I Come From Nowhere(?)

Andre, , , ,

My dissertation–if you hadn’t already gathered–focuses on the convergence of popular and classical music streams that informs much of Frank Zappa’s music. This confluence means different things in different places (for both Zappa and his audience), but it seems to me to be a defining characteristic that runs through all of his work. My questions here are: Why would this be such an important aspect of his work? and, What influenced him in thinking this way?

Strictly Genteel

On the one hand, Zappa was trying to establish for himself a reputation as a composer of serious art music. His reasons for this are, of course, open to debate, but Zappa was always quick to point out that his ambitions were aesthetically motivated. He was introduced to the modernist music of Stravinsky and Varèse around the same time he began collecting blues and R&B records. Zappa recognized that the disparate styles were commonly seen to be at odds with one another. But since both appealed to him personally, he tried to share this experience of music free from social implications. The obvious way of doing this would be to synthesize these different styles in his own work.

On a slightly different angle, it seems to me that the obvious appeal (and associated cultural capital) of being a respected artist was an equally significant factor. Zappa clearly admired Stravinsky and Varèse (and Webern and Cage, among others) and that he would want to model himself on his “idols” almost goes without saying.

But where does this all come from? What streams (cultural, social, musical) does he fit into? Despite his claims to originality, it seems unlikely that Zappa developed in a bubble.

To begin with, I suspect it may have had something to do with the conservative cultural climate of Southern California in the 1940s and 50s. Zappa saw this environment as oppressive and felt claustrophobic in the rural deserts communities of his youth. For me, Zappa’s self-identification as an outsider is neatly summarized in this 1970 photograph by John Olson of Frank posing with his parents Francis and Rosemary in their home Frank’s Los Angeles home [thanks Corné!]:

Zappa with parents

(Of course, by 1970 Frank had long been out of the house so this picture doesn’t offer an authentic vision of Zappa’s youth. Nonetheless, I think the picture captures much of the spirit of Zappa and his rebellious culture at odds with conservative values, while at the same time offering some ambiguity as to who really belongs in this environment.)

While still a child, he found refuge in the modernist avant-garde. (He would delight in his mother’s recoiling at the sound of Varèse’s sirens being played on the family turntable.) These composers offered a safe mode of rebellion for Zappa in a remarkable way. They were accepted artists–undeniably respectful members of society–whose music had a similar effect with adults to what teenagers experienced with heavy metal in the 1980s.

But I don’t think it ends there. As significant as his rebellion against perceived conservative oppression was, I think there’s something deeper. In discussing when the dichotomy between classical and popular entered the American consciousness, Paul Charosh writes:

We would be mistaken to assume that this division between types of music reflects a simple division between two sets of listeners, one group seeking edification and uplift from classical music and a separate group looking to popular music for a cure for the blues. Some favored light music over serious; others preferred classical music to the popular; but many enjoyed both types of music on different occasions, for different purposes.[1]

Charosh is referring to mid-18th century listeners, but this characterization seems to have some resonance with Zappa’s sentiments a century later. Is this a constant stream in American musical consciousness? Did Zappa inherit this dual validity of opposing musical streams?

For that matter, who else was a part of this? Zappa consistently sought to establish himself as being counter-counterculture. But even as he defined himself against the hippie movement and the politics of the New Left in the 1960s, he took certain aspects of their motivations as his own. Can we consider Zappa to be a part of these movements even if he explicitly denies accepting them?

For now, these thoughts are very preliminary. I don’t have the answers to these questions. (Yet!)

References:
[1] Paul Charosh, “‘Popular’ and ‘Classical’ in the Mid-Nineteenth Century,” American Music, Vol. 10, No. 2 (Summer, 1992), 126.
I Come From Nowhere(?)

32,946 thoughts on “I Come From Nowhere(?)”

