videos, I think it’s more than likely that Zappa at least had some of Cage’s theory in mind.
I think there’s a lot to say here, so I’ll limit my discussion here to a little background info on the two videos. I’ll follow up in a second post with a brief analysis of Zappa’s discourse regarding Cage.
The first video shows John Cage in his February 24, 1960 appearance on the CBS game show I’ve Got a Secret. Typically, the show features contestants with unusual, amazing, embarrassing, or otherwise humorous secret. A panel tries to guess their secret using only yes/no questions. The host, Garry Moore, considered Cage’s secret–
I’m going to perform one of my musical compositions … The ‘instruments’ I will use are: a water pitcher, an iron pipe, a goose call, a bottle of wine, an electric mixer, a whistle, a sprinkling can, ice cubes, 2 cymbals, a mechanical fish, a quail call, a rubber duck, a tape recorder, a vase of roses, a seltzer siphon, 5 radios, a bathtub, and a grand piano.
–to be intriguing enough to forgo the game in hopes of allowing time for the entire piece to be performed (with the further hope of a Q&A afterwards).
Floorplan for Cage’s Water Walk [1]
The piece Cage performed, Water Walk, was an adaption of his earlier piece Water Music (1952) which is generally thought of as the first of Cage’s so-called “theater pieces.” Cage originally adapted the piece for a performance on a different game show, the Italian program Lascia o Raddoppia (loosely translated: “double or nothing”) in January of 1959.
John Cage on Lascia o Raddoppia with host Mike Buongiorno
On Lascia o Raddoppia, contestants answered questions on a topic of their choice. If they were successful, they were invited back the following week to answer harder questions for progressively larger winnings. A contestant who made it through all five weeks stood to win five million lire (approximately eight thousand dollars). Cage, an accomplished mycologist, answered questions about mushrooms with the aid of an interpreter. Cage made it through all five weeks and bought a new piano with his winnings upon returning home. More significantly, Cage was also invited to perform one of his compositions each week of show. Water Walk adapted the earlier Water Music to be more appropriate to the televised medium.
Detail of the score for Water Walk [2]
Compared to Water Music, Water Walk is much simpler. Cage’s specifications for the timing of various events are much less specific. More significantly, however, Cage seems to have introduced a greater degree of humor to the second piece, pandering to the lighthearted nature of television and its audiences. I think the added humor was something that would surely have appealed to Zappa.
(The only other performance of Water Walk by Cage was done on The Henry Morgan Show in June of 1959.)
In the other video, we see Zappa performing on The Steve Allen Show three years later. Zappa’s piece, a “concerto for two bicycles, a pre-recorded tape and the musicians in the back” is much more improvised. As Zappa points out in the pre-performance interview, he hadn’t been playing the bike very long.
Jerry Hopkins, the show’s talent coordinator recalls how Zappa landed the gig:
The rules for my job were simple. Get someone who was genuinely eccentric or who did something at least a little strange or out-of-the-ordinary, but never make fun of them—the idea was to have fun with them. And, no fakes, no frauds, no bogus acts looking for exposure and willing to do anything to get it, no put-ons or send-ups, no cons. Because, Steve assured me, they never, ever worked, and they embarrassed everyone.
Only once did I ignore his advice and that was when I got a call from a young man who identified himself as Frank Zappa. He said he wanted to teach Steve how to “blow bicycle.” “Blow bicycle,” I repeated.
“Yeah, you know, like, the bicycle is a musical instrument.”
(You can read the rest of Hopkins’ account here.)
