The Idol of his Youth

Andre, , , , ,

Edgard Varese-Complete Works of, vol 1The image to the right depicts the cover of the Complete Works of Edgard Varèse, Volume 1. According to Zappa, this was the first record he ever owned. (And one that changed everything for him!)

The story of how he came to discover the record was well-rehearsed. The following quotation is drawn from an article he wrote for  Stereo Review:

I was about thirteen when I read an article in Look about Sam Goody’s Record Store in New York. My memory is not too clear on the details, but I recall it was praising the store’s exceptional record merchandising ability. One example of brilliant salesmanship described how, through some mysterious trickery, the store actually managed to sell an album called “Ionization” (the real name of the album was “The Complete Works of Edgard Varèse, Volume One”). The article described the record as a weird jumble of drums and other unpleasant sounds. I dashed off to my local record store and asked for it. Nobody ever heard of it. I told the guy in the store what it was like. He turned away, repulsed, and mumbled solemnly, “I probably wouldn’t stock it anyway … nobody here in San Diego would buy it.” I didn’t give up. I was so hot to get that record I couldn’t even believe it. [1]

A number of other sources provide a similar account. Though the details of the Look article frequently change with each retelling, Zappa is consistent in his description that the article was a feature on Samuel “Sam Goody” Gutowitz appearing in Look magazine and that it mentioned the Varèse album in negative terms to highlight Goody’s merchandising prowess. Consider the following quotation from a 1971 interview for Rock Magazine:

The thing that led me to Varèse’s music was an article in Look Magazine saying how great Sam Goody’s record store was. Sam Goody sells records so well that he can even sell a record called Ionizations – they even called the album wrong – it was The Complete Works of Edgar Varèse, Volume I. And they were telling how ugly this record sounded. It was just drums and sirens and nobody would want to own this record and Sam Goody was actually selling it [2]

Or Zappa’s response from an 1981 interview in Down Beat:

How did you first find out about Edgar Varèse?

That’s a very simple story. I read an article in Look magazine in the early ’50s which was a feature saying what a great guy Sam Goody was because he was such an exciting merchandiser and he could sell anything, he could sell any kind of record. And to give an example of what a great merchandiser he was, it said that he was even able to sell an album called “Ionisation” which had a bunch of drums banging, and it described the album in very negative terms. When I read that, I thought it sounded exactly like the kind of album that I wanted to hear because I had been playing drums since I was 12. So I went looking for the album and I finally found it after a couple of months’ search, and I took it home, put it on, and I loved it as soon as I heard it. [3]

These descriptions would all be fine, except no article matching this description ever ran in Look magazine. Several Zappa scholars have suggested the likely possibility that Zappa is conflating memories of several articles. None of them offers any suggestions as to particular articles, so I’d like to point to some potential candidates I’ve found.

Look Record GuideTo begin with, the November 7, 1950 issue of Look does include a brief (and surprisingly positive) review of the record, but makes no mention of Gutowitz:

The good-things-from-obscure-places department has come up with the following finds. From EMS, the first album of a series which proposes to record the complete works of the fantastically individualistic composer Edgard Varèse. Density 21.5, Integrales, Octandre and Ionisation—a dreamy little episode for 35 percussion instruments and absolutely nothing else—are the titles. Varèse is unlike anything else in music, and well worth knowing. The recording is excellent… [4]

Duke of the Disc DealersAlthough the album is reviewed favorably here, the description of the percussion does line up with Zappa’s memory.

Another possible source comes from a feature in The Saturday Evening Post: “Duke of the Disc Dealers.” (The image to the right links to a PDF of the article.)