  2. closca loop helm zwart inklapbare design fietshelm en1078 skatting step monowheel

    mango fina skjortor dam rea blæ°“ cool lounge uppblæ°“sbar stol mac online shop 蟿蠋蟻伪 渭蟺慰蟻蔚委蟼 谓伪 伪纬慰蟻维蟽蔚喂蟼 蟿伪 魏伪位位蠀谓蟿喂魏维 蟽慰蠀 蟺位萎蟻蔚蟼 蟽蔚蟿 蟺慰蟿畏蟻喂蠋谓 蟽蟿蟻慰纬纬蠀位慰 尉蠀位喂谓慰 蟿蟻伪蟺蔚味喂 288 蟺慰位蠉蠂蟻蠅渭伪 蠁蠅蟿维魏喂伪 蠂蟿伪蟺蠈未喂 good morning dekbedovertrek prinses 140 x 200 cm ketting…

  3. a kutya a legjobb bar谩t gal茅ria 谩llatv茅d艖 egyes眉let

    zsebes nadrè°©g n艖i sateenvarjorattaat musse cloud falida graco matkarattaat myyd盲盲n ole tarkkana black friday tarjousten kanssa kuluttaja læžšysi flik flak nuorten kello blue ahead zfcsp031 gyæžšnyæžšrç–Ÿ festett n茅met fa è°©gy matraccal jè´¸ helyen 眉l irodai beren…

  4. klju膷avnica za kolo na prstni odtis

    pantalon de ski quiksilver homme pas cher 砖诪诇转 讻诇讛 爪谞讜注讛 注诐 砖专讜讜诇讬诐 francuski le啪aj sanja 150 200 matis name拧taj lindenmann g眉rtel herren lederg眉rtel herren automatik g眉rtel como montar o seu negè´¸cio online de modelagem 3d com baixo scarpin preto bico…

  6. t臎hotensk茅 tri膷ko miminko zbo啪铆 prodejce maglina fler

    superfit zimn铆 boty 3 09080 01 velikost 36 a啪 42 膷ern茅 dè°©msk茅 maxi 拧aty manteau court camel femme la redoute vendre a perte pom d api walk basic marron bottines converse femme chaussures rose all star loveheart basse chemisier femme classique bureau af…

  8. j贸fog谩s h谩zt贸l h谩zig orsz谩gos h谩zhozsz谩ll铆t谩s kisokos

    銈汇儍銉堛偄銉冦儣 銉娿偆銈?nike 銉°兂銈?pk 銉欍兗銈枫儍銈?銉堛儵銉冦偗 銈广兗銉?涓婁笅銈汇儍銉?861781 1901 銈搞儯銉笺偢 瑁忚捣姣?閫佹枡鐒?au wowma 銉偊銉?2016 air jordan 銈ㄣ偄銈搞儳銉笺儉銉炽偄銈搞儯銈广偪銉栥儷 銉兗銉?銈儢 銈?銉兂銈般伄涓婃槧銈广偙銈搞儱銉笺儷 鏄犵敾鎯呭牨 鏄犵敾銇檪闁?/a> collana donna con ciondolo cuore girocollo lunga da ragazza sz铆nes…

  9. spodnie 7 8 tight w 154560

    torba adidas w tr co tote letonika. multivide sendienu latvija att膿los. c膿sis ionglass privacy for iphone 11 pro max xs max cip i igre za playstation 3 mali oglasi framsohn otro拧ka brisa膷a s kapuco otro拧ki varnostni brezrokavnik hudora z odsevniki otro…

  10. elegantn谩 b茅啪ov谩 kabelka

    converse cip艖 hasznè°©lt military visit to gy艖r honv茅delem.hu online verk盲ufe sexy backless abendkleider lange 2018 new diesel gelbe unterhose mit logo und men gelb bevalsa damen warm mantel lange winterjacke steppjacke bis zu 30 60 rabatt promo herren n…

  11. oasis animal wrap dress

    kovovè°© robotickè°© ruka arexx ra1 pro conrad.sk zelen媒 kunzit hiddenit vans ua old skool dè°©msk茅 tenisky katalog pln媒 strapless vestito with slit dorothy perkins petite maxi zara abito a tunica with belt pepe jeans kabè°©ty pepe jeans modrè°© kabè°©t gwen krajk…

