The Idol of his Youth

Andre, , , , ,

Edgard Varese-Complete Works of, vol 1The image to the right depicts the cover of the Complete Works of Edgard Varèse, Volume 1. According to Zappa, this was the first record he ever owned. (And one that changed everything for him!)

The story of how he came to discover the record was well-rehearsed. The following quotation is drawn from an article he wrote for  Stereo Review:

I was about thirteen when I read an article in Look about Sam Goody’s Record Store in New York. My memory is not too clear on the details, but I recall it was praising the store’s exceptional record merchandising ability. One example of brilliant salesmanship described how, through some mysterious trickery, the store actually managed to sell an album called “Ionization” (the real name of the album was “The Complete Works of Edgard Varèse, Volume One”). The article described the record as a weird jumble of drums and other unpleasant sounds. I dashed off to my local record store and asked for it. Nobody ever heard of it. I told the guy in the store what it was like. He turned away, repulsed, and mumbled solemnly, “I probably wouldn’t stock it anyway … nobody here in San Diego would buy it.” I didn’t give up. I was so hot to get that record I couldn’t even believe it. [1]

A number of other sources provide a similar account. Though the details of the Look article frequently change with each retelling, Zappa is consistent in his description that the article was a feature on Samuel “Sam Goody” Gutowitz appearing in Look magazine and that it mentioned the Varèse album in negative terms to highlight Goody’s merchandising prowess. Consider the following quotation from a 1971 interview for Rock Magazine:

The thing that led me to Varèse’s music was an article in Look Magazine saying how great Sam Goody’s record store was. Sam Goody sells records so well that he can even sell a record called Ionizations – they even called the album wrong – it was The Complete Works of Edgar Varèse, Volume I. And they were telling how ugly this record sounded. It was just drums and sirens and nobody would want to own this record and Sam Goody was actually selling it [2]

Or Zappa’s response from an 1981 interview in Down Beat:

How did you first find out about Edgar Varèse?

That’s a very simple story. I read an article in Look magazine in the early ’50s which was a feature saying what a great guy Sam Goody was because he was such an exciting merchandiser and he could sell anything, he could sell any kind of record. And to give an example of what a great merchandiser he was, it said that he was even able to sell an album called “Ionisation” which had a bunch of drums banging, and it described the album in very negative terms. When I read that, I thought it sounded exactly like the kind of album that I wanted to hear because I had been playing drums since I was 12. So I went looking for the album and I finally found it after a couple of months’ search, and I took it home, put it on, and I loved it as soon as I heard it. [3]

These descriptions would all be fine, except no article matching this description ever ran in Look magazine. Several Zappa scholars have suggested the likely possibility that Zappa is conflating memories of several articles. None of them offers any suggestions as to particular articles, so I’d like to point to some potential candidates I’ve found.

Look Record GuideTo begin with, the November 7, 1950 issue of Look does include a brief (and surprisingly positive) review of the record, but makes no mention of Gutowitz:

The good-things-from-obscure-places department has come up with the following finds. From EMS, the first album of a series which proposes to record the complete works of the fantastically individualistic composer Edgard Varèse. Density 21.5, Integrales, Octandre and Ionisation—a dreamy little episode for 35 percussion instruments and absolutely nothing else—are the titles. Varèse is unlike anything else in music, and well worth knowing. The recording is excellent… [4]

Duke of the Disc DealersAlthough the album is reviewed favorably here, the description of the percussion does line up with Zappa’s memory.

Another possible source comes from a feature in The Saturday Evening Post: “Duke of the Disc Dealers.” (The image to the right links to a PDF of the article.)

