I Come From Nowhere(?)

Andre, , , ,

My dissertation–if you hadn’t already gathered–focuses on the convergence of popular and classical music streams that informs much of Frank Zappa’s music. This confluence means different things in different places (for both Zappa and his audience), but it seems to me to be a defining characteristic that runs through all of his work. My questions here are: Why would this be such an important aspect of his work? and, What influenced him in thinking this way?

Strictly Genteel

On the one hand, Zappa was trying to establish for himself a reputation as a composer of serious art music. His reasons for this are, of course, open to debate, but Zappa was always quick to point out that his ambitions were aesthetically motivated. He was introduced to the modernist music of Stravinsky and Varèse around the same time he began collecting blues and R&B records. Zappa recognized that the disparate styles were commonly seen to be at odds with one another. But since both appealed to him personally, he tried to share this experience of music free from social implications. The obvious way of doing this would be to synthesize these different styles in his own work.

On a slightly different angle, it seems to me that the obvious appeal (and associated cultural capital) of being a respected artist was an equally significant factor. Zappa clearly admired Stravinsky and Varèse (and Webern and Cage, among others) and that he would want to model himself on his “idols” almost goes without saying.

But where does this all come from? What streams (cultural, social, musical) does he fit into? Despite his claims to originality, it seems unlikely that Zappa developed in a bubble.

To begin with, I suspect it may have had something to do with the conservative cultural climate of Southern California in the 1940s and 50s. Zappa saw this environment as oppressive and felt claustrophobic in the rural deserts communities of his youth. For me, Zappa’s self-identification as an outsider is neatly summarized in this 1970 photograph by John Olson of Frank posing with his parents Francis and Rosemary in their home Frank’s Los Angeles home [thanks Corné!]:

Zappa with parents

(Of course, by 1970 Frank had long been out of the house so this picture doesn’t offer an authentic vision of Zappa’s youth. Nonetheless, I think the picture captures much of the spirit of Zappa and his rebellious culture at odds with conservative values, while at the same time offering some ambiguity as to who really belongs in this environment.)

While still a child, he found refuge in the modernist avant-garde. (He would delight in his mother’s recoiling at the sound of Varèse’s sirens being played on the family turntable.) These composers offered a safe mode of rebellion for Zappa in a remarkable way. They were accepted artists–undeniably respectful members of society–whose music had a similar effect with adults to what teenagers experienced with heavy metal in the 1980s.

But I don’t think it ends there. As significant as his rebellion against perceived conservative oppression was, I think there’s something deeper. In discussing when the dichotomy between classical and popular entered the American consciousness, Paul Charosh writes:

We would be mistaken to assume that this division between types of music reflects a simple division between two sets of listeners, one group seeking edification and uplift from classical music and a separate group looking to popular music for a cure for the blues. Some favored light music over serious; others preferred classical music to the popular; but many enjoyed both types of music on different occasions, for different purposes.[1]

Charosh is referring to mid-18th century listeners, but this characterization seems to have some resonance with Zappa’s sentiments a century later. Is this a constant stream in American musical consciousness? Did Zappa inherit this dual validity of opposing musical streams?

For that matter, who else was a part of this? Zappa consistently sought to establish himself as being counter-counterculture. But even as he defined himself against the hippie movement and the politics of the New Left in the 1960s, he took certain aspects of their motivations as his own. Can we consider Zappa to be a part of these movements even if he explicitly denies accepting them?

For now, these thoughts are very preliminary. I don’t have the answers to these questions. (Yet!)

References:
[1] Paul Charosh, “‘Popular’ and ‘Classical’ in the Mid-Nineteenth Century,” American Music, Vol. 10, No. 2 (Summer, 1992), 126.
I Come From Nowhere(?)

32,946 thoughts on “I Come From Nowhere(?)”

  2. ray ban prix aviator

    decor pour buche en chocolat panier de rangement en bois nike air max 90 sneakerboot robe ado pour mariage adidas gazelle heren geel bolso de mano nike new balance 891 uomo bianche adidas superstar promotion

  3. robe chasuble 茅t茅 b茅b茅 mes envies

    body damskie z koronki bia艂e opaska pin up brudny r贸偶 vintage zima faux fur coat kobiety moda faux p艂aszcz bez r臋kawè´¸w patagonia ws active clas cami sous v锚tement thermique femme kratke hla膷e za nose膷nice denim 2 pri mamici joma mu拧ka obu膰a za tr膷anje…

  4. party ruha 18335 fekete catwalker

    tappeto bagno microfibra stemma alpini sabot uomo ray ban 2019 uomo anelli rosario amen maglie storiche del milan 谩rukeres艖 fejhallgat贸 k茅k pipere t谩ska tisza cip艖 amerikai futball nadr谩g