  12. reebok damskie khaki

    gafas de sol maxi mujer moda el armazones polo ralph lauren memoria p谩rna cip艖 air force 1 duckboot low wzornictwo krak贸w portfele m臋skie opole bokserki m臋skie k膮pielowe

  13. topuri si bluze in urban

    diadora 銉囥偅銈儔銉?銉嗐儖銈广偊銈с偄 銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?銈枫儳銉笺儓銉戙兂銉?l銇?涓彜 鍙ょ潃閫氳博 ripndip 銉椼儷銈兗銉愩兗銉戙兗銈兗 銉°兂銈?銉撱偢銉嶃偣銈枫儱銉笺偤 銉曘偐銉笺優銉?銉偗銉兗銉?銉兗銉曘偂銉?銉兗銈儷 銉炪儹銉濄儍銉濊粛鏇?銉儍銈恒偝銉笺儓銈掍娇銇ｃ仧銈炽兗銉囥偅銉嶃兗銉?wear 銈ㄣ偝銉?ecco linnea work bag rose dust 銈偊銉堛儸銉冦儓閫氳博 浣滄キ鏈嶄綔妤潃 澶┿伄鎭?鏄ュ绉嬪啲鍏肩敤 閫氬閫…

  14. adidas neo femme gemo

    marsupio s.o.s by orza studio borsa arlettis coccinelle abbigliamento e accessori per cani uomo camicia gucci breil ciondoli vestiti matrimonio estate 2016 slip on alte pull col polo homme legging marque pas cher veste cuir burberry

  15. 卸械薪褋泻邪褟 芯写械卸写邪 斜芯谢褜褕懈褏 褉邪蟹屑械褉芯胁 芯锌褌芯屑 芯褌 锌褉芯懈蟹胁芯写懈褌械谢褟 屑芯褋泻胁邪

    銉愩儍銈?銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?sale 30 off blucielo nuovo 銉栥儷銉併偋銉笺儹 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銈儑銈ｃ儉銈?銉┿儍銉椼偪銈儷 l 銈搞儱銉嬨偄 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 hukuro 銉庛兗銈裤儍銉乻ecom銈兗銈便兗銈?鏈潻 鏍冩湪銉偠銉?銈兗 30锛卭ff 銈儔銉熴儵銉?銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?銈广儖銉笺偒銉?銉栥儵銈ゃ儓銉?銉囥儖銉?銉囥儖銉? 銈汇儰 seya 銉堛儸銉炽儊銈炽兗銉?銈点偆銈鸿〃瑷樼劇 銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?涓彜 銉炪兗銉°偆銉夈偣銈兗銉?銉併儱銉笺儷銈广偒銉笺儓…

  16. racchetta di djokovic

    诪讝专讜谉 讚讜讞讛 诪讬诐 讚讙诐 讻祝 专讙诇 转诇讬讜谉 讬讛诇讜诐 讝讛讘 爪讛讜讘 讘讞讬转讜讱 讟讬驻讛 砖专砖专转 讬讛诇讜诪讬诐 专讜谞讬转 诇讜诇 拽诪驻讬谞讙 诪转拽驻诇 诇讜诇 诪转拽驻诇 讛转讬拽 诇转讬谞讜拽 讜诇讬诇讚 诪讬讟讜转 讜诇讜诇讬诐 讬讚 zaino con corde bauletto the couture club scarpe hogan ultimi modelli orologi femminili sportivi wenger austrian…

  17. r谩me膷ek box velikosti 3

    nella the princess knight vestito up petite abiti fall 2018 k拧iltovka adidas s16 the packcap dt8576 black black white pè°©nskè°© tri膷ka no fear zbo啪铆 zapatos zuecos de tacè´¸n iva en serpiente env铆o gratuito en spæ°“nskiva golv tg4 pila za motorno 啪ago 4 women…

  18. robe 14 ans habill茅e

    taureau avec taureau bottines grande largeur adidas originals zx 500 uomo prezzo new balance women 996 rihanna slip on pumas new balance crt300 donne nere volleyball backpack with ball holder puma thunder desert femme 2018

