I Come From Nowhere(?)

Andre, , , ,

My dissertation–if you hadn’t already gathered–focuses on the convergence of popular and classical music streams that informs much of Frank Zappa’s music. This confluence means different things in different places (for both Zappa and his audience), but it seems to me to be a defining characteristic that runs through all of his work. My questions here are: Why would this be such an important aspect of his work? and, What influenced him in thinking this way?

Strictly Genteel

On the one hand, Zappa was trying to establish for himself a reputation as a composer of serious art music. His reasons for this are, of course, open to debate, but Zappa was always quick to point out that his ambitions were aesthetically motivated. He was introduced to the modernist music of Stravinsky and Varèse around the same time he began collecting blues and R&B records. Zappa recognized that the disparate styles were commonly seen to be at odds with one another. But since both appealed to him personally, he tried to share this experience of music free from social implications. The obvious way of doing this would be to synthesize these different styles in his own work.

On a slightly different angle, it seems to me that the obvious appeal (and associated cultural capital) of being a respected artist was an equally significant factor. Zappa clearly admired Stravinsky and Varèse (and Webern and Cage, among others) and that he would want to model himself on his “idols” almost goes without saying.

But where does this all come from? What streams (cultural, social, musical) does he fit into? Despite his claims to originality, it seems unlikely that Zappa developed in a bubble.

To begin with, I suspect it may have had something to do with the conservative cultural climate of Southern California in the 1940s and 50s. Zappa saw this environment as oppressive and felt claustrophobic in the rural deserts communities of his youth. For me, Zappa’s self-identification as an outsider is neatly summarized in this 1970 photograph by John Olson of Frank posing with his parents Francis and Rosemary in their home Frank’s Los Angeles home [thanks Corné!]:

Zappa with parents

(Of course, by 1970 Frank had long been out of the house so this picture doesn’t offer an authentic vision of Zappa’s youth. Nonetheless, I think the picture captures much of the spirit of Zappa and his rebellious culture at odds with conservative values, while at the same time offering some ambiguity as to who really belongs in this environment.)

While still a child, he found refuge in the modernist avant-garde. (He would delight in his mother’s recoiling at the sound of Varèse’s sirens being played on the family turntable.) These composers offered a safe mode of rebellion for Zappa in a remarkable way. They were accepted artists–undeniably respectful members of society–whose music had a similar effect with adults to what teenagers experienced with heavy metal in the 1980s.

But I don’t think it ends there. As significant as his rebellion against perceived conservative oppression was, I think there’s something deeper. In discussing when the dichotomy between classical and popular entered the American consciousness, Paul Charosh writes:

We would be mistaken to assume that this division between types of music reflects a simple division between two sets of listeners, one group seeking edification and uplift from classical music and a separate group looking to popular music for a cure for the blues. Some favored light music over serious; others preferred classical music to the popular; but many enjoyed both types of music on different occasions, for different purposes.[1]

Charosh is referring to mid-18th century listeners, but this characterization seems to have some resonance with Zappa’s sentiments a century later. Is this a constant stream in American musical consciousness? Did Zappa inherit this dual validity of opposing musical streams?

For that matter, who else was a part of this? Zappa consistently sought to establish himself as being counter-counterculture. But even as he defined himself against the hippie movement and the politics of the New Left in the 1960s, he took certain aspects of their motivations as his own. Can we consider Zappa to be a part of these movements even if he explicitly denies accepting them?

For now, these thoughts are very preliminary. I don’t have the answers to these questions. (Yet!)

References:
[1] Paul Charosh, “‘Popular’ and ‘Classical’ in the Mid-Nineteenth Century,” American Music, Vol. 10, No. 2 (Summer, 1992), 126.
I Come From Nowhere(?)

32,946 thoughts on “I Come From Nowhere(?)”

