Most of you are probably already familiar with the following videos:
(The remainder of Zappa’s performance can be found here.) These videos have made the rounds numerous times over the years, but I don’t know if anyone’s ever looked into any possible connections between Cage and Zappa. To me, these two performances and their respective contexts are too similar to be coincidental. I think it’s very likely that Zappa saw Cage’s appearance on television and modeled his own performance on it. Even if there isn’t such a direct connection between the two videos, I think it’s more than likely that Zappa at least had some of Cage’s theory in mind.
I think there’s a lot to say here, so I’ll limit my discussion here to a little background info on the two videos. I’ll follow up in a second post with a brief analysis of Zappa’s discourse regarding Cage.
The first video shows John Cage in his February 24, 1960 appearance on the CBS game show I’ve Got a Secret. Typically, the show features contestants with unusual, amazing, embarrassing, or otherwise humorous secret. A panel tries to guess their secret using only yes/no questions. The host, Garry Moore, considered Cage’s secret–
I’m going to perform one of my musical compositions … The ‘instruments’ I will use are: a water pitcher, an iron pipe, a goose call, a bottle of wine, an electric mixer, a whistle, a sprinkling can, ice cubes, 2 cymbals, a mechanical fish, a quail call, a rubber duck, a tape recorder, a vase of roses, a seltzer siphon, 5 radios, a bathtub, and a grand piano.
–to be intriguing enough to forgo the game in hopes of allowing time for the entire piece to be performed (with the further hope of a Q&A afterwards).
Floorplan for Cage’s Water Walk [1]
The piece Cage performed, Water Walk, was an adaption of his earlier piece Water Music (1952) which is generally thought of as the first of Cage’s so-called “theater pieces.” Cage originally adapted the piece for a performance on a different game show, the Italian program Lascia o Raddoppia (loosely translated: “double or nothing”) in January of 1959.
John Cage on Lascia o Raddoppia with host Mike Buongiorno
On Lascia o Raddoppia, contestants answered questions on a topic of their choice. If they were successful, they were invited back the following week to answer harder questions for progressively larger winnings. A contestant who made it through all five weeks stood to win five million lire (approximately eight thousand dollars). Cage, an accomplished mycologist, answered questions about mushrooms with the aid of an interpreter. Cage made it through all five weeks and bought a new piano with his winnings upon returning home. More significantly, Cage was also invited to perform one of his compositions each week of show. Water Walk adapted the earlier Water Music to be more appropriate to the televised medium.
Detail of the score for Water Walk [2]
Compared to Water Music, Water Walk is much simpler. Cage’s specifications for the timing of various events are much less specific. More significantly, however, Cage seems to have introduced a greater degree of humor to the second piece, pandering to the lighthearted nature of television and its audiences. I think the added humor was something that would surely have appealed to Zappa.
(The only other performance of Water Walk by Cage was done on The Henry Morgan Show in June of 1959.)
In the other video, we see Zappa performing on The Steve Allen Show three years later. Zappa’s piece, a “concerto for two bicycles, a pre-recorded tape and the musicians in the back” is much more improvised. As Zappa points out in the pre-performance interview, he hadn’t been playing the bike very long.
Jerry Hopkins, the show’s talent coordinator recalls how Zappa landed the gig:
The rules for my job were simple. Get someone who was genuinely eccentric or who did something at least a little strange or out-of-the-ordinary, but never make fun of them—the idea was to have fun with them. And, no fakes, no frauds, no bogus acts looking for exposure and willing to do anything to get it, no put-ons or send-ups, no cons. Because, Steve assured me, they never, ever worked, and they embarrassed everyone.
Only once did I ignore his advice and that was when I got a call from a young man who identified himself as Frank Zappa. He said he wanted to teach Steve how to “blow bicycle.” “Blow bicycle,” I repeated.
“Yeah, you know, like, the bicycle is a musical instrument.”
(You can read the rest of Hopkins’ account here.)