  5. christian louboutin suzanna pumps size us 7 regular m

    it genserne vi elsker hvilken er din favoritt julekampanje betal i februar indigi apple iphone x 10 tempered glass screen 360 full body protective case cover blk new renee cook super strong loveless tpu case best i test sykkelvogn 2019 se tester i pris…

  6. bluza damska guess jeans krè´¸tka z napisami

    r贸偶ami co kolory kwiatè´¸w adidas adizero club ayakkabè°‹ t眉rkiye indirim gri erkek datart chytr茅 nè°©ramky honor lmtd baggy pant glitter tygbyxor barn svart kriste bell modelleri kriste bell haki s眉et æžšn眉 beyaz 莽apraz bantlè°‹ y眉ksek topuklu platform ayakkabè°‹…

  7. blundstone kids 诪注讬诇 讘诇谞住讟讜谉 讬诇讚讬诐 讘爪讘注 谞讬讬讘讬

    caf茅 illy machine nike zoom cage 3 hc a line square neck sleeveless tulle flower girl dresses in lol surprise backpack expandable rucksack girls school bag pink galaxy intricate palladium mobius twist wedding ring green jonathan paul eyewear vintage su…

  8. white gucci belt

    korenblauwe overall voor dames en heren bruin leren dames laarzen maat 42 marktplein korte mouw midi jurk dettagli su cielo scuro blu chiffon tessuto poliestere abbigliamento 150cm wide.per dettagli su kappa t shirt canotta vintage 70 80 canotta camise…

  9. calvin klein classic bikini hvid

    takkel for kast fra land hvorfor ansette en gravid kvinne kommentarer diamant junior sykkel 24 camisole silketré…¶ye corporate cupsole sneaker neo noir jade stribet skjorte navy neo noir skjorter til mokkasiner sko ké…¶b goddess lang ré…¶d blondekjole pyjama…

  10. tinta neon comprar

    conjunto de talheres de bambu vestido de festa frente unica bordado pulseira a莽o bon茅 adidas feminino aba reta mochila adidas power 3 table cuisine chaise curtain world shutters

  11. gavekort til gratis pré…¶vetime kreativt fitnesscenter

    dame skjorte bluse hvid med broderinger mokkasiner sko ké…¶b buksesté…¶rrelser omregning goddess lang ré…¶d blondekjole mads né…¶rgaard georgette jumpsuit mæžšrkblæ°“ badekæ°“be lasarito pink women bianco bfbetricia twin strap slippers red bh bojle kvinder underté…¶j

  12. desigual b艖 nadr谩g

    seventy abbigliamento prezzo scarpe antinfortunistiche cofra giochi vestire spose e truccare motosega a scoppio alpina offerte la pierre ingruha alkatr茅sz szerviz verziè´¸ marco tozzi cip艖 bakancs csizma 38 as t1 polistirolo in palline babbo natale sport…

  13. 瀹夊叏銇?蹇仼銇ソ銇椼個鐐恒伀 銉愩偆銈伀鏈€閬┿仾銈广儩銉笺儎

    銉斻兂銈?銉兂銉斻兗銈?鍐?/a> adidas stan smith co kadè°‹n spor ayakkabè°‹ svart kavaj kl盲nning styling instagram posts deskgram bracciale dodo a granelli in argento e resina nera 銉椼兗銉?puma 銈广儖銉笺偒銉?銉忋偆銈儍銉?銉偞 sky hi 24 绶?銈兗銈?sr42 銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?/a> 銉兗銉溿儍銈?銈︺偐銉笺偔銉炽偘銈枫儱銉笺偤…

  14. moves by minimum kjole nila dusty plum

    telenor nettbutikk asics gel ds trainer 21 tester nkd nitro v4 trikse sparkesykkel hele norges skate og pc sekk med trykket eller brodert logo alle type varer med belsac abelone blæ°“ clutch m. skulderrem i skind hula pige bobble figur til bilen gobabygo…

  15. tankini 2018 women swimsuit

    china floral hot fashion swim shorts surf beach board shorts china maxmessy women lace hollow swimwear strap dress cover ups dress sleeveless beach tunics bikini wrap outside buy coutures paris antoinette burgundy swimsuit for women in saudi baker by t…

  17. otc knee support with condyle pads

    2019 2018 new women swimming trunks bottom sexy low waist shorts swimwear briefs female swim pants optional from caicloth jean green high waisted shorts size 14 depop shop mens coffee makes me go tshirt funny fa rt joke tee for guys on sale free shippi…

  18. coque nike galaxy j1 duos

    pure drive 110 tire de carte gratuit vetement pas cher internet jogging adidas gris orange ceinture haut de gamme femme chemisier en soie noir info bagage ryanair manteau femme hiver oversize

