The Idol of his Youth

Andre, , , , ,

Edgard Varese-Complete Works of, vol 1The image to the right depicts the cover of the Complete Works of Edgard Varèse, Volume 1. According to Zappa, this was the first record he ever owned. (And one that changed everything for him!)

The story of how he came to discover the record was well-rehearsed. The following quotation is drawn from an article he wrote for  Stereo Review:

I was about thirteen when I read an article in Look about Sam Goody’s Record Store in New York. My memory is not too clear on the details, but I recall it was praising the store’s exceptional record merchandising ability. One example of brilliant salesmanship described how, through some mysterious trickery, the store actually managed to sell an album called “Ionization” (the real name of the album was “The Complete Works of Edgard Varèse, Volume One”). The article described the record as a weird jumble of drums and other unpleasant sounds. I dashed off to my local record store and asked for it. Nobody ever heard of it. I told the guy in the store what it was like. He turned away, repulsed, and mumbled solemnly, “I probably wouldn’t stock it anyway … nobody here in San Diego would buy it.” I didn’t give up. I was so hot to get that record I couldn’t even believe it. [1]

A number of other sources provide a similar account. Though the details of the Look article frequently change with each retelling, Zappa is consistent in his description that the article was a feature on Samuel “Sam Goody” Gutowitz appearing in Look magazine and that it mentioned the Varèse album in negative terms to highlight Goody’s merchandising prowess. Consider the following quotation from a 1971 interview for Rock Magazine:

The thing that led me to Varèse’s music was an article in Look Magazine saying how great Sam Goody’s record store was. Sam Goody sells records so well that he can even sell a record called Ionizations – they even called the album wrong – it was The Complete Works of Edgar Varèse, Volume I. And they were telling how ugly this record sounded. It was just drums and sirens and nobody would want to own this record and Sam Goody was actually selling it [2]

Or Zappa’s response from an 1981 interview in Down Beat:

How did you first find out about Edgar Varèse?

That’s a very simple story. I read an article in Look magazine in the early ’50s which was a feature saying what a great guy Sam Goody was because he was such an exciting merchandiser and he could sell anything, he could sell any kind of record. And to give an example of what a great merchandiser he was, it said that he was even able to sell an album called “Ionisation” which had a bunch of drums banging, and it described the album in very negative terms. When I read that, I thought it sounded exactly like the kind of album that I wanted to hear because I had been playing drums since I was 12. So I went looking for the album and I finally found it after a couple of months’ search, and I took it home, put it on, and I loved it as soon as I heard it. [3]

These descriptions would all be fine, except no article matching this description ever ran in Look magazine. Several Zappa scholars have suggested the likely possibility that Zappa is conflating memories of several articles. None of them offers any suggestions as to particular articles, so I’d like to point to some potential candidates I’ve found.

Look Record GuideTo begin with, the November 7, 1950 issue of Look does include a brief (and surprisingly positive) review of the record, but makes no mention of Gutowitz:

The good-things-from-obscure-places department has come up with the following finds. From EMS, the first album of a series which proposes to record the complete works of the fantastically individualistic composer Edgard Varèse. Density 21.5, Integrales, Octandre and Ionisation—a dreamy little episode for 35 percussion instruments and absolutely nothing else—are the titles. Varèse is unlike anything else in music, and well worth knowing. The recording is excellent… [4]

Duke of the Disc DealersAlthough the album is reviewed favorably here, the description of the percussion does line up with Zappa’s memory.

Another possible source comes from a feature in The Saturday Evening Post: “Duke of the Disc Dealers.” (The image to the right links to a PDF of the article.)