Zappa’s performance even got a write up in a local Cucamonga newspaper:
“Ontario Composer, Steve Allen To Play Wacky Duet”
Frank Zappa, 22, Ontario resident and composer of music, serious and otherwise, will be seen on television tomorrow night playing a bicycle concerto for two with Steve Allen. The show is at 11 p.m., Channel 5. “It’s very funny,†said Zappa. “You play a bicycle by plucking the spokes and blowing through the handle bars.†Other methods of producing “cyclophony†is to stroke the spokes with the bow of a bass fiddle, twirl the pedals and let air out of the tires. The Zappa-Allen concerto will be abetted by a man in the control room fooling around with a tape recorder and by a jazz group which will supply toneless background noise. Zappa studied music and art at Chaffey College. He wrote the score for “The World’s Greatest Sinner,†a low-budget tale about a sacrilegious imposter who repents. “Sinner†had its premiere at Vista-Continental Theater, Hollywood, and opened Wednesday at the Ken Theater, San Diego. Zappa writes musical commercials for TV and radio. They are recorded at Pal Studio, Cucamonga. [3]
These videos both provide neat examples of how the frequently-opposed worlds of art and pop occasionally intersect. A lot of the responsibility for these meetings can be placed on television. I haven’t quite worked this out completely yet, but it seems that for Zappa, the added visual dimension of televised performance goes hand in hand with what he thought about Cage.
In both of these videos, what interests me is the awkward mix of polite respect and anxious laughter on the parts of the hosts and the audiences of each show. I think that these two videos give us an intimate glance a very specific moment in the history of avant-garde music. Audiences (and television programmers) were still receptive to experimental ideas, which themselves hadn’t yet been relegated to exclusive academic circles.
From my perspective, nearly fifty years later, it’s remarkable how adventurous television programming was in the middle of the twentieth century. It’s easy to complain about the lack of this sort of programming nowadays, but I think these examples might give us a better understanding of the current situation.
burlingamefit
iphone x case deals loro piana clutch zak quad lock xr pouzdro fabletics sweater 拧aty nike mesh bucket cappello lacoste mens chaymon trainers
cellofire
los angeles dodgers 50th anniversary hat keyboard kobe as a enfant youth nike st. louis rams 50 rocky mcintosh limited navy blue team color nfl jersey sale nike air max nero ltd reduced nike mercurialx proximo ii tf deep royal blue total crimson chrome…
ponosolution
nike ash jarius wright one color nfl 13 carolina panthers pullover hoodie love balmain torba oppo f3 cover leer waist zak dames flip kryt huawei p20 拧aty jeans top girl
learndslr
air jordan 23 schuhe schwarz limited dan orlovsky youth jersey detroit lions 8 alternate blue nfl mens chicago blackhawks 10 patrick 2015 stanley cup sharp digital camo veterans day practice jersey upcoming air force 1 2019 billig air revolution sky hi…
luxurygrilles
crochet portfel with pockets 3 card phone case mcm shoulder zak phone pouzdro for moto g7 play r暖啪ov媒 a b铆l媒 polo 拧aty over the berretto kansas city chiefs
ncrets
dkny allen shoulder torba oneplus 6 original case small zak organizer inserts samsung galaxy s8 plus k暖啪e pouzdro 拧aty the population catalina fit a flare sb cappello
winzuk
honor 10 lite flip pouzdro plus size flapper style 拧aty nero felt cowgirl cappello dr martens core 939 brown hiking boots gold cross sandalen google pixel 2 xl hoesje clear
docinsider
cheap new era nfl fitted hats unit new air jordan 12 gs white and black womens boston red sox camo hat billig under armour curry iii red shoes for sale billig nike usa soccer hat for cheap nike hyperdunk 2012 red and black
evastat
nike mercurial superfly iv elite adidas superstar green billig atlanta braves hat toddler 2017 low top air force 1 white billig hanes cool dri womens polo nike air more money cny usa billig
peekapets
air jordan 17 hvit blue adidas yeezy boost 750 hong kong ordinance nike free flyknit 5.0 grey gold billig rangers 84 prince fielder grey cool base stitched youth mlb jersey nike hyper dunk low rojo nike air max 90 leather sort sklep
nanopose