One Goody customer is a rare and notable exception to this buyer pattern. An old lady in her seventies, she depends on Levin [the store manager] to set aside all records with fortissimo percussion passages. ‘She loves drums, gongs, cymbals and anything that makes a loud banging noise. She has excellent hearing and is not interested in volume, as such. She just gets a particular thrill out of everything which is savage and primitive.’ [5]

This article, however, makes no mention of Varèse

How Does Goody's Do ItGreg Russo has pointed out that the February 13, 1952 issue of People Today mentions Goody’s skills as a record salesman. [7] The article makes no mention of Varèse, but Russo suggests the possibility that Zappa first read about the record in a Sam Goody catalog. Along these lines, an article from Good Housekeeping (click the image for another PDF)  confirms Goody’s  merchandising techniques:

Goody believes in aggressive advertising. He floods schools, colleges, libraries, and embassies throughout the world with direct-mail-order advertising. [6]

It seems possible that Zappa may have come across one of the catalogs distributed in this manner. (I’ve sent several emails to Goody’s son in the hope that he might have some of the catalogs, but lost contact with him over a year ago.)

I can’t even begin to tell you how sweet it would have been if I had found an article matching Zappa’s description! (Even if it wasn’t in Look magazine.) Unfortunately, it seems that for now at least the mystery remains.

References:
[1] Frank Zappa, “Edgard Varèse: Idol of my Youth,” Stereo Review 26, no. 6 (June 1971): 62. (Text here.)
[2] David Reitman, “I Dreamed I Interviewed Frank Zappa In My Maidenform Bra,” Rock Magazine 2.13 (January 25, 1971): 31. (Text here.)
[3] John Diliberto and Kimberley Haas, “Frank Zappa on Edgar Varese,” Down Beat 48, no. 11 (November 1981): 22. (Text here.)
[4] Joseph Roddy, “Look Record Guide,” Look Magazine 14 (November 7, 1950): 111.
[5] Richard Thruelsen, “Duke of the Disc Dealers,” The Saturday Evening Post 229 (October 27, 1956): 124. (PDF here.)
[6] “How Does Goody’s Do It?,” Good Housekeeping 143 (September 1956): 56. (PDF here.)
[7] Greg Russo, Cosmik Debris: The Collected History and Improvisations of Frank Zappa (Floral Park, NY: Crossfire Publications, 1999), 9.
The Idol of his Youth

46,641 thoughts on “The Idol of his Youth”

  1. ribbitsalon

    unicorn beetle hoesje for note 9 limited nike black youth drew brees jersey nfl 9 new orleans saints salute to service therma long sleeve max side torebki lifeproof 4s case handtas shaped favor boxes retro gameboy pouzdro

  2. evlworld

    san francisco giants hat amazon locker room royal blue air max invigor mens shoes uk nike rams for cheap nike air yeezy 2 black buy nike magista opus fg soccer cleat yahoo nike free flyknit 3.0 black and red for canada

  3. tsilifeline

    pittsburgh pirates adjustable hat loom nike air force 1 high flax kopen ralph lauren swim shorts navy air jordan 06 adidas yeezy sort guld nike air max 90 yeezy blanc

  4. gaohuiguoshu

    mens loafers slip ons 2 girls fashion scarves 7 tools home improvement bulb planters 2 mens suit jackets 4 tools home improvement water heater parts bady bassinet bedding sets 2

  5. hotelsamet

    asics zaraca elite lance moore mens jersey pittsburgh steelers 16 lights out black nfl north face summit series 800 down jacket jordan 10 white red jordan 4 retro og gs nike free 5.0 damen schwarz and white verkauf

  6. mavruka

    all pink nike free 3.0 v3 womens shoes uk shoes new balance beacon v2 nike vapormax flyknit grey mens billig converse made in nike shox classic verde texas rangers baylor hat queen

  7. alconstruir

    home kitchen bakeware french bread baguette pans home kitchen footboards 3 girls active top bottom sets 8 industrial scientific roofing collated nails womens work dresses 4 home kitchen mirror sets

  8. smmwelch

    carolina herrera shopping zak samsung j7 2015 pouzdro 膷erven茅 floral 拧aty cowgirl cappello costume green alexander mcqueen sneakers laufschuhe f眉r vorfu脽l盲ufer 2017

  9. eurorumo

    jordan 1 smoke texas ranger western hat club nike go flyease womens noir boston red sox rainbow hat hatchling null spell mystic sleeveless midi dress adidas hamburg navy white gum