  1. zeppelin lz 127 count f茅rfi kar贸ra 7644

    valigie leggere e capienti etichette tessuti taglia scarpe diadora unfield dual feh茅r gyerek hosszç…¤ ujjç…¤ pè´¸lè´¸ sæžšt茅tk茅k v茅kony kæžštæžštt kabè°©t abbigliamento rugby vestiti donna immagini h铆mzett kæžšt茅ny hè°©romszæžšg kend艖vel 4600 ft n艖i kabè°©t vè°©sè°©r min艖s茅gi aig…

  2. software dise帽o camisetas

    dekoracje 艣lubne rustykalne onesie kigurumi polska bobasy baby born botki ocieplane 35 sexowna bielizna meska tommy hilfiger tabela rozmiarè´¸w butè´¸w sukienka z 偶akietem rozmiar 44 kardigan fioletowy bia艂e kurtki damskie zimowe akcesoria dmuchane do base…

  3. 噩丕賰賷 賳爻丕卅賷 賯氐賷乇 卮賲賵丕賴 亘丕賱賱賵賳 丕賱亘賳賷 賷丕賯丞 毓乇賷囟丞

    kolczyki listki z艂ote wiertarko wkr臋tarka sieciowa mikrofon na baterie marynarka dresowa damska wszystko o modzie baby hose outdoor funny t shirt rainbow deadpool lgbt gay pride gaypridehub 銈广優銉笺儓銈偢銉ャ偄銉伄濂虫€с亰鎵嬫湰銈炽兗銉囬泦 銉夈儸銈广偝銉笺儔銇湇瑁呫優銉娿兗銈?/a> szlifier…

  4. 莽ift spor k谋yafeti ko艧u spor giyim grubu sat谋n al aerobik giyim spor grubu giyim bask谋

    hè°©tizsè°©k trimm futè°©r 35 l nike nsw dwn fill bombr erkek g眉nl眉k ceket 928819 072 kadè°‹n b眉y眉k beden nak谋艧lè°‹ ka艧e kaban tsd0246 siyah tsd0246 dam vila vihonesty new maxi d kl盲nning ljusgræ°“ olcsè´¸ vidaxl strandtè°©ska vè°©szon 茅s valè´¸di b艖r k茅k 茅s markus unisex…

  5. neymar air jordan nike

    salomon trail running backpack 20l skechers on the go 600 flip flops mens sweat è„¿ capuche whistles legging coton femme chaussure homme 47 t shirt soutien gorge note 9 prix adidas black and white mercurial vapor 12 adidas t shirt donna marrone puma swea…

  6. chaussure luxe italienne femme

    lack badeanzug naketano sweatjacke m盲nner converse fourr茅e enfant moule gateau forme pantaloni neri eleganti stretti tessuto divano bauletto girls on film etuikleider blau mit arm nachthemd jungen

  7. s.belmonte f茅rfi b艖r p茅nzt谩rca 谩tkapcsol贸val fekete

    armani exchange 拧木apky biela atrakt铆vne dè°©mske hodinky g d mal茅 zlat茅 najpredè°©vanej拧ie zna膷kov茅 拧iltovky e shop lajka pi霉 alla moda g forcina da sposa da sposa strass clip otc6211w teleszkè´¸pos pè°©raelsz铆vè´¸ n艖i merev ez眉st nyaklè°©nc teny茅sztett gyæžšnggyel…

  8. kakve novosti nas o膷ekuju u online kupnji rtl vijesti

    obuwie dzieci臋ce botki koszyk na zabawki do k膮pieli kurtka zimowa damska dstreet prezent dla m臋偶czyzny na walentynki 蟽蟿畏 尾慰蠀位纬伪蟻委伪 纬喂伪 苇蟺喂蟺位伪 蟺伪喂未喂魏维 蟺伪蟺慰蠉蟿蟽喂伪 20 factory outlet 蟺伪喂未喂魏伪 伪胃位畏蟿喂魏伪 蟺伪蟺慰蠀蟿蟽喂伪 伪胃位畏蟿喂魏维 蟺伪蟺慰蠉蟿蟽喂伪 魏慰蟻喂蟿蟽喂蠋谓 welcome stores å–‚è …ç»´…

  9. 住专讙诇 诪讬讚讜转 讘讙讚讬 讬诐 诇谞砖讬诐 讗讜诇住讟讗专

    blaues langes kleid welche schuhe brillenversand online seltmann weiden allegro damen parka 眉bergang praia bikini winflo 5 zoom chuteira futsal joma top flex vermelha botafogo mercado da bola timberland eua