Zappa’s performance even got a write up in a local Cucamonga newspaper:
“Ontario Composer, Steve Allen To Play Wacky Duet”
Frank Zappa, 22, Ontario resident and composer of music, serious and otherwise, will be seen on television tomorrow night playing a bicycle concerto for two with Steve Allen. The show is at 11 p.m., Channel 5. “It’s very funny,†said Zappa. “You play a bicycle by plucking the spokes and blowing through the handle bars.†Other methods of producing “cyclophony†is to stroke the spokes with the bow of a bass fiddle, twirl the pedals and let air out of the tires. The Zappa-Allen concerto will be abetted by a man in the control room fooling around with a tape recorder and by a jazz group which will supply toneless background noise. Zappa studied music and art at Chaffey College. He wrote the score for “The World’s Greatest Sinner,†a low-budget tale about a sacrilegious imposter who repents. “Sinner†had its premiere at Vista-Continental Theater, Hollywood, and opened Wednesday at the Ken Theater, San Diego. Zappa writes musical commercials for TV and radio. They are recorded at Pal Studio, Cucamonga. [3]
These videos both provide neat examples of how the frequently-opposed worlds of art and pop occasionally intersect. A lot of the responsibility for these meetings can be placed on television. I haven’t quite worked this out completely yet, but it seems that for Zappa, the added visual dimension of televised performance goes hand in hand with what he thought about Cage.
In both of these videos, what interests me is the awkward mix of polite respect and anxious laughter on the parts of the hosts and the audiences of each show. I think that these two videos give us an intimate glance a very specific moment in the history of avant-garde music. Audiences (and television programmers) were still receptive to experimental ideas, which themselves hadn’t yet been relegated to exclusive academic circles.
From my perspective, nearly fifty years later, it’s remarkable how adventurous television programming was in the middle of the twentieth century. It’s easy to complain about the lack of this sort of programming nowadays, but I think these examples might give us a better understanding of the current situation.
myowniq
fila tee 拧aty cotton sleep berretto sole bliss boots most comfortable herren penny loafers customize your iphone hoesje russia blank red home long sleeves soccer country jersey
delmarballet
mens nike buffalo bills 55 jerry hughes limited royal blue tank top suit nfl jersey purple summer dress plus size iphone xr flip case lgk20 plus case under armour storm match play adidas mens ultimate365 heather golf polo
nomographics
nike presto salmon adidas compression leggings photo collage iphone case jordan long sleeve white samsung 9 otterbox case speck tough case
usmccam
stuart weitzman halfway boot geox sukie wei脽 iphone 7 plus storage hoesje nike youth gabe jackson limited white jersey oakland raiders nfl 66 rush vapor untouchable drippy ita torba lg6 cell phone cases
mydink
incipio pen臎啪enka pouzdro iphone 7 n谩mo艡nictvo bardot prom 拧aty bass pro mesh cappello light pink ladies shoes lonsdale damen schuhe s8 printed dekking
artpoli
膷ern谩 拧aty party look patagonia bear trucker cappello sketchers wide shoes pumps gr枚脽e 46 g眉nstig s6 active portemonnee hoesje whitney mercilus red name number logo nfl nike houston texans 59 long sleeve t shirt
cshore
uomo cotton fedora cappelli womens adrenaline gts 18 running shoes geox velcro schuhe phone hoesje with popsockets on them toddler 76ers shirt cavalli class torebki uk
hixnet
nike air force 1 07 lv8 beige plaid cc beanie red plaid swing dress long sleeve sparkly prom dress nike nsw tch flc jogger mens white snapback
cutmyface
home kitchen graters 2 tools home improvement push buttons industrial scientific measurement kits womens wear to work pants home kitchen soda makers industrial scientific trash cans 1
peakoilnews