  19. veste suedine camel homme

    puma toddler grey cristiano ronaldo soccer boots stan smith dames wit sac a ficelle nike perruque fantaisie mini peluche panda coque balenciaga bumper iphone 6 maillot une piece d茅collet茅

  20. dè°©mske plè°©tenky adidas

    samsung predstavio digitalnu olovku koja izgleda kao obi膷na futrola magnetic frame za samsung a750f galaxy a7 2018 12 haljina iz zare koje morate uloviti na sni啪enju fashion summer elfordulè°©sgè°©tlè´¸ pè°©rna gæžšrd铆thet艖 f眉rdet艖sz茅k marvel a hihetetlen pè´¸kemb…

  21. nyckelband slice of life carolina gynning

    test urbanista tokyo billiga hæžšrlurar med grumligt ljud kæžšp mfi billaddare fæžšr iphone 4 fyndiq snabbt mobilladdare iphone 5 snæžš of sweden æžšrh盲ngen elsa coin ring clips fæžšrlovnings bræžšllopsringar att leva tillsammans gesprek bondgenoten overvecht zimihc…

  22. abat jour in vetro

    iphone 6 finanziamento tasso zero abito carnevale topolino prezzo pittura termica gutschein bonprix bestandskunden sandalen online dicker schal schwarz exklusive damenmode reduziert lange kleider damen hochzeit calida pigiami levigatrice da muro bosch

  23. under armour freedom logo t shirt for men blackwhite 3xl

    safety equipment 拧portov茅 vesty abbigliamento 1 classe venta de productos para u帽as esculpidas cagliari piscina m贸da pro d臎ti boden white dress grey pink bridesmaid dresses windsor dress blue sexy indian dress champion sleeveless kd 12 youth

  24. 讚讬讜 诇诪讚驻住转 讘专讗砖讜谉 诇爪讬讜谉

    讙诇讙讬诇讬讜转 讘诪讘爪注 讗讜驻谞讜注 50 住诪 拽 诇讬诇讚讬诐 fiskars lehtiharava hinta 枚ljyn m盲盲r盲 谞注诇讬 谞讬讬拽 诇讬诇讚讜转 驻诇讗驻讜谉 讟诇讜讬讝讬讜转 讚谞讬讗诇 讗讚专讬 转讻砖讬讟讬诐 诪拽专专 砖讗专驻 4 讚诇转讜转 724 诇讬讟专 讗驻诇讬拽爪讬讜转 诇诪砖拽驻讬 诪爪讬讗讜转 诪讚讜诪讛 拽讟诇讜讙 诪拽专专讬诐 诪讙祝 讗讜住讟专诇讬 讘讝讜诇

  25. gaudi shop on line

    schweizer marke jacke rot blau karierter schal cold shoulder kleid schwarz sneaker beige nike asciugamani per palestra negozi online bambini economici gucci 茅tui samsung galaxy grand plus chemin de table dentelle blanc samsung 4k fernseher 50 zoll hein…

  26. lyhyt parta

    arabis 茅tkez艖asztal b茅zs omnitronic speaker cable 2×2.5qmm black teraszfç–Ÿt艖 k眉lt茅ri h艖sugè°©rzè´¸ hasznè°©lt bakancsok olcsè´¸n charcoal respirator tommy hilfiger feh茅r tanga brazilian lexa 1 ajtè´¸s 1 fiè´¸kos 铆rè´¸asztal dobos bç…¤tor kft zombi kirè°©lyn艖 jelmez gyere…

  27. 屑械褏邪薪懈褔械褋泻懈械 褔邪褋褘 winner skeleton simple golden 谐邪褉邪薪褌懈褟 12 屑械褋褟褑械胁

    vans ua authentic 44dx 銉愩兂銈?銈兗銈汇兂銉嗐偅銉冦偗 銈儠銈枫儳銉儉銉笺儻銉炽償銉笺偣 銉炪偔銈?銈儯銉熴偨銉笺儷銉兂銉斻兗銈?銉偆銉ゃ兗銉?/a> 杩斿搧閫佹枡鐒℃枡 銉戙儓銉儍銈?patrick 銈广儖銉笺偒銉?銉溿偣銉堛兂 銉儍銈偣 givenchy 銈枫儳銉儉銉笺儛銉冦偘 榛?2way 銉偠銉笺伄涓彜 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銉栥儷銉?銉兂銉斻兗銈?鏌勮姳 妞嶇墿 銇€氳博 澶с亶銇勩偟銈ゃ偤 銉儑銈ｃ兗銈?銉溿儓銉犮偣 銈广偒銉笺儓 銉熴儔銉…

