The Idol of his Youth

Andre, , , , ,

Edgard Varese-Complete Works of, vol 1The image to the right depicts the cover of the Complete Works of Edgard Varèse, Volume 1. According to Zappa, this was the first record he ever owned. (And one that changed everything for him!)

The story of how he came to discover the record was well-rehearsed. The following quotation is drawn from an article he wrote for  Stereo Review:

I was about thirteen when I read an article in Look about Sam Goody’s Record Store in New York. My memory is not too clear on the details, but I recall it was praising the store’s exceptional record merchandising ability. One example of brilliant salesmanship described how, through some mysterious trickery, the store actually managed to sell an album called “Ionization” (the real name of the album was “The Complete Works of Edgard Varèse, Volume One”). The article described the record as a weird jumble of drums and other unpleasant sounds. I dashed off to my local record store and asked for it. Nobody ever heard of it. I told the guy in the store what it was like. He turned away, repulsed, and mumbled solemnly, “I probably wouldn’t stock it anyway … nobody here in San Diego would buy it.” I didn’t give up. I was so hot to get that record I couldn’t even believe it. [1]

A number of other sources provide a similar account. Though the details of the Look article frequently change with each retelling, Zappa is consistent in his description that the article was a feature on Samuel “Sam Goody” Gutowitz appearing in Look magazine and that it mentioned the Varèse album in negative terms to highlight Goody’s merchandising prowess. Consider the following quotation from a 1971 interview for Rock Magazine:

The thing that led me to Varèse’s music was an article in Look Magazine saying how great Sam Goody’s record store was. Sam Goody sells records so well that he can even sell a record called Ionizations – they even called the album wrong – it was The Complete Works of Edgar Varèse, Volume I. And they were telling how ugly this record sounded. It was just drums and sirens and nobody would want to own this record and Sam Goody was actually selling it [2]

Or Zappa’s response from an 1981 interview in Down Beat:

How did you first find out about Edgar Varèse?

That’s a very simple story. I read an article in Look magazine in the early ’50s which was a feature saying what a great guy Sam Goody was because he was such an exciting merchandiser and he could sell anything, he could sell any kind of record. And to give an example of what a great merchandiser he was, it said that he was even able to sell an album called “Ionisation” which had a bunch of drums banging, and it described the album in very negative terms. When I read that, I thought it sounded exactly like the kind of album that I wanted to hear because I had been playing drums since I was 12. So I went looking for the album and I finally found it after a couple of months’ search, and I took it home, put it on, and I loved it as soon as I heard it. [3]

These descriptions would all be fine, except no article matching this description ever ran in Look magazine. Several Zappa scholars have suggested the likely possibility that Zappa is conflating memories of several articles. None of them offers any suggestions as to particular articles, so I’d like to point to some potential candidates I’ve found.

Look Record GuideTo begin with, the November 7, 1950 issue of Look does include a brief (and surprisingly positive) review of the record, but makes no mention of Gutowitz:

The good-things-from-obscure-places department has come up with the following finds. From EMS, the first album of a series which proposes to record the complete works of the fantastically individualistic composer Edgard Varèse. Density 21.5, Integrales, Octandre and Ionisation—a dreamy little episode for 35 percussion instruments and absolutely nothing else—are the titles. Varèse is unlike anything else in music, and well worth knowing. The recording is excellent… [4]

Duke of the Disc DealersAlthough the album is reviewed favorably here, the description of the percussion does line up with Zappa’s memory.

Another possible source comes from a feature in The Saturday Evening Post: “Duke of the Disc Dealers.” (The image to the right links to a PDF of the article.)

One Goody customer is a rare and notable exception to this buyer pattern. An old lady in her seventies, she depends on Levin [the store manager] to set aside all records with fortissimo percussion passages. ‘She loves drums, gongs, cymbals and anything that makes a loud banging noise. She has excellent hearing and is not interested in volume, as such. She just gets a particular thrill out of everything which is savage and primitive.’ [5]

This article, however, makes no mention of Varèse

How Does Goody's Do ItGreg Russo has pointed out that the February 13, 1952 issue of People Today mentions Goody’s skills as a record salesman. [7] The article makes no mention of Varèse, but Russo suggests the possibility that Zappa first read about the record in a Sam Goody catalog. Along these lines, an article from Good Housekeeping (click the image for another PDF)  confirms Goody’s  merchandising techniques:

Goody believes in aggressive advertising. He floods schools, colleges, libraries, and embassies throughout the world with direct-mail-order advertising. [6]

It seems possible that Zappa may have come across one of the catalogs distributed in this manner. (I’ve sent several emails to Goody’s son in the hope that he might have some of the catalogs, but lost contact with him over a year ago.)

I can’t even begin to tell you how sweet it would have been if I had found an article matching Zappa’s description! (Even if it wasn’t in Look magazine.) Unfortunately, it seems that for now at least the mystery remains.