bucket cappello with zip pocket wolverine tarmac boots ballerina schuhe 2019 lg g7 hoesje sean lee cowboys jersey cheap aldo teddy bear portmonetka
playpig
nike hiking torba red supreme iphone 8 plus case ted en baker tassen pitaka carbon pouzdro cotton midi shirt 拧aty canada goose donna beanie
justkidsstore
composite toe boots waterproof acw air force 1 low white plus size little black dress empire waist ui maikai dress limited nike aqua womens william hayes jersey nfl 95 miami dolphins therma long sleeve detroit red wings rinkside pond hockey pullover ho…
arckano
purper small rugzak huawei mate 20 pro smart kryt very zelen谩 lace 拧aty suede baseball berretto donna delson clenton meindl island gtx
drlaurahill
korean 拧aty for p谩nsk茅 volcom boxit cappello steve madden riptide boys schwarz dance schuhe oneplus 5t avengers hoesje mens nike pittsburgh steelers 95 greg lloyd limited black player name number tank top nfl jersey
bitkisayar
tools home improvement bamboo flooring womens newsboy caps 1 tools home improvement recessed bathtubs 2 girls shorts 2 toys games playhouses industrial scientific torque limiters slip clutches 1
mehrhost
blackhawks third personalized authentic black nhl jersey s3xl nick easton mens elite green jersey nike nfl minnesota vikings salute to service 62 oneplus 6 credit card case pink backpack price limited nike camo youth vance mcdonald jersey nfl 89 pittsb…
saronit
nordcap trekkingsandalen custom galaxy s10 plus hoesje nike mens corey liuget limited navy blue jersey los angeles chargers nfl 94 tank top suit waterproof shoulder torba oppo r9s cover kate hill travel portemonnee
durabilttrans
sk贸rzany tote portmonetka with zipper official samsung a7 2018 case lavie roze handtas samsung galaxy a6 clear pouzdro cheetah print overall 拧aty wtaps bucket cappello
sunshiney
cool satchel torebki moment iphone 7 plus case round rugzak handtas phone kryt oppo a71 girls long maxi 拧aty puma bmw berretto prezzo
darievna
bruin leer mini rugzak galaxy s9 plus charger pouzdro plus size r暖啪ov媒 skater 拧aty sunbody gus cappello popular shoes of 2018 stella mccartney slip on schuhe
faqroku
xr iphone phone h眉lle haditenger茅szet k茅k tee shirt ruha new balance 500 hvit new balance 390 damen shoes for women 2019 flyknit vapormax schwarz herren
johngriswold
waist torba superdry case supreme iphone 8 little card portemonnee iphone xs max dragon ball pouzdro modr媒 ruffle 拧aty san francisco giants under armour mlb supervent berretto
enersens
spain 19 rodrigo away soccer country jersey aspinal of london round torba oneplus 6t nylon case marine blauw satin evening zak iphone pouzdro 6 7 8 spanish fiesta 拧aty
beyondbeing
kryt samsung s4 galaxy adicolor cotton bodycon 拧aty detroit tigers new era mlb core classic 39thirty berretto leopard print peep toe booties schwarze schn眉rboots nokia 8 bumper hoesje
samueluherek
nike black womens ted ginn jr name number logo slim fit nfl 19 new orleans saints long sleeve t shirt valentino clutch srebro personalised iphone 5 case two passport portemonnee galaxy s6 glitter pouzdro chi chi london r暖啪ov媒 floral 拧aty
blomaerofilms
los angeles clippers anniversary patch 9fifty snapback 膷epice nike vapormax 膷ern谩 2019 geox baskets compensees femme bostonian f茅rfi dress cip艖 cat in the hatter costume with mask adidas predator football boots rosado
rowanwest
nike x parra varsity jacket dune tan sandals puma hybrid rocket runner mens missguided petite blazer dress new look yellow tartan dress biggie 72 jersey
meztechnik
iphone pouzdro rainbow off shoulder layered ruffle 拧aty new england patriots 47 nfl dark charcoal clean up berretto bass winter weejuns zehentrenner 42 damen samsung j3 2017 hoesje ireland
cityzencane
pretty phone case long strap canvas zak winnie the pooh silicone phone pouzdro neon midi bodycon 拧aty dallas cowboys cancer cappello ralph lauren moccasins
adsldati
womens formal dresses womens work utility 2 girls cold weather earmuffs 6 baby boys sweaters 6 bady diaper bags 1 mens sunglasses 2
gregdowning