limited travis swanson youth jersey detroit lions 64 alternate blue nfl nike air max 97 hyperfuse negro nike hypervenom phelon orange white fresh billig air jordan 11 hvid navy every nfl team uniform all white nike shox for nursing for cheap billig
corsicactus
adizero prime boost midnight light kansas city royals hat band patterns nike free run black mint billig asics gel volley billig nike air max 90 white womens sale new jersey devils jamie langenbrunner 15 green replica jersey sale
laeamerica
pittsburgh pirates hat grey 2017 air jordan 4 retro fiba womens plus size dri fit polo shirts blue black nike lebron 10 elite travis jordan 6 adidas black f50 tracksuit for cheap
niceguts
kit chelsea dream league for cheap jordan retro 8 champagne miami dolphins military hat target chuteira nike elastico pro iii tf san diego padres star wars hat ukulele chords mercurial superfly size 5 2017
crcfoods
cleveland cavaliers 23 lebron james revolution 30 swingman 2014 red jersey nike dunk sky hi off bianca ear hat knitted hat vietnamese nike magista opus mens firm ground soccer cleat night stylish mens winter hat for cheap adidas zx 750 trainers noir ve…
veofilm
mens nfl sweatshirts for cheap aj super fly cheap all grey shoes nike air huarache huarache ultra
sunpacfl
cheap all white nike superflyx 6 kids billig cheap all red air jordan 6 rings billig womens nike air max fury black pink shoes on sale billig jordan 11 nc blue adidas crazy 1 adv cheap blue and grey shoes billig nike zapatos verde naranja
wikistrea
heat 10 tim hardaway black hardwood classics nights finals patch stitched nba jersey torebki spring 2019 free cases with free shipping moschino teddy shoulder zak k暖啪e kryt for samsung note 9 guess jeans 拧aty
buyinaustintx
samsung note 8 ferrari hoesje ducks 24 dillon brooks green basketball pac12 patch stitched ncaa jersey john lewis alina plecak design your own phone case lou camera leer crossbody zak kmart iphone xr pouzdro
karlywegner
limited vincent rey womens jersey cincinnati bengals 57 road white nfl new era oversized shirt supra vaider low junya watanabe moncler nike air pegasus 83 blau and gelb red bottom clothes
sucrehoteles
shockproof a waterproof phone pouzdro retro 拧aty up nike donna aerobill legacy 91 perforated berretto mens wide high top sneakers moccasins schwarz friday blu life one x2 mini hoesje
odgwormald
colorado rockies 9 dj lemahieu purple jersey pink baby gown nike magista onda ic ebay quote north face steep series down jacket youth nike arizona cardinals 94 sam acho limited white nfl jersey sale elite james casey womens jersey philadelphia eagles 8…
daytonhyundai
battery case for ipod touch 6th generation bueno portemonnees shoulder zak pouzdro for lg q7 plus target cheetah 拧aty kansas jayhawks diamonds snapback berretto wave daichi 2
envirofilt
nike patriots 26 logan ryan black mens stitched nfl limited 2016 salute to service jersey salomon s lab ultra 3 ashlyn harris jersey for cheap pink and white nike ctr360 maestri ii elite shoes spain striped wedding gown nike lebron soldier 9 red black
sellosfacil
golden goose sneakers grey paul green sneaker plateau torras samsung galaxy s10 hoesje nfl mike iupati mens elite white jersey 76 arizona cardinals nike road vapor untouchable ted baker crossgrain document torba galaxy s9 plus leather case with belt cl…
chapacms
minnesota vikings baseball cap for eu adidas pure boost gold and black billig chicago bears snapback hat billig nike air force 1 flyknit review korea billig matt ryan jersey mercurial vapor superfly 8 30 billig
twittogram
the rock sleeveless shirt nike elastico al ikhsan johor colombia copa america shirt black chicago white sox hat value maple leafs shirt for cheap ladies louboutin heels
abtheater
b铆l媒 cheetah print 拧aty baltimore orioles new era mlb shade classic neo 39thirty berretto mid calf lace up boots with heel deichmann neue schuhe lg stylo 2 back dekking mens nike kansas city chiefs 35 christian okoye red team color vapor untouchable li…
puenthai
pittsburgh penguins 71 malkin navy blue third womens jersey moncler agnes jacket sierra jacket north face toronto blue jays santa hat templates bred 4s for sale signature red sole shoes
fpinet
nike mercurialx proximo tf review vancouver billig nike free run superfly nike air huarache black white yellow nike air jordan 7 retro for men black grey red billig nike hyperdunk quicker billig adidas ultra boost st vs asics kayano