  28. 啪enske 膷arape za baletanke 膷ipkaste i

    obuca za bebe prona膽i obuca za bebe u kategoriji bebi plitke mu拧ke 膷izme sa logotipom tommy hilfiger somborski oglasi kupujem prodajem toy story die cut drinking bottle with straw alien signs at shop recent updates and snapshots minecraft sainsburys sa…

  29. ghillie sandals

    les robes pas cher couvre matelas anti punaise bagage volotea site vente homme superstar strisce pitonate tiendas donde venden adidas superstar reebok sporttasche pink dyson seche cheveux airwrap coque nfl samsung note 8 plus ecco soft 4 womens green

  30. borse piero guidi scontate

    reggiseno con chiusura anteriore borsa liu jo anna bauletto personalizzazione orologi scarpe reebok bianche donna miglior tostiera cintura vintage luisa spagnoli autunno inverno 2016 2017 magliette stretch uomo bracciale fabrizio corona jan茅 crosswalk…

  31. mocassin rouge femme

    maillot string noir lac des bouillouses randonn茅e mocassin michael kors lisseur silvercrest prix clip on nao膷ale cijena kopacke sa carapom cene akcija podnice za krevet baterija 18650

  32. bodo 拧e kdaj imeli bazen

    martes kurtka damska 3w1 lady legrano acai whitered rose r. s schab nadziewany broku艂em gutschein gutschein kaufen josef seibel spirit of nature leder lloyd agostino herren sneaker aus leder 759739 im online timberland boots weiss hellblau saia nè´¸ cint…

  33. zapatos color nude beige sandalias de vestir

    sandalias de cu帽a de esparto. susan. alpargater铆a de par slinky zapatos altos black brazalete sodial pulsera de joyeria de hombres y mujeres reloj inteligente michael kors access touch oro rosa 爻丕毓丞 apple watch 丕賱匕賰賷丞 è³´è³· 丌禺乇 噩賴丕夭 賷禺囟毓 賱賱 賮賰賷賰 賲賳 賯亘賱 丕賱…

  34. 賰賱 賲丕 乇賷丿 賲毓乇賮 賴 毓賳 賴丕 賮賷 爻丕賲爻賵賳噩 galaxy a7 2018 賵 a9 2018

    t锚nis adidas originals x plr preto camiseta basica yves saint laurent speedo pullover hoody sudadera negro botines adidas espa帽a alpargatas todoterreno gala gonzè°©lez en la semana de la 亘丕賱氐賵乇 丕賰爻爻賵丕乇丕 噩匕丕亘丞 è³± 夭賷賷賳 乇賯亘 è³° 毓賱賶 胤乇賷賯丞 丕賱賲卮丕賴賷乇 賰賱賲丕 丨 賵賷 毓賱賶…

  35. ricambi per orologi breil

    handy ladekabel media markt rockabilly shop xxl 1803 schratt kollektion bogner geldbæžšrse amazon massagematte auto wanddeko kinderzimmer junge dvd online shop kæžšnig kost眉m erwachsene t shirt 23 billige strumpfhosen 3 puzzleteile cane bullmastiff prezzi…

  36. a legjobb tes贸k n艖i p贸l贸

    zaino in pelle louis vuitton bollitore elettrico kenwood vestito blu uomo cravatta tamaris n艖i cip艖 1 22418 23 418 dolce gabbana n艖i tripla karkæžšt艖 retro jeans billie n艖i ræžšvid ujjç…¤ pè´¸lè´¸ ræžšvid ujjç…¤ fels艖k speedo gyerek bathrobe microterry apple g konto…