  19. ikea spejl badevå¿™relse

    conjuntos de padel hombre fundas huawei p9 2018 zapatos perry ellis hombre prego briller ver de terre udsalg rapper kostume sort bå¿™lte herre offerta scarpe invernali luci per scale interne sciarpe donna grandi gucci dolomite polo urban ring uomo

  20. maximo lue m skygge marineblæ°“

    romerikes blad mannen bak verdenssuksessen jeg sov med ideal of sweden magnet lommebokdeksel for iphone 7 plus æ°“pningstider bé…¶senteret lederhosen kostyme oktoberfest karneval premium t skjorte for kvinner solgul brandbil lego 10592 eco strawz bé…¶rste ti…

  21. sort drapy bukser

    simone 3 mikkel sæ°“dan gé…¶r du det simple bryllup å¿™stetisk blæ°“ selected homme skjerf selected homme herreskjerf til vis meg din cyclocross blandevei bodé…¶ sykehusapotekene i nord lingeri og underté…¶j online natté…¶j basis natkjole kort underbukser herre tilb…

  22. pas cher magasin noir carhartt acrylique suivre bonnet

    black chaussures pour femmes en cuir v茅ritable de bomba啪ne 啪enske nogavice atomic elektri膷ni upalja膷 promo nike air spizike acheter robes trompette sir猫ne de la mode des femmes du printemps 2019 dungeons and dragons dungeon masters guide 5th edition eb…

  24. hoodie tr酶je lyser酶d r茅sum茅

    girls bardot junior coats outerwear free shipping clothing sheep fur coat fashion womens coat 2017 new men blazer fashion brand new quality luxury wool blends suit blazer masculino male suits jacket m 6xl light jacket with dark pant my style in 2019 me…

  25. kate spade new york large polly leather crossbody bag

    stivaletti uomo scarpe beige stivali casual cerniera zip puzzle da 1000 pezzi marca ravensburger vista su alesund norvegia abiti matrimonio 2017 spring wardrobe upgrade all new prada paradigme saffiano bag gucci pink marmont hot suede gg logo fringe bl…

  26. onia calder 10 pop leaves swim trunk

    best mall dot flip up modular full face motorcycle helmet dual visor motocross size opt yeezy boost 350 v2 butter house of cop personal luxury shopper cotton supreme snapback cap snapback clothing mens anaheim ducks fanatics branded black orange authen…

  27. tecidos finos comprar online

    t锚nis converse all star european ox branco t锚nis reebok royal effect w shades curtains blinds quilt supplies online vestidos fiesta dia outlet nike air max 90 tapete para bano estabilizador de camisa cruzeiro palestra all star converse netshoes

  29. nyakl谩nc szem茅lyre szabott infinity arany 4 n茅v aj谩nd茅k doboz

    chanel 銈枫儯銉嶃儷 銉炪儓銉┿儍銈汇€€銉併偋銉笺兂 銈枫儳銉儉銉笺儛銉冦偘 銉偠銉?銉栥儵銉冦偗 銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?涓彜 converse all star 銈炽兂銉愩兗銈广偑銉笺儷銈广偪銉?銇?銉︺儖銈汇儍銈偣 銉忋兂銉夈儛銉冦偘 銈枫儳銉儉銉笺儛銉冦偘 銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?銉愩儍銈?2way 娓呮绯?/a> man kalsonger superdry orange label 3 pack underkl盲der amazon 銈枫儕銉儹銉笺儷 銉堛兗銉堛儛銉冦偘 銉愩儍銈?…

  30. valigie samsonite grandi

    2016 nueva marca pantalones cortos para hombre pantalones esprit collection chaqueta de entretiempo navy hombre libri per bambini un libro per realizzare grandi giochi di scarpe da calcio nike con calzino nero scarpe vendita 50 di sconto nero giardini…

  31. Funda silicona TPU suave trasera para iPhone 7 8Plus

    卮禺氐賷丞 丌賷賮賵賳 xs 丨丕賮馗丞 賲囟丨賰 丕賱賰乇鬲賵賳 噩乇丕亘 賴丕鬲賮 丌賷賮賵賳 X XS 11Pro 賲丕賰爻 XR 賱胤賷賮 丕賱賯胤 鬲賵賲 睾胤丕亍 賱賷賳丞 爻賷賱賷賰賵賳 賵丕囟丨 Funda personalizada TPU para iPhone 7 Plus Funda protectora personalizada para iphone, funda protectora personalizada para iphone 11 11Pro Max 6S…

  32. nadal 啪eleo tajno ven膷anje

    arilje general data ras champion speed rope 400 sport vision en ce moment sur le lego shop home 40254 nutcracker et lego marvel avengers ps4 buy titans terrors and toysplay with the dc universe in lego lego architecture solomon r. guggenheim museum xc2…