  10. pulsera enfermera plata

    calzettoni givova stivaletti pioggia zaino solo soprani costumi da mare nike giacca pelle armani jeans stivali ugg bassi neri smalto gel come si mette zapatillas jordan air 1 nike con resortes 2018 teni fila 2018 scarpe cinti donna

  11. biancaluna copriletti

    loja reebok online brasil tenis de gel nike toquinha para beb锚 de croch锚 mercurial roxa e verde peluches de cumplea帽os jeffrey campbell designer almacenes alkosto celulares botas ni帽a zara ponto frio samsung s8 onde comprar uma polaroid bebe de pijama

  12. converse chuck taylor all star bajas marrones

    vans qualitè„¿ di prima classe donna authentic sneakers occhiali da sole arnette 01 25 green mirror light caldaie a condensazione ariston i prezzi dei migliori modelli elegantes baratos vestidos de noche largos 2017 moda alikeey dama de la moda borla bot…

  13. sagan klapki damskie

    zegarki allegro damskie portfel obag dokumenty potrzebne do 艣lubu konkordatowego buty zx damskie d艂ugie kolczyki z per艂ami divan dizajn kolektiv nakit za sezonu jesen zima lutka na satu umjetnosti sorto ytong obiteljska ku膰a bruna popularna brazilska i…

  14. hiver new style grand prix veste courte unie effet fourrure

    讟讘注讜转 讗讬专讜住讬谉 yes i do 注拽讘讬诐 诇讬诇讚讜转 拽讟谞讜转 拽谞讜 讝讜诇 注拽讘讬诐 诇讬诇讚讜转 拽讟谞讜转 讛专讘讛 诪住讬谉 讞诇拽 转讞转讜谉 砖诇 讘讙讚 讬诐 拽爪专 诇讙诇讬砖讛 诇谞砖讬诐 诪讚讙诐 vera 砖讞讜专 mode homme pull regular fit imprim茅 salsa en original homme e de skate s chaussures homme baskets campus nouveaut茅 chauss…

  15. 慰位喂魏萎 蠁蟻慰谓蟿委未伪 蟿慰蠀 伪蠀蟿慰魏喂谓萎蟿慰蠀 蟽慰蠀

    portfel fossil damski fuksjowe szpilki clarks suitcase pe艂ne dane osobowe z艂ote baleriny ccc hrvatska zaklada za znanost ict integracija 膷arape i halteri index oglasi huawei p30 pro zasebni uporabniki telekom slovenije ljetni poplun tarrington house 蟺蔚…

  16. ceinture fantaisie femme mode

    superga leopard slip on nike hypervenom air jordan royal blue samoa adidas new balance 576 red leather skechers trail homme marron stan smith primeknit grau valise 50x40x20 decathlon son haut de gamme tente decathlon 3 places

  17. easygo 2ofus 3in1 multifunkciè´¸s iker babakocsi latte

    fellowes a3 lamin谩l贸g茅p st. bernard citroms谩rga alkalmi ruha gyerekruha klub portafoglio gucci nero uomo gonna lunga mangano kit rete pallavolo gucci cartoon camicia regali semplici per lei timberland bakancs euro rock whe office shoes magyarorsz谩g

  18. pustne maske na plan i拧膷emo najbolj拧o masko leto拧njega pusta

    batoh bat暖啪ek adidas interaktivn铆 prasè°©tko 膷un铆k slaninka premi茅ra v extralize se hè°©zenk谩艡暖m strakonic nepovedla kryt媒 plaveck媒 baz茅n hora啪膹ovice luxusn茅 dar膷eky pre mu啪ov 膷ierne 膷ipkovan茅 拧aty koucla ve膷ern茅 拧aty a koktejlov茅 b茅啪ov茅 pè°©nsk茅 kotn铆kov茅 p…

  19. erkekler i莽in en sevdi臒iniz klasik tak谋m elbise rengi nedir

    adidas falcon 銈广儖銉笺偒銉?杩斿搧ok 銉曘偋銉兗銈?闀疯病甯?銉°兂銈?felisi 125 nk 0003 銉€銉笺偗銉栥儵銈︺兂 au wowma 銉偊銉?/a> 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銈广儓銉儍銉併儜銉炽儎 銉°兂銈恒伄閫氳博 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銉嶃儍銈儸銈广儊銈с兗銉?璨撮噾灞炪伄绱犳潗銉椼儵銉併儕 ravelry nr 2 fana kofte med rundt bå¿™restykke pattern by puma bayan spor krukker til omplan…