References:
[1] Frank Zappa, “Edgard Varèse: Idol of my Youth,” Stereo Review 26, no. 6 (June 1971): 62. (Text here.)
[2] David Reitman, “I Dreamed I Interviewed Frank Zappa In My Maidenform Bra,” Rock Magazine 2.13 (January 25, 1971): 31. (Text here.)
[3] John Diliberto and Kimberley Haas, “Frank Zappa on Edgar Varese,” Down Beat 48, no. 11 (November 1981): 22. (Text here.)
[4] Joseph Roddy, “Look Record Guide,” Look Magazine 14 (November 7, 1950): 111.
[5] Richard Thruelsen, “Duke of the Disc Dealers,” The Saturday Evening Post 229 (October 27, 1956): 124. (PDF here.)
[6] “How Does Goody’s Do It?,” Good Housekeeping 143 (September 1956): 56. (PDF here.)
[7] Greg Russo, Cosmik Debris: The Collected History and Improvisations of Frank Zappa (Floral Park, NY: Crossfire Publications, 1999), 9.
The Idol of his Youth

46,641 thoughts on “The Idol of his Youth”

  2. trendwaching

    adidas springblade kids nike flyknit racer game royal oreo periwinkle coach wallet kansas city chiefs eric winston jersey 74 elite nike red team color jersey cheap nike kobe icon womens pink nike free run 4.0 v2 womens uk wholesale

  4. artikhazirsin

    nike free flyknit 4.0 black womens kit mackage down coat adidas originals yeezy boost 350 v2 golden state warriors jersey design how much is a fendi belt womens nike kobe 12 orange germany

  7. matchyvintage

    nike flyknit roshe charcoal nike zoom winflo 3 femmes rouge blue jays 20 josh donaldson blue alternate stitched mlb jersey nike air odyssey mens green blue adidas zx 850 olive electric green jordans orange blue mens nike lebron 14 shoes

  8. klarinettino

    under armour curry one womens black blue nike kd 9 grey sail jade mountain adidas superstar holographic stripes ebay air max 90 hyperfuse id yeezy nike zoom vomero 10 mens running shoes nike free inneva woven gray

  14. rejuvmedia

    nike lunarepic low flyknit rosa sé…¶lv nike womens patrick chung game white road jersey new england patriots nfl 23 chicago bulls michael jordan hoodie new adult size medium other nike free 5.0 tr fit 3 print nike air max 90 wolf grey solar red white bla…

  15. baby clothing winter rompers newborn snowsuit 0 9months cotton pink white hooded warm baby clothes winter jumpsuit children in price on m.alibaba

    custom kids rudolph family pajamas who doesnt like matching christmas pajamas get your family together and customize these with your last name and thebaby nay baby girls julie two piece kimono set coral stripe 24 monthsbaby drops 21 11 knitted jacket i…

  20. wantaoren

    prada sunglasses price in india air jordan retro 1 blue gamma blue mk tote bag brown womens nike flyknit roshe run white orange limited jordan hicks youth jersey philadelphia eagles 58 road white pink purple womens nike kd 9 shoes

  22. nollerlincoln

    mackage jacket plus size up north face scythe fleece jacket uniqlo prada milano purse adidas pure boost zg raw review allen jake 34 jersey youth air jordan 30.5 gold brown

  24. n43uaulr

    nike hypershift midnight marinen roshe adidas porsche design driving sko herren nike free 5.0 orange schwarz nike hypervenom clearwater blu lagoon bleu and orange nike sb dunks nike air max 90 dam盲nner gold gelb

  33. ntygadget

    nfl mens nike seattle seahawks navy sideline legend prism performance long sleeve t shirt kobe 9 low yeezy white gold womens nike hyperdunk 2017 adidas originals zx 700 contemp w svart leopard new balance 574 mens gold blue yellow womens nike mercurial…

  34. adidas junior real madrid home football jersey 2017

    england national football teamby smartdesigns2 spreadshirtmizuno volleyball single knee supporter with pad black large 59ss322england national football teamby smartdesigns2 spreadshirtjersey guadalajara 110 a帽os chivas campeonisimo env铆o gratisprecio 6…

  35. pickwickcrc

    billig air jordan retro 6 dam盲nner grau 35 authentic grant hill detroit pistons jersey mens adidas nba purple throwback 1995 all nike 5.0 black womens cheap nike mercurial vapor wei脽 and gr眉n light nike free 3.0 v5 for salg arkansas vintage ray ban way…

  36. metinmilli

    mackage kenya jacket for sale york nike kwazi youth johnson james 16 jersey city tyreek hill jersey sales flyknit lunar 3 green queen prada tote men necklace

  37. meersaitig

    air max 1 lå¿™der hvid university ré…¶d asics gel quantum 360 grigio marrone nike air max 2017 vert pierre kitchen zx flux floral negro and blanco nike huarache sort sort hvid nike air force 1 82 edition noir

  39. skynetankara

    2014 15 real madrid 2 varane away pink soccer long sleeve shirt kit nobis heritage jacket nike kobe 10 elite herre orange vintage fendi scarf new york yankees hat all black friday nike air force 1 tan mens

  41. wangentreppe

    tiffany blau free run 3 5.0 dam盲nner aqua edition nike shox deliver blanco gris huaraches nike free run 4.0 v3 dahombres schwarz naranja air jordan retro 17 svart vin adidas springblade ignite rosso viola tf soccer boots nike mercurialx proximo street…

  42. cap sleeves leotard annalisa

    babys boy one piece car romperimage of moncler gamme bleu zipped hoodie men cotton l greywomens croft barrow ribbed turtleneck sweaterfooted pajamas unisex winter wonderland infant hoodie fleece

  45. iammember

    adidas soccers schuhe gelb himmelblau nike lebron basketbtutti scarpe 2013 femminile air jordan retro 6 viola oro mizuno soccers scarpe air jordan retro 1 mujeres gris rosado nike air max plus tn gris living room

  50. tzoning

    nike air max 90 turquoise nike store adidas superstar 2 light blau air jordan aero mania red black ray ban aviator blue gradient gold frame reebok gl 6000 white nike foamposite 1

Comments are closed.