  33. bottes ugg bailey bow ii fille en rose ugg petite

    bordo komadi kojima je nemogu膰e odoljeti preklopni elektri膷ni bicikl fy 057 odin jakna ab tex softshell d艂ugi sweter czarny sprzedam transformator transformatory per艂owe wizytè´¸wki na st贸艂 stakleni svije膰njak s u obliku bo啪i膰ne kuglice ks tools orodje s…

  36. saucony shadow mens green

    maillot de bain taille haute pas cher vetement homme cyclisme la martina manteaux le coq sportif jacket pink snapdeal online shopping bags nike hypervenom 2015 adidas originals newburgh watch skechers high tops mens scarpe bianche nike prezzo debardeur…

  37. deine schwarze kleidung wird schnell grau dann w盲schst du

    coque otterbox pour iphone cas texturis茅 argent茅 de t茅l茅phone de chasse de echarpe et bonnet femme pas cher polaroid pilotenbrille verspiegelt kæžšnigsprodukte gravurplatte namensanh盲nger details zu meerjungfrau kleid abi ballkleid lang abendkleid ball f…

  38. jersey pique wrap dress

    讚诇转讗 谞注诇讬 讘讬转 谞砖讬诐 砖诪诇讜转 诇讬讜诐 讬讜诐 2018 indian chiffon embroidered frock br 讬讬注讜抓 驻讬谞谞住讬 讜驻谞住讬讜谞讬 讬讜注抓 驻讬谞谞住讬 讛讗诐 讗谞讬 爪专讬讱 讘讬讟讜讞

  39. botas invierno 2015 mujer

    amazon per vendere gucci bamboo spray lavori di natale fai da te 2016 prolife gatto biglietti coppa italia inter collane lunghe con ciondolo bigiotteria zaini economici amazon lettino pieghevole neonato daniel wellington bianco e nero borsa tracolla ma…

  41. air max 270 noir blanc et bleu

    adidas dragon bambino vendita t shirt disney vintage jack purcell low top slip on sneaker ecco mens trainers sale adidas yeezy 500 80s oro scarpe samsonite puma skechers la tenue du cuisinier cycliste velo femme diamant homme perruque naturelle remy ha…

  42. insmat pirate robust deksel deksel til nettbrett

    klar parat skolestart de bedste bé…¶ger om skolestart mvmt herreur stort udvalg af mvmt herreure til skarpe priser mink horse signature zip shirt lange å¿™rmer fischer sprint jr é…¶kologisk baby sengeté…¶y traktor freds world 70×100 cm nrk og tv 2 deler fotbal…

  43. sol med solbriller

    ilse jacobsen rub1 lange gummisté…¶vler sort sol med solbriller samsé…¶e samsé…¶e frankie bukser regular fit gré…¶n hvorfor ansette en gravid kvinne kommentarer diamant junior sykkel 24 skisko klassisk klassiske skisko for langrenn oslo birdie lysslynge titani…

  44. 銉嗐儑銈ｃ偡銉с儍銉?teddyshop 姘寸潃 銈裤兂銈儖 銈枫儳銉笺儓銉戙兂銉?t

    mavi deri mont fiyatlarè°‹ gyerek tè°©ska oroszlè°©n pierre cardin erkek takè°‹m elbise siyah 54 beden adidas erkek modelleri ve fiyatlarè°‹ elegancki p艂aszcz m臋ski ombre c269 granat xxl ceny i opinie hogyan a haj borotvè°©lkozè°©s utè°©n adidas ap8335 wandertag pad j…

  46. baba pl茅d 80x110cm the best friends narancss谩rga

    tute lacoste prezzi abito da sposa da sera nike da calcio 2018 logo gioielli pasztell zæžšld selyemkend艖 varrè´¸ gabi selyemfest艖 organza menyasszonyi ruha vintage esk眉v艖 luna felakaszthatè´¸ kozmetikai tè°©ska. ç…¤j 3 400 ft by andra h茅tkæžšznapi ruha envy air jo…

  47. botines art piel modelo amsterdam

    black white sheer chiffon sarong wrap beach cover up women swimwear swimsuit free shipping drop shipping deep v neck backless plain high cut one piece swimsuit white primitive croydon shorts negros y azules switchali ba帽adores mujer 2017 una pieza casu…

  48. studenterhue orange

    zapatillas boxeo mujer tenis de basquetbol nike 2015 deportivas mujer talla 43 poc borsa da viaggio paracolpi lettino rosa dolomite coast to coast costumi 2015 uomo abbigliamento jordan uomo abiti eleganti bambina economici venta de pelotas de futbolit…

  50. modeli poslovnih pisama

    babyono 070 bezpe膷nostn茅 popruhy pre deti hugo boss ro膷na ura samsung galaxy 6 cijena acquisti online donna spinello nero quarzo prince argento prodotti mania vintage vintage luxury authentic guaranteed alla moda donna giubbino colmar economici online…

Comments are closed.