  20. scarpe alte asics

    f茅rfi æžšv 30 mm barna exkluz铆v field co. vè°©lltè°©ska laptop tè°©ska akciè´¸ ft csepel cruiser 26 neo n3 f茅rfi cruiser ker茅kpè°©r 2019 fekete missq casual pamutbè´¸l k茅sz眉lt szett der茅kban decollete nere tacco 10 dolomite stivaletti eleganti uomo accappatoio borbo…

  21. tom tailor suede biker jacket 渭蟺慰蠀蠁伪谓 纬蠀谓伪喂魏蔚喂慰 1005146 29999

    posudice za spremanje hrane 2 kom 5711 outlet tepisi vivre the flexx 啪enska cipela rodea jasne szpilki sanda艂y czy trampki to obuwie sportowe french country 苇蟺喂蟺位伪 cantico cantico ralph lauren 蟺慰蠀魏维渭喂蟽慰 jean oxford 蟽蟿蔚谓萎 纬蟻伪渭渭萎 渭蟺位蔚 蠂蟻蠀蟽伪 蟺伪喂未喂魏伪 蟽蔚蟿 魏…

  22. by malina maxikjole

    讻讬住讜讬 诪讬讟讛 讬讜拽专转讬 诇讘谉 诪讘讚 住讗讟谉 诪砖讬 讗讬讻讜转讬 讘砖讬诇讜讘 转讞专讛 讘转讜诐 诪讻专讝 讬讞 爪 讗讚讬讚住 讬砖专讗诇 讘讞专讛 讘 讚谞讬 诇讜讬 转拽砖讜专转 诪转谞讛 诪拽讜专讬转 诇讙讘专 falketind flex1 bukse zurich 住讟 诪讝讜讜讚讜转 讘讚 4 讬讞 32 28 24 19 讗讬谞讟砖 swiss voyager 拽诇讜转 诪砖拽诇 讻讞讜诇 讙讬谞住 鈧? 讻专讬转 诇诪谞讬注转 驻爪注讬 诇讞抓 讻专讬转 诇讻住…

  23. bogart well dressed well served fashion bogartstore

    rebride 砖诪诇讜转 讻诇讛 注诐 谞讬住讬讜谉 砖诪诇讜转 讻诇讛 讬讚 砖谞讬讛 拽讛讬诇讛 爪讬讜讚 诇讞讬讬诇讬诐 壮 壮 壮 壮 壮 陆 壮 壮 壮 壮 壮 讝讗驻 讛砖讜讜讗转 诪讞讬专讬诐 诪讻谞住 讻讜转谞讛 讗驻讜专 birkemo 80s rock kostyme dame 80 tallet tema flere virksomheder viser flaget og sté…¶tter copenhagen pride zodiac halskå¿™de jomfru oxy…

  24. flamingo zabawka pluszowa krè´¸wka niebieska 34cm

    to by艂 dobry rok najlepsze gry 2019 roku na pc ranking p艂aszcz dzianinowy wielokolorowy bonprix p艂aszcze klasyczne damskie be偶owe w bonprix napisy z drewna drewniane napisy litery imiona du偶e d臋bowe narz臋dzia r臋czne narz臋dzie wielofunkcyjne 14w1 stanle…

  25. 诪讚讘拽讜转 拽讬专 诇注讬爪讜讘 讛讘讬转 注讬讙讜诇讬诐 讗讜专讬谞讟诇讬讬诐

    转讜住祝 砖诪谉 诪专讜讻讝 诇诪谞讜注讬 讚讬讝诇 stp 讗讜讟讜 365 讘讜讘转 讚讬住谞讬 诪讬拽讬 诪讬谞讬 诪讗讜住 诪谞讙谞转 winfun helly hansen vintersko sté…¶veé…¶ tundra cwb svart græ°“ google publiserer ny statistikk toppmatet vaskemaskin test 2019 de beste toppmatede sminke til bé…¶rn makeup til bé…¶rn uden p…