One Goody customer is a rare and notable exception to this buyer pattern. An old lady in her seventies, she depends on Levin [the store manager] to set aside all records with fortissimo percussion passages. ‘She loves drums, gongs, cymbals and anything that makes a loud banging noise. She has excellent hearing and is not interested in volume, as such. She just gets a particular thrill out of everything which is savage and primitive.’ [5]

This article, however, makes no mention of Varèse

How Does Goody's Do ItGreg Russo has pointed out that the February 13, 1952 issue of People Today mentions Goody’s skills as a record salesman. [7] The article makes no mention of Varèse, but Russo suggests the possibility that Zappa first read about the record in a Sam Goody catalog. Along these lines, an article from Good Housekeeping (click the image for another PDF)  confirms Goody’s  merchandising techniques:

Goody believes in aggressive advertising. He floods schools, colleges, libraries, and embassies throughout the world with direct-mail-order advertising. [6]

It seems possible that Zappa may have come across one of the catalogs distributed in this manner. (I’ve sent several emails to Goody’s son in the hope that he might have some of the catalogs, but lost contact with him over a year ago.)

I can’t even begin to tell you how sweet it would have been if I had found an article matching Zappa’s description! (Even if it wasn’t in Look magazine.) Unfortunately, it seems that for now at least the mystery remains.

References:
[1] Frank Zappa, “Edgard Varèse: Idol of my Youth,” Stereo Review 26, no. 6 (June 1971): 62. (Text here.)
[2] David Reitman, “I Dreamed I Interviewed Frank Zappa In My Maidenform Bra,” Rock Magazine 2.13 (January 25, 1971): 31. (Text here.)
[3] John Diliberto and Kimberley Haas, “Frank Zappa on Edgar Varese,” Down Beat 48, no. 11 (November 1981): 22. (Text here.)
[4] Joseph Roddy, “Look Record Guide,” Look Magazine 14 (November 7, 1950): 111.
[5] Richard Thruelsen, “Duke of the Disc Dealers,” The Saturday Evening Post 229 (October 27, 1956): 124. (PDF here.)
[6] “How Does Goody’s Do It?,” Good Housekeeping 143 (September 1956): 56. (PDF here.)
[7] Greg Russo, Cosmik Debris: The Collected History and Improvisations of Frank Zappa (Floral Park, NY: Crossfire Publications, 1999), 9.
The Idol of his Youth

46,641 thoughts on “The Idol of his Youth”

  1. primosc

    puma donna nrgy neko scarpe dallas mavs throwback maglia seattle seahawks 47 nfl khaki 47 clean up 膷epice suns city edition maillot kanye energy boost off hvit air max 90 svart

  2. netlinebr

    nike huarache guld kids yankees cap for eu dhgate ajax jersey for cheap royals light blue jersey nike toki low schwarz canucks 2019 jersey for cheap

  3. fullonrad

    tech craft nike magista obra negro moon azul nike hypervenom free run blanco wholesale oakland snapback youth kentucky football jersey for cheap washington redskins baby gear for cheap st louis blues camo hat

  4. mdroster

    roshe one white jordan horizon wolf grey hvid wholesale raptors hat ovo jordan 2 violet blanc ray ban black aviator sunglasses price new balance 577 sns rosso

  5. cuenco

    baltimore ravens nfl hat for cheap ghete nike air force one black white adidas zx flux noir and or very cleveland browns hat for eu kvinders nike free 5.0 metalleic silver air max 2016 sko sort

  6. eduworlds

    adidas neo negro jumper nike air max 2017 unisexe noir hernandez david 47 jersey adidas superstar junior rouge wholesale yankees hat logo seattle seahawks winter hat for uk

  7. opensats

    puma eskiva hi nike free og superior blue kyrie 4 lucky charms shirt ray ban jackie ohh iii nike air max 2014 schwarz grau nike free rn nero nero

  8. fromeaparty

    la yankees cap for sale new balance 1500 grey red kobe del sol 4 chicago bears slouch hat for sale marner signed jersey chicago bears griswold hat for eu

  9. sakshotel

    jordan barn retro 13 jordan 11 hvit and blue low nike free run 3.0 v4 maschio nero racer blue 12s newborn raiders apparel for cheap nike schuhe air max rot

  10. esitelecom

    nike air force 1 high foamposite white schwarz herren new balance 574 black lime carhartt 47 yankees for uk kvinners nike shox oz hvit nike x supreme scarpe jordan 7 black university red

  11. freimap

    anaheim ducks new era hat for sale liverpool limited edition black for cheap nike roshe run gold floral pink and sort jordan retro 4 adidas zx 500 og red wholesale toronto raptors baseball hat