  10. therawplate

    reebok instapump michael jordan hats uk maps wholesale nike free 4.0 v3 black and green billig west ham away kit 2020 nike air max 2015 womens all red grey uk adidas zx 750 blue and yellow

  11. samsunlobe

    cheap air max shoes jordan 1 low desert ore blanc authentic mike singletary mens throwback jersey chicago bears 50 bear patch big number home navy blue mitchell and ness nfl liga mx kits adidas nmd herren wei脽 salah jersey number for cheap

  12. asecondmind

    st louis blues golf hat for eu all pink predators pittsburgh pirates realtree hat game online saree dress nike air jordan 6 nero infrarosso kanye west schuhe air yeezy 2

  13. ekytalk

    youth nike san diego chargers 38 marcus gilchrist elite navy blue team color nfl jersey sale adidas springblade ignite bianca nike air max 1 schwarz verkauf 1980 pittsburgh pirates hat vietnam war air jordan 3 legend bleu

  14. braamweg

    carhartt long sleeve tee shirt nhl jerseys chicago blackhawks 6 parkhurst original black throwback ccm jersey with 2013 stanley cup patch all grey air jordan 6 shoes spain billig nike air foamposite rose nike air max schwarz zebra nike kyrie 4 all blac…

  15. coleygov

    nike air huarache shoes military blue obsidian korea adidas yeezy boost 350 next release rate kansas city royals 13 salvador perez 2013 all star blue womens jersey air jordan future low black white mlb jerseys baltimore orioles 25 derrek lee black cool…

  16. umccadillac

    youth nike atlanta falcons 44 vic beasley game white nfl jersey plus size dri fit shirts outdoor research advocate cap black and gold youth football cleats sons of anarchy wallet with chain soft briefcase bag

  17. comunidadmh

    zach lavine city jersey nike air huarache black grey camo maggie linen wrap dress 50th birthday outfit st louis blues flexfit hat for uk womens nike air max sneakers noir

  18. vidiem

    automotive tie downs tarps 4 industrial scientific side-cutting pliers toys games trampolines womens sunglasses 3 automotive tie downs rope baby boys receiving blankets

  20. formulaoff

    african beach dress janoski cork blanc nike cowboys 50 sean lee black womens stitched nfl limited gold salute to service jersey adidas nmd r1 primeknit rojo camo black off shoulder rib knitted midaxi dress nike huarache noir bleu

  21. vedakompass

    bohemian hippie torebki clear samsung s7 edge case dkny tassen house of fraser lg aristo 2 pouzdro metropcs new years wedding guest 拧aty authentic western cappelli

  22. ftscrossfit

    black and red fake cream white yeezy mock turtleneck long sleeve t shirts womens nike air more uptempo 96 light bone used evening gowns salomon men’s sense ride 3 minnesota twins santa hat free

  23. leekoil

    glitter homecoming dresses new york yankees hat gold nugget air max 95 og metallic gold new balance 559 noir buy black white asics gel hyper 33 shoes 2012 new nfl jerseys pittsburgh steelers 43 troy polamalu black yellow drift fashion ii elite jerseys

  24. czaterianie

    air force 1 low schwarz album adidas ultra boost silver buy online milwaukee brewers fathers day hat for cheap amazon michael kors tote bags air jordan 21 rosso nike air parace 1 high foamposite blanco negro hombres

  25. gotapool

    air jordan 30 80 nike air force 1 high flax kopen chicago white sox hat chance the rapper age nike air max 2015 white and purple nike free flyknit grey womens noir super bowl 51 tom brady jersey

  26. menscore

    versace most iconic dress poppies and peonies purses womens nike air max 97 gold nike mens kyle wilber limited camo jersey oakland raiders nfl 58 2018 salute to service jordan retro 11 burgundy denver broncos matt paradis orange nike 61 nfl long sleeve…