acoulen
adidas ultra boost 4.0 size billig what store sells jordan 13 nike air presto womens black white yellow shoes billig tottenham kit 2012 nfl redskins clothing for cheap nike air jordan 14 grey shoes for sale
sftony
hugo boss down gilet reebok grey running shoes detroit lions womens legend logo dri fit nfl t shirt red air max 90 rot schwarz white mens 2015 nike nfl st. louis rams t shirts 3 louboutin sole guard
dancerships
pittsburgh penguins 71 malkin navy blue third womens jersey moncler agnes jacket sierra jacket north face toronto blue jays santa hat templates bred 4s for sale signature red sole shoes
coolrvpro
nike hypervenom phelon ebay 2017 billig mens asics gel kinsei 5 grey purple shoes on sale boston red sox trucker hats kentucky wine and white yeezy trainers review shoes uk billig oregon ducks uniforms 2018 for cheap retro 8 kids
capitolv
moncler avrieux fake adidas ultra boost review vintage princess wedding dresses adidas crazy light boost 1 yet nike magista orden kunstrasen 2016 mlb jerseys arizona diamondbacks 40 putz white cool base jerseys
jasonlinphoto
b铆l媒 cheetah print 拧aty baltimore orioles new era mlb shade classic neo 39thirty berretto mid calf lace up boots with heel deichmann neue schuhe lg stylo 2 back dekking mens nike kansas city chiefs 35 christian okoye red team color vapor untouchable li…
sterlingep
nike elastico turf blue blue white under armour fat tire 2013 super bowl new nfl jerseys baltimore ravens 52 ray lewis elite black jerseys with baltimore ravens art patch ben roethlisberger autographed helmet for cheap all white adidas superstar suede…
seacrs
hugo boss down gilet reebok grey running shoes detroit lions womens legend logo dri fit nfl t shirt red air max 90 rot schwarz white mens 2015 nike nfl st. louis rams t shirts 3 louboutin sole guard
grasslandip
pink and white nike cp3 basketball shoes shoes uk nike patriots 15 chris hogan black super bowl li 51 mens stitched nfl limited 2016 salute to service jersey nike air max 2011 svart leather the north face stormy rain triclimate green lingerie dress new…
rodmanusa
womens purple graphic tee nike air yeezy ii 2 red october glowing shoes for sale zilroy air max 2 trainer 94 all white black uk billig nike air jordan 5 all grey black uk monster energy hats black and green machine womens nike kobe 9 low
refreshbr
the rock sleeveless shirt nike elastico al ikhsan johor colombia copa america shirt black chicago white sox hat value maple leafs shirt for cheap ladies louboutin heels
mozsteel
red driving moccasins asic schuhe for overpronation mimco phone hoesje xr oakland raiders limited jersey rains drip drip drip torba nokia 8810 case
lafdental
reebok instapump washington nationals hats cheap online phantom vision academy tf nike baltimore ravens 82 torrey smith 2013 black limited jersey royal blue nike air vapormax womens all black air max tn blue black shoes spain
newtravels
nike air jordan 11 gold and grey nike precision jersey for cheap nike free 5.0 atomic red tropical teal svart nike free 5.0 v2 men blue billig canada black sale nike air pegasus nike air jordan flight origin 4
sellergyllc
the rock sleeveless shirt nike elastico al ikhsan johor colombia copa america shirt black chicago white sox hat value maple leafs shirt for cheap ladies louboutin heels
evlworld
new balance mrl247bk black air max 95 essential texas rangers dog ear hat knitting pattern all grey real yeezy cheap shoes spain notre dame undefeated 2018 shirt for cheap uk green sale jordan 3 iii 40 47 billig
billsodds
crochet newsboy hat pattern pinterest 2017 nike air force 1 pine green atlanta braves mascot hat ending salomon slab mtn mens nike philadelphia eagles 19 chris givens limited black alternate nfl jersey all grey nike hyperdunk 2017 shoes spain
ericrcourtney
laminated torebki otterbox marvel case wit fur clutch zak a7 2017 pouzdro lazada short sleeve floral wrap 拧aty champion beanie donna
encweddings
rick owens moncler vest new balance vazee sigma manolo blahnik red bottom shoes italian league jerseys for cheap frozen dresses for kids
fluffsstuffs
weekender zak with suit compartment oppo a71 pouzdro kate middleton pencil 拧aty florida local cappello matalan studded boots leichter trailrunning schuh