  12. boredgourd

    adidas zx700 grigio nike air jordan 5 black red ray ban metal aviator sunglasses jordan 5 hvit blue nike air presto cream ray ban rb3025 aviator large metal polarized

  13. entkalker

    dallas cowboys light jacket for cheap cap monster energy for eu nike cortez cuir marine jordan flight 9 white blue air jordan 1 blau and grau chicago cubs hats lids

  14. siames

    cool chicago bears hats for eu light blue uptempo milwaukee brewers cap for sale adidas eqt laufen support 93 og royal schwarz where can i buy dallas cowboys stuff near me adidas neo trainers gris

  15. buzzages

    nike flyknit racer marathon blau nike air jordan retro 11 tout noir oakley half jacket 2.0 mens sunglasses psg jumpman t shirt for cheap nike hypervenom orange and black buy online nike air lebron slide 3 elite bianca

  17. urbanhit

    eagles beanie new era adidas zx700 schwarz viet nam nike free trainer 5.0 svart and lilla aleali jordan 6 trae young t shirt jersey adidas high tops hvid sort

  18. visvita

    dallas cowboys light jacket for cheap cap monster energy for eu nike cortez cuir marine jordan flight 9 white blue air jordan 1 blau and grau chicago cubs hats lids

  20. glennraps

    jordan spizike bianca poison rosso mens air jordan 1 mid basketball shoes white converse original yellow ferrari jordans new adidas yeezy boost 750 todas azul nike magista opus blanco verde sg

  21. haresmoor

    ray ban wayfarer tortoise shell green lenses miami heat vice fitted hat for uk lebron 16 online shoes rockies carhartt hat for uk detroit red wings beanie for uk kobe 8 bianca and oro

  22. floatermd

    schwarz nike react presto air max 97 vapormax zielony luigi baseball gorra baltimore orioles new era mlb 銉栥儵銈︺兂 on metallic 59fifty 銈儯銉冦儣 trend sandalen 2018 air max 97 gr眉n rot

  23. howtouseobs

    pantaloni tuta jordan uomo coke blanc air force 1 lebron 15 equality zwart nike clc99 trucker berretto iphone 6 h眉lle defender feh茅r lace bodycon ruha uk

  24. painmm

    felpa nike nsw puma ferrari chaussure blanc et noir asics gel phoenix mujer tampa bay rays new era mlb team classic 39thirty berretto air force 1 midnight haditenger茅szet feh茅r piros silk ruha

  25. llcmenahga

    nike magista onda prix 2017 billig jordan 8 phoenix billig air jordan future navy blue cheap all red women air jordan 5 billig mens angels jersey for cheap cheap mens air max size 9

  26. ascozzisolar

    ted baker 銉嶃偆銉撱兗 銉栥兗銉?/a> new balance 574 verde giallo alle hvit jordan 12 air max 97 damskie czerwony texas rangers new era mlb clubhouse kids 59fifty sapka jelly roll sac 脿 main

  27. nowruzhaly

    uomo oro slides fizik schoenen r5b new balance 574 blue brown nike air jordan 11 black cowboy cappello open crown converse tout star chaussure haute top

  28. akpeonypatch

    finn balor wwe custom trucker gorra 銉儍銉?sox locker room 甯藉瓙 comfortable schuhe for being on your feet alle day schwarz gr眉n vapormax plus merrell around town sunvue slide yankees bucket klobouky

  29. teddyandbo

    seattle mariners new era mlb flag fill 9fifty snapback 膷epice tee shirt homme puma cortica motto negro most popular shoulder ta拧ky 2018 vagabond olivia 銉栥儵銉冦偗 jordan 4 cool grigio retail prezzo

  30. ourjokebooks

    predator boots nero e rosso air jordan 1 lav blue og svart adidas nmd r1 primeknit bia艂y japan nike cold weather sapka dmf betsey sacs unicorn vestito tutu

  31. mandrait

    nike air huarache nero jd adidas protator absolado cleats white and black vans womens air jordan 4 blanco oro air jordan 1 blau gelb cleveland indians knit hat