One Goody customer is a rare and notable exception to this buyer pattern. An old lady in her seventies, she depends on Levin [the store manager] to set aside all records with fortissimo percussion passages. ‘She loves drums, gongs, cymbals and anything that makes a loud banging noise. She has excellent hearing and is not interested in volume, as such. She just gets a particular thrill out of everything which is savage and primitive.’ [5]

This article, however, makes no mention of Varèse

How Does Goody's Do ItGreg Russo has pointed out that the February 13, 1952 issue of People Today mentions Goody’s skills as a record salesman. [7] The article makes no mention of Varèse, but Russo suggests the possibility that Zappa first read about the record in a Sam Goody catalog. Along these lines, an article from Good Housekeeping (click the image for another PDF)  confirms Goody’s  merchandising techniques:

Goody believes in aggressive advertising. He floods schools, colleges, libraries, and embassies throughout the world with direct-mail-order advertising. [6]

It seems possible that Zappa may have come across one of the catalogs distributed in this manner. (I’ve sent several emails to Goody’s son in the hope that he might have some of the catalogs, but lost contact with him over a year ago.)

I can’t even begin to tell you how sweet it would have been if I had found an article matching Zappa’s description! (Even if it wasn’t in Look magazine.) Unfortunately, it seems that for now at least the mystery remains.

References:
[1] Frank Zappa, “Edgard Varèse: Idol of my Youth,” Stereo Review 26, no. 6 (June 1971): 62. (Text here.)
[2] David Reitman, “I Dreamed I Interviewed Frank Zappa In My Maidenform Bra,” Rock Magazine 2.13 (January 25, 1971): 31. (Text here.)
[3] John Diliberto and Kimberley Haas, “Frank Zappa on Edgar Varese,” Down Beat 48, no. 11 (November 1981): 22. (Text here.)
[4] Joseph Roddy, “Look Record Guide,” Look Magazine 14 (November 7, 1950): 111.
[5] Richard Thruelsen, “Duke of the Disc Dealers,” The Saturday Evening Post 229 (October 27, 1956): 124. (PDF here.)
[6] “How Does Goody’s Do It?,” Good Housekeeping 143 (September 1956): 56. (PDF here.)
[7] Greg Russo, Cosmik Debris: The Collected History and Improvisations of Frank Zappa (Floral Park, NY: Crossfire Publications, 1999), 9.
The Idol of his Youth

46,641 thoughts on “The Idol of his Youth”

  2. stocknara

    new york yankees hat melbourne county florida new york yankees caps blue ridge north face gotham ii parka midi sage dress mitchell and ness chicago bears hat billig air jordan 13 white true red

  4. arwendaily

    iphone x en xs same dekking nike mens tyrell williams limited green jersey los angeles chargers nfl 16 salute to service tank top one shoulder plecak samsung galaxy grand 2 flip cover organic cotton mesh produce tassen apple kryt charger

  5. vlogveast

    richtige schuhe zum joggen portafoglio pinko saldi anfibi igi co 2020 jewelry promise rings samsung j6 waterproof case north face mcmurdo black

  6. jjjexx

    black the north face hat ray ban sonnenbrille fielmann celine sac c chaine graine de caf茅 plaqu茅 or homme tiffany and co ball chain necklace field tote in signature canvas with horse and carriage print

  7. getscialisgets

    light boat shoes schuhpflege leder braun personalised phone hoesje 7 plus nike ash womens travis frederick backer nfl 72 dallas cowboys pullover hoodie omg unicorn portmonetka samsung galaxy s10e pattern cover

  8. vedspace

    women’s shoes with the red bottom pandora infinite love ring pandora silver daisy ring moncler quincy nike kobe 9 high hommes tout noir asics gel lyte iii green black

  9. mygrowingpeople

    speedcross 4 gtx blau tech21 galaxy s6 hoesje nike carlos dunlap mens black limited jersey 96 nfl home cincinnati bengals baggallini plecak yellow silicone iphone xr case clear box clutch handtas

  10. codecreatorbd

    navy booties rot wing 6692 i7 phone hoesje game nike brown mens darren fells home jersey nfl 88 cleveland browns acne musubi camera torba friends tv show mobile cover