  37. 賲 噩乇 賯氐乇 丕賱丕賵丕賳賷 賯丿賵乇 丕賱囟睾胤

    jack jones vintage tri膷ko nejlep拧铆 vans retro skate sk8 mid p谩nsk茅 blankyt zlat茅 betsy & adam plus size vestiti 锌褍褏芯胁懈泻 track down moda nova plus size estivo vestiti

  38. i love shoes scarpe

    scarpe dsquared sneakers gucci flora for uomo mocassino scamosciato blu ii.vilè°©ghè°©borç…¤s horogkeresztes porcelè°©n tè°©ny茅r militè°©ria nike cip艖 webshop tan pl ræžšvidnadrè°©g fekete xl f茅rfi beats solo3 wireless black unghie in acrilico colorate orologi o bag 2…

  39. f茅rfi sztreccs j茅gerals贸

    h m ruha 34 es 5990 ft aress sabina k茅tr茅szes lè°©nyos f眉rd艖ruha hè°©tizsè°©k frozen j茅gvarè°©zs disney 40cm gyerek fullcap alterego webshop 铆gy neveld a sè°©rkè°©nyodat ovis hè°©tizsè°©k 45 æžšs divatos f茅rfi vè°©szon cip艖 tæžšbb rekeszes mç–Ÿb艖r tè°©ska guess blog tæžšræžšlkæžšz艖 s…

  40. zimski kaput sa kapulja膷om crven

    pandora lederarmband 3 fach armband mit gold verschluss 585 in kinder winter kleid f眉r m盲dchen baby 拽住讚讜转 诇讗讜驻谞讬讬诐 najbardziej popularny okulary przeciws艂oneczne marc jacobs z艂oty sinn schenken in wien aion goldkette gold 585 zopfkette freundschaftsb盲n…

  42. bumbu sp膿les b膿rniem cena aptuveni 1 l墨dz 17

    muski lancici od hirurskog celika ipanema sandale my first iv baby dexy co kids smart trike smart fold 700 tr墨sritenis transformeris 8 in 1 pelnu trauki iek拧telp膩m un 膩rpus t膩m aj produkti latvijas iedz墨vot膩ji st膩v gar膩s rind膩s p膿c jaun膩 iphone 6s slav…

  43. osprey exposure 36

    zalando fr promo chaussures femme doudoune fine et courte femme foulards femme pas cher bijoux fantaisie site table bois pied central sweat 脿 capuche nice things ann茅e 70 deguisement magasin bottes homme paris tee shirt femme pour les fetes

  45. okazja philips s艂uchawki nauszne sbchl 140

    t锚nis feminino doma shoes plataforma armè°©rio de cozinha 6 portas 2 gavetas montesa kits paranè°© nogal arena okulary zerè´¸wki fa my little pony mekko l盲mmin toppatakki studio 8 martina mekko musta naisten mekot britax selk盲 menosuuntaan turvaistuin max fi…

  46. blusa azul pull amp bear de segunda

    handy bluetooth lautsprecher test 敫旊（韴姢 雲胳澊歃?caixa de som no ponto frio hé…¶yttaler test 2016 mochilas para la escuela luoqi marca alta calidad oxford mujeres mochila escolar mochilas parfois mochila de nylon acolchada las tiendas para comprar y reutili…

  48. les chaussure italiennes

    fossil uhr m盲nner schwarz harry potter kaufen kette mit austauschbaren scheiben herrenuhren mit extra langem armband ralph lauren reduziert air max 97 ultra blanche decathlon survetement kalenji completi calcio sandali legno donna cappelli di lana ai f…

  49. top paillettes argento

    collezione scarpe guess inverno 2016 unghie gel giallo fluo tuta adidas originals uomo parka donna imbottito coque eellesse prix portable samsung coque vans iphone 5s ou se damen handschuh gr枚脽entabelle new look negozio

  50. top bandeau elastique

    custom grip iphone x leather case mustard newport suspenders najlacnejsie skolske tasky pekne blaho啪elanie k narodeninam 90r eastpak e ek620 zaino zaini sportivi yogi pakr padded 3mm surgical stainless steel ball chain tiffany co. authentic silver ball…

Comments are closed.