  32. tribesanz

    nike pegasus 89 vert nike air max react 270 mujer dallas cowboys new era nfl team basic 59fifty berretto adidas predator 18.3 feh茅r 茅s piros feh茅r lace bohemian maxi ruha syracuse baseball casquette

  33. lapanse

    nike air pegasus canada billig air jordan 13 low og billig wholesale nike superflyx 6 kids all gold billig jordan flex fit hat australia weather jordan national football team jersey tom brady military jersey

  34. adatogeljitu

    best asics running cip艖 for n艖i fitted denim shirt ruha femme bucket sun chapeau zizo bolt sag iphone xr fila bia艂e damskie long hvit shirt kjole

  35. thisisdrip

    nike air presto bianco sporco bianca airmax 90 nike sko for kvinner puma 90s buty nordstrom bucket sapka ralph lauren bucket sac mini rosso glitter cocktail vestito

  36. braliexpress

    nike air vapormax run utility black reflect silver air force 1 lv8 red and blue atlanta braves blu cappello nike air vapormax se femme okc fitted hats atlanta falcons baseball casquette

  37. barryturley

    alto neck anarkali vestito chicago cubs new era mlb color prism pack 59fifty 膷epice ensemble jaune adidas samuel smith tap zapatillas nike club duffel ta拧ka authentic balenciaga 闈?/a>

  38. discnerd

    vintage cavs hat for sale nike magista obra schwarz friday air jordan 10 gold schwarz vans cheetah shoes kvinders sko hvid heels nike lebron 9 noir and rouge

  39. dtsupport

    adidas yeezy boost 350 description quizlet billig nike magista obra on feet video adidas pure boost blue black shoes adidas ace 15.1 sg size 10.5 newcastle away kit 2018 jordan 1 ying yang white

  40. xpertmoving

    vivobarefoot training zapatillas balenciaga explorer belt ta拧ka replica small 銇嬨亱銇?bridesmaid 闈?/a> nike air force 1 donna light blu asics gel sonoma svart m臋skie retro 5

  42. sockcop

    purple and black retro 7 ray ban aviator black price nike air huarache noir jd sports kansas city chiefs skull cap for sale nike air tilce mid svart kvinners nike free run 5.0 rosso arancia

  43. hallsongarden

    vander esch 銈搞儯銉笺偢銉?/a> air jordan 1 h酶y pine gr酶nn 5xl nba 銈搞儯銉笺偢銉?/a> blanc air force 1 chaussure youth ralph lauren 膷epi膷ku klobouky 膷ern谩 maglia of cleveland cavaliers

  44. cabbitrecords

    handtasche day 2018 leggings adidas 2019 nike air foamposite one optic jaune vapormax collab blancuzco snapback giallo nike presto extreme fekete 茅s feh茅r

  45. lionhardt

    adidas crazy light boost orange and black knight billig nike elastico lazada phone number jordan pro classic women cheap black white and red shoes blue black nike air max 90 top layer leather for uk billig all blue jordan 7 nashville predators clothing

  46. pixcorpdesign

    fossil caroline slim bifold brieftasche felpa adidas rick e morty new balance homme 500 chaussure noir retro 4 negro y oro fancy vestito cappelli ebay asics gel 3 fekete

  47. frankconet

    sacoche kenzo homme burberry vestito shirt donna nike 膷epice metal veste nike bleu rouge oro gladiator zapatillas floral zip around pen臎啪enka

  48. etismar

    nike tiempo genio ic 10 muller soccer jersey for cheap nike air max lunar 1 women sky blue billig nike air max 96 deion sanders korea air jordan 7 black green for cheap nike hypervenom phelon jabong quote

  49. wegotg

    zielony velvet court buty ecco cool gtx golf obuv wake forest demon deacons nike ncaa anthracite classic swoosh cap felpa jordan saldi nemeziz messi bleu groen huaraches heren

  50. asvencon

    justin holiday jersey nobis vest vest guard nike free 3.0 focfly so marrè´¸n rosado air max 2014 dark green ugg 1873 boot 4 boot nike air max negro with blanco dots

Comments are closed.