  26. modern bomber jacket night

    warriors boys kids sports botki obcas czarne sembonia synthetic leather shoulder bag dark brown bota feminina cano alto preta salto sanda艂y nike 26 silver and gold tag watch tea 210 2 pcs red pearl necklace set pad do playstation 2 bluzy lekarskie skle…

  27. sneakers fluo gucci

    sporthose damen lang weit tarnmuster pullover damen tegami tupperware guess anh盲nger festliche mode h m heine maxikleid jersey preisvergleich stand up paddle borsello hype bauletto faith zaino in pelle carpisa

  28. robe pull longue col roul茅

    stylish navy half sleeve t shirt childrens remote control toys good cruiser city bike brands san francisco teddy bear doll plush toys panda ragdoll birthday gift special offer puma womens smash v2 buck trainers under armour outlet outlet malls violet n…

  29. zapatillas adidas energy boost

    skechers antideslizantes zapatos de futbol olmeca zapatillas merrell mujer catalogo bambas suela gorda tastiere gaming migliori marsupio sahaja capelli bianchi cause dolomite cartella pelle uomo siti vestiti lunghi foulard floreali

  30. sparkly converse shoes

    adidas frauen schuhe superstar new balance 860 damen preis school bags for university jogging b茅b茅 garcon pas cher bottillon caoutchouc femme lunette rouge et noir

  31. housse de telephone samsung j5

    asics gel kayano donna grigio bike equipment bag nike mercurial victory ag mens football boots vans shorts herren silber felpa reebok performance fila berlin coque chanel samsung galaxy a coque soccer assurance iphone voliere exterieur pas cher

  32. boots homme boucle

    lfp resultados sandalias plataforma y tacon ancho regalos por navidad stradivarius mujer vestidos 2018 mejores botas trekking 2018 sandalias deportivas ni帽a ripley zapatillas merrell mujer comprar nike tiempo camperas columbia de pluma

  33. vestido floral azul

    gerry weber kleider 2017 new balance wl574 w schuhe grau pink push up bikinis g眉nstig heine muster f眉r damen strickjacke freundschaftsarmband geflochten kr眉ger steinheim trachtenmode heine g眉nstige schuhe damen pendelleuchte wei脽 rund palestra italia u…

  34. popolno膷n茅 拧aty

    flag poles and parts silver anodized ball ornament nonnyl s925 sterling silver pearl necklace freshwater cultured pearl pendants women wireless earphone recommendation pet valu cat toys crystal star charm pendant in sterling silver on 14 inch choker le…

  35. eastpak noir blanc

    anya hindmarch handbags dakine blue backpack dji phantom 3 standard backpack trotteur pour fille adidas stan smith nio nike ballista running shoes ray ban lunette de vue enfant nmd cs2 adidas oro rosa

  36. siste julegaver pæ°“ nett

    zimowa kurtka columbia south canyon lined jacket olive green prsten chirurgickè°© ocel swarovski kadin tagged bilekten ba臒lè°‹ yazlè°‹k 艧anslè°‹ ayakkabè°‹cè°‹lè°‹k amazon 銉娿偆銈?銉椼儶銉兂銉堛儶銈兗銉儸銉笺偟銉?銈广儖銉笺偒銉?coach 銈炽兗銉?銉斻兂銈?銉愩儍銈?銈枫儳銉儉銉?銉曘儶銉炪偄銉椼儶 銉┿偗銉?s 銈儛銉笺儠銉儷set 姘寸…

  37. ladies longline gilet

    zapatillas force moda jovenes 2016 lacoste style calzado moderno para hombre adidas superstar nere righe bianche eskimo uomo marsupio j.mclaughlin deguisement pat patrouille fille basket legere running coque puma iphone 7 pro chaussure eram pas cher bl…

  38. chiemsee sporttaschen

    ropa para ni帽as gucci pulseras actividad fisica comparativa hermana abusa de su hermano menor lentes de dama de moda max mara sommerkleider daunenmantel reduziert mæžšbel deutschland online kurzarmhemd ralph lauren outdoorjacke damen gelb 讘专讬讻转 讗讜专讞讛 讘专讬…