mens nike indianapolis colts 31 quincy wilson limited royal blue rush vapor untouchable nfl jersey radley czarny quilted torba mi redmi 6 cover puma equation rugzak phone kryt cartoon rachel roy caftan 拧aty
faqtrax
3.1 phillip lim alix leer crossbody zak k8 plus phone pouzdro ebay abaya 拧aty burberry fisherman cappello lacing shoes for high arches segelschuhe leder
campusquest
oofos oocloog schuhe covers winter loopy cell phone hoesje womens nike kansas city chiefs 87 travis kelce limited black rush vapor untouchable nfl jersey kenneth cole skè´¸rzany torba moto e4 plus phone cover
trustoc
washington redskins new era nfl shadow tech 39thirty petten fenty puma groen creepers nike air huarache ultra triple fekete wei脽 midi shirt kleid kopen adidas superstar schoenen blank flexfit hoeden
cpsisc
arancia rosso sox cappello ecco womens mary jane shoes slip on dress schuhe iphone se 360 degree dekking yankees 24 gary sanchez white strip usa flag fashion stitched mlb jersey under armour heat gear plecak
emradar
mens hiking boots 1 home kitchen chair covers 1 baby boys footies 5 bady bibs burp cloths sets 5 mens suits 2 womens baseball caps 1
veggiecampus
baby boys robes 1 tools home improvement faucet valves automotive paint tools equipment 1 baby boys sunsuits 5 industrial scientific pipettor accessories home kitchen ceiling mounted storage racks
rungisfruits
iphone xr anime case osprey rugzak fairview huawei p smart 2019 smart pouzdro tight zelen谩 拧aty new era plain berretto merrell encore rexton
ticketjr
uomo marina militare blu flat berretto escalante running shoes thigh hoch schuhe stiefel razer phone leer hoesje nba los angeles clippers pullover hoodie black mary poppins carpet torba portmonetka
jkirlin
fashion shoes for boy gr眉n wedge abs盲tze lg hoesje walmart mens nike new york jets 79 brent qvale elite green salute to service nfl jersey its a small world plecak clear iphone xr cases
parrotalert
7 plus battery case grijs suede clutch zak universal silicone bumper pouzdro cece velvet 拧aty mlb oro berretto metallic balenciaga sneakers
seathemusic
trish scully unicorn 拧aty kentucky wildcats nike ncaa wool true college fitted berretto monogrammed slippers mens engelbert strauss s1 sicherheitshalbschuhe laut iphone hoesje orioles shirt
hitchwireless
industrial scientific cup washers womens bikinis bottoms 3 automotive coolant temperature industrial scientific gauges depth mens fashion hoodies sweatshirts 1 industrial scientific brushes
craftaholics
pretty phone case long strap canvas zak winnie the pooh silicone phone pouzdro neon midi bodycon 拧aty dallas cowboys cancer cappello ralph lauren moccasins
vantivio
nike air max 97 argento metallic adidas yeezy boost 350 triple blanco v2 water glitter phone tok adidas chaussure stan smith vert giacca sportiva nike toddler rouge jordan 12
kueting
marc jacobs iphone xr hoesje nike youth alex cappa limited camo jersey tampa bay buccaneers nfl 65 rush realtree air jordan side torba tactical phone case iphone x lauren ralph lauren dryden ellen rugzak tech21 pure clear pouzdro iphone xs max
satelis
satin lace up formal 拧aty texas rangers fitted baseball berretto balenciaga trainers boys wei脽 perforated schuhe toughest hoesje for galaxy s6 mens brian westbrook elite midnight green nike jersey nfl philadelphia eagles 36 home vapor untouchable
benistabili
n铆zk媒 cut plunge 拧aty oklahoma sooners trucker cappello sharon noel shoes marine blau dress with wei脽 abs盲tze soft hoesje j7 prime nike mens mike alstott limited red home jersey tampa bay buccaneers nfl 40 vapor untouchable
cypherbooks
nike tampa bay buccaneers authentic font long sleeve nfl t shirt grey eagles new era knit hat samsung galaxy a5 back cover ivory maxi dress long sleeve nba city edition hats lipsy red bodycon dress
joliethyundai
steelers draft day cappello scott premium mtb pretty ballerinas schwarz friday good hoesje for iphone xs max nike game barkevious mingo jersey 51 nfl seattle seahawks womens alternate grey eric javits torebki last call