  27. bakirtesisat

    christian shoes louboutin toronto maple leafs phil kessel 81 white replica jersey sale philadelphia eagles hard hats for uk adidas black f50 tracksuit for cheap nike flyknit air max blue hyper jade sort jordan sneakers retro 6

  28. portlandmilf

    tools home improvement appliance cords womens cardigans sweaters womens checkbook covers 2 home kitchen children s clothes hangers boys hiking boots 3 mens backpacking boots 2

  29. cintimedia

    lillard berretto trendy shoes 2019 mammut boulderschuhe iphone 8 plus hoesje for zwart phone mens nike cleveland browns 95 myles garrett limited brown rush vapor untouchable nfl jersey torebki with rfid protection

  30. teamcansler

    oneplus 7 battery pouzdro 拧ed谩 needle a thread 拧aty bucket cappelli for uomo zumiez firefighter work boots crib schuhe girl samsung s7 hoesje lifeproof

  31. edwinraben

    nike huarache gray and blau size 4 infant jordans gold crystal dress salomon x pro 100 bayern munchen 7 ribery goalkeeper long sleeves mens adults 2016 2017 club soccer jerseys moncler shiny vest

  32. earcandyllc

    roshe run 1 blanc asics gel rocket nero argento nfl gear bears kansas city royals 13 salvador perez 2013 all star blue womens jersey nike mercurial vapor xiii elite football boots blanc youth nike steelers 32 franco harris black team color stitched nfl…

  33. susannworld

    jimmy choo flash sunglasses cartera negra chanel air force one taille 40 green bay packers alternate uniforms pandora leather lariat necklace coque batterie huawei p30

  34. makrisberns

    yellow gauze dress nike flyknit air max negro blanco purple venom dress office look zara special prices dresses game david andrews mens jersey new england patriots 60 home navy blue nfl nike air force 1 flyknit hvid

  35. designerjps

    home kitchen kids furniture bedroom sets 5 industrial scientific mop handles mens sleep sets 4 home kitchen bike racks stands bady rail covers 2 home kitchen coffee maker parts accessories tampers

  36. lawbyrds

    toys games model rockets industrial scientific adhesive dispensers accessories bady wearable blankets 4 baby boys snow wear 3 home kitchen hanging wall files toys games helmets 3

  37. bcapalt

    custom iowa hawkeye football jersey minnesota vikings womens heart soul nfl t shirt purple asics quantum 360 5 men nike washington redskins 37 reed doughty game white nfl jersey sale supreme tnf vest adidas superstar nero bianca oro

  40. festiciel

    industrial scientific snagging wheels luggage messenger bags 1 automotive idler arms tools home improvement light switches 2 home kitchen pizza cutters 1 mens fire safety

  41. voicegenx

    coque iphone 8 gifi coque ordinateur portable asus 15.6 pouces foam slippers for men dicke wollm眉tze louis vuitton mini neverfull tom ford conrad sunglasses

  42. hinduchanting

    womens lingerie everyday bras girls rain boots 4 industrial scientific commercial toilet seats 6 mens tie clips 2 industrial scientific cat 7 cables 7 womens visors 5

  43. thecreagent

    christian shoes louboutin mens 2015 nike nfl new york jetss t shirts 62 philadelphia eagles hard hats for uk nike wmns air pegasus 83 team rouge nike flyknit air max blue hyper jade sort jordan sneakers retro 6

  47. voyagetourisme

    what do the numbers mean on contact lenses bolsa chanel palacio de hierro paire de chaussure versace benfica trikot oakley sliver stealth prizm polarized housse de protection ipad 8

  48. alarmstl

    pandora me whale charm baby blue moncler shirt moncler madame jacket little girl dresses walmart nike stefan janoski svart crystal mint yes charms pandora

  50. casahirta

    nike sb stefan janoski svart hvit og,nike sb stefan janoski fragmennt wolf gr氓,nike free trainer 5.0 svart junior,nike wmns free tr fit 3 prt hvit pearlized rosa adidas gazelle mens burgundy and blue noir guest baby shower outfits adidas f50 nero infra…

Comments are closed.