  39. montature occhiali da vista avvolgenti

    r眉ckenfreies abendkleid kurz nike air force 1 gr枚脽e 37 emporio armani uhr lederarmband coat pant brooch stivali texani amazon idee per creare borse plaid trapuntati mini orologio high heels braun heine kommode wei脽 tiefe 40 cm

  40. tommy portfel damski

    kolorowe t shirty cacharel boots vestidos ajustados para bodas catalogo andrea para ni帽a 2016 liquidacion de ski corte ingles blazer ro偶ek dla noworodka na zim臋

  41. jaki expres do kawy ci艣nieniowy

    little live pets ptaszek cena dmuchany brodzik 啪enske torbe osijek trixie igra膷ka za pametne pse mini mover game ruksak 拧kolski teen disney soy luna p20 netto str贸j neymara oryginalny str贸j k膮pielowy 5 10 15 torebki puma sklep

  42. puma speed cat classic camo

    article de danse classique pas cher trench imperm茅able femme avec capuche robe longue boheme ecru affaire b茅b茅 naissance adidas soccer cleats f50 asics t shirt fille 2017 poussette peg perego trio book cross reebok shoes for women price promo vans homm…

  43. only mantel grau kapuze

    fundas para xiaomi redmi 3s gucci hombress pulsera with diamantissima motif bluse mit hohem kragen schlipse kaufen heine strickjacke schwarz fabrizio koffer test gæžšrtz zahlung auf rechnung 讻住讗 诪谞讛诇讬诐 诪驻讜讗专 讙讚讜诇 讜专讞讘 诪转讗讬诐 诇讻讘讚讬 诪砖拽诇 转诪讜谞讛 砖诇 诪讙驻讬 住拽讬 诇…

  44. comprar bambas nike mujer

    crocs o cross botin tacon cuadrado negro zapatos choclos de hombre decimas adidas ni帽a camiseta malla camisas columbia de mujer adidas predator sin cordones polos calvin klein mujer scarpe con zeppa interna ash sconti 20 coop rebecca bracciali uomo

  45. george cox suede leather creepers 3976

    adidas tee running fyller tee legend bl盲ck pappers handdukar och vikt handduk fotografering fæžšr maxikl盲nning dam anna field maxikl盲nning beige ræžšd naketano dam parkas online billiga mæžšrkgræžšn skapa væ°“ningsfat av tallrikar skæ°“lar erkek kè°‹yafetiten blazer…

  46. tenisky dc chelsea tx d谩msk茅 v r暖啪ov媒 czech

    hasznè°©lt garage sapka eladè´¸ luè—•ne spodnie bawe艂niane mancs 艖rjè°©rat skye jelmez 104 cm 丕賰爻爻賵丕乇丕 賴賳丿賷丞 賲賲賷夭丞 2020 fæžšrsvarets kalsonger storlek 5 silvini pè°©nskè°© bunda parina pribor za 膷i拧膰enje kamina como hacer pantalones baggy mujer 1 a帽o de la fiesta de…

  47. ile kosztuje oryginalna torebka louis vuitton

    perilica posu膽a samostoje膰a bosch super silence serie asos curve waterfall parka jakna br. 54 prodaja le啪ajeva 39 蟺伪喂未喂魏慰委 蟽蟿伪胃渭慰委 蠂伪蟻维蟼 蟽蔚 蠈位畏 蟿畏谓 蔚位位维未伪 渭蔚 蠂蟻蠋渭伪 蟿伪喂谓委伪 led 渭蟺位蔚 deepcool blue 渭伪纬谓畏蟿喂魏萎 纬喂伪 魏慰蠀蟿喂维 伪未喂维尾蟻慰蠂畏 胃萎魏畏 samsung galaxy s10 wat…

  48. nuovo bracciale pandora rigido prezzo

    superdry orange label superdry mens military jacket s army california baron von black leather long coat for mens vf personalized custom baseball uniform san costo espadrillas originali gucci costumi interi bianchi regali originali per lui san valentino…

  50. parma retail nike

    mizuno wave elevation 2 rosse new balance sweatshirt kids 2017 kitten heels sale kyrie 2 womens grey nike hypervenom phantom 3 for sale new balance 996 gris y azul vans iso 1.5 negro new balance 501 women yellow zapatillas salomon hot sale nike air for…

Comments are closed.