  11. dumansosyal

    cubs 38 mike montgomery whiteblue strip flexbase authentic 2017 gold program stitched mlb jersey tommy hilfiger duffle torba m臋skie huawei p smart wallet case satchel zak with shoulder strap pouzdro samsung a8 b铆l媒 blazer 拧aty with belt

  12. kqj293

    coach pink lemonade purse damen boots mit absatz save my bag lavaggio minorchine platform stone cage necklace black leather iphone 11 pro case

  13. mersiniz

    dolphins beanie hat zions nh deals nike air max 2017 all black red kobe 9 expression zamalek jersey puma womens fur hood moncler coat 47 ny giants for eu

  14. viagragerx

    five ten maltese falcon mtb spd sneaker modern damen sports iphone xr hoesje nike celtics 12 terry rozier iii green nba swingman icon edition jersey marynarka wojenna torebki for wedding minnie mouse phone case iphone 8 plus

  15. caralarma

    design your own boston red sox hat amazon r m richards high low dress coach small envelope wallet nhl jerseys ottawa senators 25 chris neil black jerseys steph curry sour patch shoes mens pandora princess wish ring rose gold

  16. piegongold

    gold bridesmaid schuhe hoesje note 8 spigen womens nike baltimore ravens 97 michael pierce game black fashion nfl jersey very radley torebki wallet case for samsung s9 heren hiking rugzak

  17. kitchendecorpad

    efest battery pouzdro rose zlato sequin bodycon 拧aty 20x beaver cowboy cappello clarks orinoco spice blue torch 3.0 road schuhe samsung galaxy s7 phone hoesje with belt clip

  18. silifkeli

    euro 2020 jerseys jersey kobe bryant 24 for cheap louboutin wedding shoes mens red bottom heels with straps adidas x 16.3 ic sky blue mens ted baker gilet

  19. karetcustom

    tiffany angel heart tag necklace pandora me unicorn new york mets floppy hat repair austin texas white folklorico dress what expensive shoes have red soles detroit pistons jonas jerebko 33 blue authentic nba jersey sale

  20. cairnsparency

    tiffany co diamond quality spigen glass iphone 11 pro nike air more money uptempo atlanta braves dog ear hat womens adidas hamburg oro and nero zx 1k boost shoes

  21. torilsdesign

    euro 2020 jerseys jersey kobe bryant 24 for cheap louboutin wedding shoes mens red bottom heels with straps adidas x 16.3 ic sky blue mens ted baker gilet

  22. rotimpex

    mens 2015 nike nfl baltimore ravens t shirts 53 nike phantom venom 2 boston red sox bobble hat viet amazon nike zoom hyperrev white purple tiffany silver ball chain best phone case ever

  23. photonaix

    apple magsafe charger case hilfiger oversized t shirt houston astros 47 mlb cooperstown 47 clean up cap lularoe jessie sizing long midi summer dress stylish white womens blouse

  24. hakaruina

    coach wallet long men forever 21 black mini dress nike control flex 4 blanc limited jah reid mens jersey kansas city chiefs 75 home red nfl merlot michael kors purse denali retro 95

  25. updetinfo

    code reduction geox 2021 hermes luxus taschen billetera burberry hombre maglia chanel nera tracolla borsa prada coque samsung a51 5g

  26. neilizur

    adidas originals red track pants vltn moncler jacket chicago bulls white hat pittsburgh pirates mlb hats mp3 download evening bloom mini dress green man utd 1977 away shirt for cheap

  27. crimsoku

    jordans 1 high grey nike roshe blanc noir tick mlb new york yankees black on black 59fifty fitted cap lyrics devondre campbell 59 jersey nike tailwings pandora pearl stud earrings

  28. sinsumbar

    legend blue low 11s dolphins trucker hat kits super cheap sunglasses red black blue nike lebron st low ii iphone 8 plus back cover transparent polo crew neck bear

  29. fatihilgen

    african wedding 拧aty with cape san francisco 49ers new era nfl salute to service 39thirty berretto fly london mes boots purple schuhe damen gr枚脽e 45 huawei mate 20 pro cute hoesje belmont bruins big tall classic primary pullover hoodie navy

  30. selenabil

    adidas absolado flutter sleeve floral maxi nike roshe run grau sole boy knit hats 4s ranch portrait dresses for sale how to find out if your coach purse is real

  31. sinkaltim

    270s trainers mcallister zach 34 jersey michael kors prism saffiano leather satchel north face vortex triclimate jordan wooly hatsping list kids nike pittsburgh steelers customized white game jersey

  33. lbxtrade

    moncler montbeliard green louis vuitton red bottom baby shoes nike new york giants 10 eli manning white color rush limited jerseys whats the shoe with the red bottom steph curry 2 usa shoes ruby jewellery pandora

  34. etuvcihazi

    nike blazer high vintage rouge chicago white sox 47 mlb firework captain cap nike running aeroloft padded gilet coach black parker backpack new balance x dime messi 17.3 cleats

  35. friedads

    270s trainers mcallister zach 34 jersey michael kors prism saffiano leather satchel north face vortex triclimate jordan wooly hatsping list kids nike pittsburgh steelers customized white game jersey

  36. poingaming

    cat girl costume child juventus zebra kit for cheap patriots home jersey color new york yankees fisherman hat 8am hardwear necklace gold game barry cofield washington redskins mens home jersey 96 nfl burgundy red

  37. costruth

    mens asics gel kinsei 5 black blue tiffany ring couple miami dolphins throwback jacket for cheap moncler jacket with fur hood womens tan san diego padres hat listing toddler hat knitting pattern with ear flaps 7.5

  38. filpchat

    kobe 9 em red white blue 2013 super bowl new nfl jerseys san francisco 49ers 7 colin kaepernick red limited jerseys dress and jacket for wedding guest pandora christmas charms 2018 womens long moncler jacket louboutin chelsea boots womens

  40. alhepsi

    black long smock dress elite kyle williams womens jersey buffalo bills 95 road white nfl ombre coach wallet north face denali fleece hoodie cincinnati reds franchise hat online cheap jersey for cheap

  42. celestebarcelona

    blaue stiefeletten paul green borsa mare con cerniera sneakers imperial michael kors drop earrings otterbox unlimited case for ipad maglia ufficiale del milan

  43. continuegame

    mike ditka womens elite green jersey nike nfl chicago bears salute to service 89 ralph lauren carrington portmonetka double mobile phone case rfid in tassen avidet pouzdro ebay flapper 拧aty

  44. bocoranhkg

    f眉脽linge gummistiefel iphone 8 shell hoesje miami marlins fernandez jersey air jordan plecak bia艂y galaxy s10 plus thin case baellerry heren portemonnee

  45. francparler

    camel chelsea boots crocband glitter clog silber redmi note 6 pro mobile back dekking nba 2k19 hardwood classic jersey adidas originals trefoil festival crossbody torba samsung galaxy j3 clear case

  47. muitotosto

    nike cowboys 83 terrance williams black mens stitched nfl limited 2016 salute to service jersey air jordan 2 svart gull pittsburgh steelers new era 2017 nfl salute to service 59fifty cap oo9014 moncler kavir jacket moncler jacket bloomingdales

  48. owlcti

    leather slides womens trachten sneaker damen iphone 8 plus protective dekking crimson tide 34 damien harris blackout limited stitched ncaa jersey colorful summer torebki led cover galaxy s9

  49. cissemosse

    nike womens react metcon coach womens small backpack nike mens revolution 5 black classic polo signature gucci snake collar shirt ray ban rx5154 tortoise

  50. sowfine

    tenis moda mujer handtasche birkin pochette in rafia mujer gafas de sol bolsos chanel aliexpress teva sandals pride

Comments are closed.